文献速递脊柱外科小儿骨科

脊柱侧凸手术在青少年和成人脊髓脊膜膨出患者中的作用是什么?一项系统综述

What is the Role of Scoliosis Surgery in Adolescents and Adults with Myelomeningocele? A Systematic Review.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2022-01-01

本系统综述纳入13项研究、556例脊髓脊膜膨出(MMC)合并脊柱侧凸的青少年和成人患者,评估脊柱侧凸与继发损害的关系及手术对功能和生活质量的影响。结果显示合并脊柱侧凸者继发损害更常见,但现有证据不支持手术后功能或健康相关生活质量有显著改善。作者建议对此类患者的手术推荐应非常谨慎,并告知风险高、获益可能小。

要点

  • MMC合并脊柱侧凸的青少年和成人较无脊柱侧凸者更易出现膀胱/肠道失禁、行走能力下降和压力性损伤等继发损害。
  • 现有证据不支持脊柱侧凸手术后功能或健康相关生活质量有显著改善。
  • 神经功能水平、脑积水和脑干功能障碍对生活质量的决定作用大于脊柱畸形。

核心结论

  • MMC合并脊柱侧凸的青少年和成人较仅有MMC者更易发生继发损害。
  • 现有最佳证据不支持脊柱侧凸手术后功能或健康相关生活质量有显著改善。
  • 神经功能障碍水平、脑积水和脑干功能障碍是生活质量的更重要决定因素。
  • 未来需设计前瞻性研究以回答哪些MMC合并脊柱侧凸患者可从脊柱手术中获益。
  • 作者认为手术获益非常有限,外科医生对此类患者推荐手术时应非常谨慎,并告知患者及家属并发症风险高且获益可能小。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索Medline和Embase从2000年至2021年2月5日的文献,共识别1429篇出版物,最终纳入13项研究。
  • 纳入标准为报告15岁以上MMC患者脊柱侧凸的原创研究,排除非英文文献及脊柱侧凸合并MMC患者少于10例的研究。
  • 采用PRISMA规范,研究方案在数据收集前注册于PROSPERO(CRD42021236357)。
  • 采用非随机研究方法学指数(MINORS)进行质量评价,13项纳入研究中多数为回顾性病例系列,少数为回顾性/比较研究,平均MINORS评分为12.3±1.65。
  • 13项纳入研究共包含556例MMC合并脊柱侧凸患者。

主要发现

  • 研究普遍发现MMC合并脊柱侧凸者较无脊柱侧凸的MMC患者更易出现膀胱/肠道失禁、行走能力下降和压力性损伤等继发损害,这些继发损害与脑积水和高位MMC病变相关。
  • 一项评估死亡率的研究显示,尽管大多数死亡的脊柱裂患者有脊柱侧凸,但死亡年龄与脊柱侧凸之间未发现关联。
  • 评估功能结局的研究均不支持MMC患者脊柱侧凸手术后功能有显著改善。
  • 未观察到Cobb角与坐位平衡之间的相关性,但骨盆倾斜度和运动功能障碍水平与脊柱侧凸严重程度呈强相关。
  • 脊柱手术后坐位压力分布无变化,病变水平和脊柱侧凸程度独立影响肺功能损害程度。

关键数值与推荐

  • 平均MINORS评分为12.3±1.65,MINORS评分超过12分一般认为报告质量良好,低于12分认为偏倚风险高。
  • 纳入研究共556例MMC合并脊柱侧凸患者。
  • 证据等级为Level IV,治疗性研究。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为手术获益非常有限,外科医生对此类患者推荐手术时应非常谨慎。
  • 作者建议外科医生告知患者及家属并发症风险高且获益可能小。
  • 作者指出未来需设计前瞻性研究以确定哪些MMC合并脊柱侧凸患者可从脊柱手术中获益。

局限性

  • 多数纳入研究为回顾性病例系列,少数为回顾性/比较研究。
  • 平均MINORS评分为12.3±1.65,部分研究评分低于12分,被认为偏倚风险高。
  • 作者指出未来需设计前瞻性研究以回答哪些患者可从脊柱手术中获益。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Life expectancy of individuals with spina bifida has continued to improve over the past several decades. However, little is known about the longitudinal course of scoliosis in individuals with myelomeningocele (MMC), a spina bifida subtype, across their lifespan. Specifically, it is not known whether management during or after the transition years from adolescence to adulthood is associated with comorbidities in adulthood nor if these individuals benefit from scoliosis treatment later in life. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: In this systematic review, we asked: (1) Is the risk of secondary impairments (such as bladder or bowel incontinence, decreased ambulation, and skin pressure injuries) higher among adolescents and adults with MMC and scoliosis than among those with MMC without scoliosis? (2) Is there evidence that surgical management of scoliosis is associated with improved functional outcomes in adolescents and adults with MMC? (3) Is surgical management of scoliosis associated with improved quality of life in adolescents and adults with MMC? METHODS: We performed a systematic review of articles in Medline and Embase from 2000 until February 5, 2021. Search terms such as "spinal dysraphism," "spina bifida," "meningomyelocele," and "scoliosis" were applied in diverse combinations. A total of 1429 publications were identified, and 13 were eligible for inclusion. We included original studies reporting on scoliosis among individuals older than 15 years with MMC. When available, we extracted the prevalence of MMC and scoliosis, studied population age, percentage of patients experiencing complications, functional outcomes, and overall physical function. We excluded non-English articles and those with fewer than 10 individuals with scoliosis and MMC. We used the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses, and registered the review before data collection (PROSPERO: CRD42021236357). We conducted a quality assessment using the Methodologic Index for Nonrandomized Studies (MINORS) tool. In 13 included studies, there were 556 individuals with MMC and scoliosis. Most were retrospective case series, although a minority were retrospective/comparative studies. The mean MINORS score was 12.3 ± 1.65 (a MINORS score over 12 generally is considered good reporting quality, scores below 12 are considered at high risk of bias). RESULTS: In general, studies found that individuals with MMC and scoliosis were more likely to have secondary impairments such as bladder/bowel incontinence, decreased ambulation, and pressure injuries than were patients with MMC without scoliosis. These secondary impairments were associated with hydrocephalus and high-level MMC lesions. However, when one study evaluated mortality, the results showed that although most deceased individuals who had spina bifida had scoliosis, no association was found between the age of death and scoliosis. Among the studies evaluating functional outcomes, none supported strong functional improvement in individuals with MMC after surgery for scoliosis. No correlation between the Cobb angle and sitting balance was noted; however, the degree of pelvic obliquity and the level of motor dysfunction showed a strong correlation with scoliosis severity. There was no change in sitting pressure distributions after spinal surgery. The lesion level and scoliosis degree independently contributed to the degree of lung function impairment. Although studies reported success in correcting coronal deformity and stopping curve progression, they found no clear benefit of surgery on health-related quality of life and long-term outcomes. These studies demonstrated that the level of neurologic function, severity of hydrocephalus, and brainstem dysfunction are greater determinants of quality of life than spinal deformity. CONCLUSION: This systematic review found that adolescents and adults with MMC and scoliosis are more likely to have secondary impairments than their peers with MMC only. The best-available evidence does not support strong functional improvement or health-related quality of life enhancement after scoliosis surgery in adolescents and adults with MMC. The level of neurologic dysfunction, hydrocephalus, and brainstem dysfunction are greater determinants of quality of life. Future prospective studies should be designed to answer which individuals with MMC and scoliosis would benefit from spinal surgery. Our findings suggest that the very modest apparent benefits of surgery should cause surgeons to approach surgical recommendations in this patient population with great caution, and surgeons should counsel patients and their families that the risk of complications is high and the benefits may be small. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bradko V, Castillo H, Fremion E, et al. What is the Role of Scoliosis Surgery in Adolescents and Adults with Myelomeningocele? A Systematic Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 34939968. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002087

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。