可调节缝线在斜视治疗中的应用:美国眼科学会报告
本报告综述了评估可调节缝线在成人及儿童斜视治疗中有效性的科学文献。检索PubMed至2021年4月,共17篇文章符合纳入标准(11篇II级证据,6篇III级证据),无I级研究。多数非随机研究报告可调节缝线技术在运动对齐结果上优于非可调节技术,但该发现并非在所有研究中一致。
要点
- 无I级证据评估可调节缝线在斜视手术中的有效性。
- 多数非随机研究报告可调节缝线组运动对齐成功率更高。
- 再手术率在可调节缝线组较低,但并非所有研究一致。
核心结论
- 尽管无I级研究,多数符合纳入标准的非随机研究报告可调节缝线技术在运动对齐结果上优于非可调节技术。
- 该优势并非在所有综述研究中一致显示,需进一步研究可调节缝线技术的发展与分析。
研究设计与样本
- 文献检索PubMed数据库至2021年4月,无日期限制,限英文出版物。
- 检索到551篇相关文献,55篇全文审阅,17篇符合纳入标准并由方法学家评定证据等级。
- 纳入所有随机对照研究(不论样本量)及样本量≥100例比较可调节与非可调节缝线技术的队列研究。
主要发现
- 17篇纳入文章中,11篇为II级证据,6篇为III级证据,无I级研究。
- 12项关注运动对齐结果的研究中,4项小型随机临床试验未发现组间统计学显著差异,但仅能检测非常大的差异。
- 8项非随机研究中7项发现可调节缝线技术在运动对齐成功率上具有统计学显著优势,总体及某些亚组均如此。
- 运动对齐成功见于外斜视(3项不限于儿童的研究)和内斜视(1项成人研究及2项儿童研究)。
- 多数报告再手术率的研究发现可调节缝线组再手术率较低,但该发现并非一致。
临床怎么用
- 对于成人及儿童斜视患者,可考虑使用可调节缝线技术以改善运动对齐结果。
- 需注意证据主要来自非随机研究,随机对照试验未显示显著差异,临床决策应结合个体情况。
局限性
- 无I级证据,随机对照试验样本量小且仅能检测非常大的差异。
- 多数支持可调节缝线的证据来自非随机研究,存在选择偏倚等局限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To review the scientific literature that evaluates the effectiveness of adjustable sutures in the management of strabismus for adult and pediatric patients. METHODS: Literature searches were performed in the PubMed database through April 2021 with no date limitations and were restricted to publications in English. The searches identified 551 relevant citations, of which 55 were reviewed in full text. Of these, 17 articles met the inclusion criteria and were assigned a level of evidence rating by the panel methodologist. The search included all randomized controlled studies regardless of study size and cohort studies of 100 or more patients comparing the adjustable versus nonadjustable suture technique, with a focus on motor alignment outcomes or reoperation rates. RESULTS: The literature search yielded no level I studies. Of the 17 articles that met the inclusion criteria, 11 were rated level II and 6 were rated level III. Among the 12 studies that focused on motor alignment outcomes, 4 small randomized clinical trials (RCTs) did not find a statistically significant difference between groups, although they were powered to detect only very large differences. Seven of 8 nonrandomized studies found a statistically significant difference in motor alignment success in favor of the adjustable suture technique, both overall and in certain subgroups of patients. Successful motor alignment was seen in both exotropia (in 3 studies that were not limited to children) and esotropia (in 1 study of adults and 2 of children). The majority of included studies that reported on reoperation rates found the rates to be lower in patients who underwent strabismus surgery with adjustable sutures, but this finding was not uniformly demonstrated. CONCLUSIONS: Although there are no level I studies evaluating the effectiveness of adjustable sutures for strabismus surgery, the majority of nonrandomized studies that met the inclusion criteria for this assessment reported an advantage of the adjustable suture technique over the nonadjustable technique with respect to motor alignment outcomes. This finding was not uniformly demonstrated among all studies reviewed and warrants further investigation in the development and analysis of adjustable suture techniques.
引用
- Heidary G, Aakalu VK, Binenbaum G, et al. Adjustable Sutures in the Treatment of Strabismus: A Report by the American Academy of Ophthalmology. Ophthalmology. 2021. PMID: 34446304. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2021.07.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。