弹簧撑开系统与传统生长棒治疗早发性脊柱侧凸的有限元比较
本研究采用有限元分析,建立代表传统生长棒(TGR)和弹簧撑开系统(SDS)的两个脊柱侧凸模型,模拟初始植入及长达18个月的骨骺脊柱生长。结果显示TGR在18个月随访时残留弯曲更小(16.08 vs 26.98)且T1-S1生长更高(359 mm vs 348 mm),但以椎间盘应力遮挡增加和棒断裂风险更高为代价,SDS模型的椎间盘上下表面压缩载荷更大。
要点
- TGR术后6个月撑开时棒应力增至417MPa,SDS模型6个月随访时最大应力为262MPa。
- 18个月随访时TGR模型残留弯曲16.08、T1-S1生长359 mm,SDS模型分别为26.98、348 mm。
- SDS模型椎间盘应力遮挡少于TGR,18个月时上下椎间盘表面压缩载荷分别增加112±19N和100±17N。
核心结论
- 在本有限元分析中,TGR治疗相比SDS获得了稍大的弯曲矫正,但代价是椎间盘应力遮挡增加和棒断裂风险更高。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为有限元分析(FEA),创建了两个代表性的韧带性脊柱侧凸有限元模型,一个代表传统生长棒(TGR),一个代表弹簧撑开系统(SDS)。
- 模拟了初始植入及长达18个月的骨骺脊柱生长;SDS模型在此期间持续撑开,TGR模型在指数手术后进行了两次额外撑开。
主要发现
- 术后最大von Mises应力SDS为249MPa,TGR为205MPa。
- 在6个月的TGR撑开期间,TGR棒应力增加超过两倍至最大417MPa,而SDS模型在6个月随访时最大应力为262MPa。
- 在后续随访期间,TGR棒应力持续高于SDS模型。
- 在18个月随访时,TGR模型额外延长导致残留弯曲更小(16.08)和T1-S1生长更高(359 mm),相比SDS模型(26.98,348 mm)。
- 随访期间,SDS模型的椎间盘应力遮挡少于TGR模型;18个月随访时,SDS模型椎间盘上下表面压缩载荷大于TGR对应部位(平均上部:+112 ± 19N;平均下部:+100 ± 17N)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Finite element analysis (FEA). OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to determine biomechanical differences between traditional growing rod (TGR) and spring distraction system (SDS) treatment of early-onset scoliosis. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Many "growth-friendly" implants like the TGR show high rates of implant failure, spinal stiffening, and intervertebral disc (IVD) height loss. We developed the SDS, which employs continuous, dynamic forces to mitigate these limitations. The present FEA compares TGR and SDS implantation, followed by an 18-month growth period. METHODS: Two representative, ligamentous, scoliotic FEA models were created for this study; one representing TGR and one representing SDS. initial implantation, and up to 18 months of physeal spinal growth were simulated. The SDS model was continuously distracted over this period; the TGR model included two additional distractions following index surgery. Outcomes included differences in rod stress, spinal morphology and iVD stress-shielding. RESULTS: Maximum postoperative von Mises stress was 249MPa for SDS, and 205MPa for TGR. During the 6-month TGR distraction, TGR rod stress increased over two-fold to a maximum stress of 417MPa, compared to a maximum of 262 MPa in the SDS model at 6-month follow-up. During subsequent follow-up periods, TGR rod stress remained consistently higher than stresses in the SDS model. Additional lengthenings in the TGR model led to a smaller residual curve (16.08) and higher T1-S1 growth (359 mm) at 18-month follow-up compared to the SDS model (26.98, 348 mm). During follow-up, there was less stress-shielding of the IVDs in the SDS model, compared to the TGR model. At 18-month follow-up, upper and lower IVD surfaces of the SDS model were loaded more in compression than their TGR counterparts (mean upper: +112 ± 19N; mean lower: +100 ± 17N). CONCLUSION: In the present FEA, TGR treatment resulted in slightly larger curve correction compared to SDS, at the expense of increased IVD stress-shielding and a higher risk of rod fractures. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: N/A.
引用
- Lemans JVC, Kodigudla MK, Kelkar AV, et al. Finite Element Comparison of the Spring Distraction System and the Traditional Growing Rod for the Treatment of Early Onset Scoliosis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2021. PMID: 34935758. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000004297
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。