Grand Seiko自动验光仪测量儿童与成人调节反应的重复性研究
这项前瞻性可靠性评估研究使用Grand Seiko自动验光仪,在33 cm处观看20/150大小字母时,测量5至<11岁弱视儿童(n=24)、非弱视儿童(n=36)及18至<35岁成人(n=34)的调节反应(AR)重测重复性。结果显示弱视眼95%一致性界限(LOA)最大(-1.25 D,1.62 D),非弱视儿童与成人双眼LOA相似且较窄;ICC表明该仪器测量AR可靠。结论认为非弱视者重复性优于弱视眼,建议弱视眼多次测量以提高精确度。
要点
- 弱视眼AR的95% LOA最宽(-1.25 D,1.62 D),重复性低于非弱视眼。
- 非弱视儿童与成人双眼的95% LOA相似且较窄,ICC提示仪器可靠。
- 建议对弱视眼进行多次AR测量以提高精确度。
核心结论
- Grand Seiko自动验光仪在非弱视儿童和成人中测量AR的重复性和可靠性优于弱视儿童弱视眼。
- 建议在弱视眼获取多次AR测量以提高精确度。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性可靠性评估研究,纳入5至<11岁弱视儿童24例、非弱视儿童36例及18至<35岁成人34例。
- 在33 cm处观看20/150大小字母时进行AR重测,采用Bland-Altman 95% LOA和ICC评估重复性与可靠性。
主要发现
- 弱视眼AR的95% LOA最宽,为-1.25 D至1.62 D。
- 弱视儿童对侧眼95% LOA为-0.88 D至0.74 D,非弱视儿童眼1为-0.68 D至0.71 D、眼2为-0.59 D至0.70 D。
- 成人眼1 95% LOA为-0.49 D至0.45 D,眼2为-0.66 D至0.67 D。
- ICC显示Grand Seiko自动验光仪是测量AR的可靠仪器。
关键数值与推荐
- 弱视眼AR的95% LOA为-1.25 D至1.62 D,对侧眼为-0.88 D至0.74 D。
- 非弱视儿童眼1 95% LOA为-0.68 D至0.71 D,眼2为-0.59 D至0.70 D。
- 成人眼1 95% LOA为-0.49 D至0.45 D,眼2为-0.66 D至0.67 D。
临床怎么用
- 临床使用Grand Seiko自动验光仪评估弱视儿童调节反应时,应进行多次测量以提高精确度。
- 非弱视儿童和成人的单次测量重复性较好,弱视眼需谨慎解读单次结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To assess test-retest repeatability of the accommodative response (AR) in children with and without amblyopia and adults using the Grand Seiko autorefractor. DESIGN: Prospective reliability assessment. METHODS: Test-retest of accommodation was obtained while participants viewed 20/150 sized letters at 33 cm using the Grand Seiko autorefractor in children 5 to <11 years with amblyopia (n=24) and without amblyopia (n=36), and adults 18 to <35 years (n=34). Bland-Altman 95% limits of agreement (LOA) and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were used to assess repeatability and reliability. The AR between the fellow and amblyopic eyes of children with amblyopia and eye 1 and eye 2 of the visually normal participants was assessed using group comparisons. RESULTS: The 95% LOA of the AR was greatest in the amblyopic eyes (-1.25 diopters [D], 1.62 D) of children with amblyopia. The 95% LOA were similar between the fellow eyes (-0.88 D, 0.74 D) of children with amblyopia and both eyes of the children without amblyopia (eye 1: -0.68 D, 0.71 D; eye 2: -0.59 D, 0.70 D) and the adults (eye 1: 95% LOA = -0.49 D, 0.45 D; eye 2: LOA = -0.66 D, 0.67 D). ICCs revealed the Grand Seiko autorefractor as a reliable instrument for measuring AR. CONCLUSIONS: The Grand Seiko autorefractor was more repeatable and reliable when measuring the AR in children and adults without amblyopia than in the amblyopic eye in children with amblyopia. It is recommended that multiple measures of the AR be obtained in amblyopic eyes to improve the precision of measures.
引用
- Chinn RN, Raghuram A, Curtiss MK, et al. Repeatability of the Accommodative Response Measured by the Grand Seiko Autorefractor in Children With and Without Amblyopia and Adults. Am J Ophthalmol. 2021. PMID: 34699740. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2021.10.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。