基于IOLMaster 700的六种人工晶状体屈光度计算公式准确性比较
回顾性纳入599例(599眼)白内障术前IOLMaster 700检查患者,比较6种公式的绝对预测误差中位数。Barrett Universal Ⅱ整体表现最佳(0.35 D),短眼轴和长眼轴及不同前房深度组均最低;Haigis在角膜屈光力≤42.00 D或≥46.00 D时更准确。
要点
- Barrett Universal Ⅱ在整体、短眼轴、长眼轴及不同前房深度组MedAE最低。
- SRK/T在正常眼轴组MedAE最低(0.35 D)。
- Haigis在角膜屈光力≤42.00 D或≥46.00 D时MedAE最低。
核心结论
- Barrett Universal Ⅱ公式整体预测性最佳,Haigis与SRK/T次之。
- Barrett Universal Ⅱ在短眼轴、长眼轴及不同前房深度组预测误差最低。
- Haigis公式在角膜屈光力≤42.00 D或≥46.00 D时可能更准确。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性系列病例研究,纳入599例(599眼)于温州医科大学附属眼视光医院接受白内障术前IOLMaster 700检查的患者。
- 按眼轴长度、平均角膜屈光力及前房深度分组,采用Friedman检验比较6种公式的绝对预测误差中位数(MedAE)。
主要发现
- 整体6公式MedAE差异有统计学意义(χ²=120.549,P<0.001),Barrett Universal Ⅱ最小(0.35 D),SRK/T次之(0.36 D)。
- Barrett Universal Ⅱ与Haigis、SRK/T两两比较差异无统计学意义(均P=1.000),其余公式间差异均有统计学意义(均P<0.01)。
- 短眼轴组Barrett Universal Ⅱ的MedAE为0.40 D,长眼轴组为0.31 D,均为最低;正常眼轴组SRK/T最低(0.35 D)。
- 平坦角膜屈光力组Haigis的MedAE为0.26 D,陡峭组为0.34 D,均为最低;正常组Barrett Universal Ⅱ最低(0.33 D)。
- 不同前房深度组Barrett Universal Ⅱ的MedAE均最低,分别为0.46、0.33、0.31 D。
关键数值与推荐
- 短眼轴组:眼轴长度≤22.5 mm(100眼);正常眼轴组:>22.5 mm且<25.5 mm(375眼);长眼轴组:≥25.5 mm(124眼)。
- 平坦角膜屈光力组:≤42.00 D(47眼);正常组:>42.00 D且<46.00 D(461眼);陡峭组:≥46.00 D(91眼)。
- 浅前房组:前房深度≤2.5 mm(71眼);正常前房组:>2.5 mm且<3.5 mm(436眼);深前房组:≥3.5 mm(92眼)。
临床怎么用
- 临床可优先选用Barrett Universal Ⅱ公式,尤其在短眼轴、长眼轴及不同前房深度患者中。
- 正常眼轴患者可考虑SRK/T公式,其MedAE最低。
- 角膜屈光力≤42.00 D或≥46.00 D时,可考虑选用Haigis公式以提高准确性。
局限性
- 本文为回顾性研究,未报告随机化或盲法设计。
- 样本来自单中心,外推性需进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To compare the accuracy of 6 intraocular lens power calculation formulas based on the new swept-source optical coherence tomography biometry and to analyze the prediction error. Methods: Retrospective case series study. Clinical data were collected from 599 patients (599 eyes) who had underwent uncomplicated phacoemulsification and the IOLMaster 700 examination at the Eye Hospital of Wenzhou Medical University between November 2018 and November 2019. Among the patients, there were 208 males and 391 females with an age of (69±10) years. According to the axial length (AL), eyes were divided into the short AL group (≤22.5 mm, n=100), the normal AL group (>22.5 mm and<25.5 mm, n=375); and the long AL group (≥25.5 mm, n=124). Eyes were also grouped based on the mean keratometry (Km) as flat (≤42.00 D, n=47), normal (>42.00 D to<46.00 D, n=461), and steep (≥46.00 D, n=91), and by anterior chamber depth (ACD) as shallow (≤2.5 mm, n=71), normal (>2.5 mm to<3.5 mm, n=436), and deep (≥3.5 mm, n=92). The median absolute errors (MedAEs) of the Barrett Universal Ⅱ, Haigis, Hoffer Q, Holladay Ⅰ, Holladay Ⅱ, and SRK/T formulas in different AL, Km, and ACD groups were compared using the Friedman test. Results: The differences in MedAE among the 6 formulas of 599 patients (599 eyes) were statistically significant (χ²=120.549, P<0.001). The MedAE of the Barrett Universal Ⅱ formula was smallest (0.35 D), followed by the SRK/T formula (0.36 D). There was no significant difference between the MedAEs of the Barrett universal Ⅱ and Haigis, SRK/T formula (all P=1.000), but there were statistically significant differences among the other formulas (all P<0.01). In different AL groups, the MedAE of each formula was statistically different (χ²=38.307, 38.779, 112.997; all P<0.01).The Barrett Universal Ⅱ formula resulted in the lowest MedAE in the short AL group (0.40 D) and the long AL group (0.31 D). The MedAE of the SRK/T in the normal AL group was lowest (0.35 D). The 6 formulas showed significant differences in MedAE values in different Km groups (χ²=12.284, 90.924, 39.387; all P<0.05).The Haigis formula achieved the lowest MedAE in the flat Km group (0.26 D) and the steep Km group (0.34 D). The Barrett UniversalⅡ formula achieved the lowest MedAE in the normal Km group (0.33 D). The differences in MedAE values of the 6 formulas in different ACD groups were statistically significant (χ²=37.389, 57.643, 52.845; all P<0.01), and the MedAE values of the Barrett Universal Ⅱ in different ACD groups were smallest (0.46, 0.33, 0.31 D). Conclusions: The Barrett Universal Ⅱ formula perform the best over the entire AL range, followed by the Haigis and SRK/T formulas. The Barrett Universal Ⅱ formula result in the lowest prediction error in the short AL group, the long AL group, and all ACD groups. The Haigis formula may be more accurate when the Km was ≤42.00 D or ≥46.00 D. (Chin J Ophthalmol, 2021, 57: 502-511). 目的: 比较基于IOLMaster 700新型扫频光学生物测量仪的6个人工晶状体(IOL)屈光度数计算公式的准确性。 方法: 回顾性系列病例研究。收集2018年11月至2019年11月在温州医科大学附属眼视光医院杭州院区接受白内障摘除手术前曾行IOLMaster 700检查的白内障患者599例(599只眼)临床资料,其中男性208例,女性391例,年龄(69±10)岁。根据眼轴长度分为短眼轴组(≤22.5 mm,100只眼)、正常眼轴组(>22.5 mm且<25.5 mm,375只眼)及长眼轴组(≥25.5 mm,124只眼);根据角膜屈光力分为平坦组(≤42.00 D,47只眼)、正常组(>42.00 D且<46.00 D,461只眼)及陡峭组(≥46.00 D,91只眼);根据前房深度分为浅前房组(≤2.5 mm,71只眼)、正常前房组(>2.5 mm且<3.5 mm,436只眼)、深前房组(≥3.5 mm,92只眼)。比较整体及不同分组间Barrett Universal Ⅱ、Haigis、Hoffer Q、Holladay Ⅰ、Holladay Ⅱ和SRK/T公式计算的IOL屈光度数绝对预测误差中位数(MedAE)的差异。统计学分析主要采用Friedman检验。 结果: 599例患者(599只眼)6个公式间IOL屈光度数MedAE值差异有统计学意义(χ²=120.549,P<0.001),Barrett Universal Ⅱ公式的MedAE值最小(0.35 D),SRK/T公式次之(0.36 D),进一步两两比较显示除Barrett Universal Ⅱ与Haigis、SRK/T公式比较差异无统计学意义外(均P=1.000),其余两公式间比较差异均有统计学意义(均P<0.01)。不同眼轴分组中,6个公式间IOL屈光度数MedAE值差异均有统计学意义(χ²=38.307,38.779,112.997;均P<0.01),Barrett Universal Ⅱ公式在短眼轴组及长眼轴组中MedAE值均最小,分别为0.40、0.31 D,SRK/T公式在正常眼轴组中MedAE值最小(0.35 D)。不同角膜屈光力分组中,6个公式间IOL屈光度数MedAE值差异均有统计学意义(χ²=12.284,90.924,39.387;均P<0.05),Haigis公式在平坦组及陡峭组中的MedAE值最小,分别为0.26、0.34 D,Barrett Universal Ⅱ公式在正常组中的MedAE值最小(0.33 D)。不同前房深度分组中,6个公式间IOL的MedAE值差异均有统计学意义(χ²=37.389,57.643,52.845;均P<0.01),Barrett Universal Ⅱ公式在前房深度各分组中的MedAE值均最小,分别为0.46、0.33、0.31 D。 结论: 基于IOLMaster 700扫频光学生物测量仪,6个IOL屈光度数计算公式中Barrett Universal Ⅱ公式预测性最佳,尤其对于短眼轴、长眼轴及不同前房深度患者预测误差值低;Haigis、SRK/T公式次之。当角膜屈光力≤42.00 D或≥46.00 D时,Haigis公式可能更为准确。(中华眼科杂志,2021,57:502-511).
引用
- Deng XH, Chang PJ, Huang JH, et al. [Comparison of the accuracy of intraocular lens power calculation formulas based on the new swept-source optical coherence tomography biometry]. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2021. PMID: 34256470. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112142-20200729-00511
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。