患者与外科医生在全关节置换术中的风险承担态度
该研究调查了就诊于高手术量专科医院、考虑行全关节置换术的骨关节炎患者,比较其与关节置换外科医生在一般风险承担及假设获益与并发症概率下愿意手术或推荐手术的态度。结果显示两组在一般风险承担上相似,但在较低获益概率时患者比外科医生更愿意手术,患者也更常对并发症风险持无所谓态度。
要点
- 患者与外科医生在一般、健康、职业、财务及运动休闲风险承担上相似(P > .20)。
- 获益概率降低或并发症风险升高时,愿意手术或推荐手术的比例均下降。
- 在较低获益概率时,愿意手术的患者比例高于外科医生推荐手术的比例。
核心结论
- 患者与外科医生在相似比例下愿意接受或推荐关节置换手术,但在低获益高伤害情景下两者出现分歧。
研究设计与样本
- 对就诊于高手术量专科医院、考虑行全关节置换术的患者进行问卷调查,并比较关节置换外科医生对类似问题的回答。
主要发现
- 患者应答率为82%(162/197),关节置换外科医生应答率为65%(30/46)。
- 患者平均年龄66.4岁,58%为女性;外科医生2019年平均手术量为399台。
- 两组在一般、健康、职业、财务及运动/休闲风险承担方面的回答相似(P > .20);外科医生在驾驶方面风险承担略高(P = .05)。
- 在中等改善概率70%至95%(并发症风险2%)之间,以及在中等改善概率90%至95%(并发症风险4%和6%)之间,患者愿意手术与外科医生推荐手术的比例无法区分。
- 在较低改善概率时,愿意手术的患者比例高于外科医生推荐手术的比例;患者也更常对并发症风险持无所谓态度。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Decisions regarding care for osteoarthritis involve physicians helping patients understand likely benefits and harms of treatment. Little work has directly compared patient and surgeon risk-taking attitudes, which may help inform strategies for shared decision-making and improve patient satisfaction. METHODS: We surveyed patients contemplating total joint arthroplasty visiting a high-volume specialty hospital regarding general questions about risk-taking, as well as willingness to undergo surgery under hypothetical likelihoods of moderate improvement and complications. We compared responses from surgeons answering similar questions about willingness to recommend surgery. RESULTS: Altogether 82% (162/197) of patients responded, as did 65% (30/46) of joint replacement surgeons. Mean age among patients was 66.4 years; 58% were female. Surgeons averaged 399 surgeries in 2019. Responses were similar between groups for general, health, career, financial, and sports/leisure risk-taking (P > .20); surgeons were marginally more risk-taking in driving (P = .05). For willingness to have or recommend surgery, as the chance of benefit decreased, or the chance of harm increased, the percentage willing to have or recommend surgery decreased. Between a 70% and 95% chance of moderate improvement (for a 2% complication risk), as well as between a 90% and 95% chance of moderate improvement (for 4% and 6% complication risks), the percentage willing to have or recommend surgery was indistinguishable between patients and surgeons. However, for lower likelihoods of improvement, a higher percentage of patients were willing to undergo surgery than surgeons recommended. Patients were also more often indifferent between complication risks. CONCLUSION: Although patients and surgeons were often willing to have or recommend joint replacement surgery at similar rates, they diverged for lower-benefit higher-harm scenarios.
引用
- Fontana MA, Medina CK, Kohilakis EC, et al. Patient and Surgeon Risk-Taking Regarding Total Joint Arthroplasty. J Arthroplasty. 2021. PMID: 34952164. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2021.12.021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。