晶状体拱高对浅前房眼人工晶状体计算公式准确性的影响
本回顾性病例系列纳入409只术前前房深度小于3.0 mm的行超声乳化术眼,按眼轴分为短眼轴组(<22.00 mm)与正常眼轴组(22.00≤AL<24.50 mm),再按术前晶状体拱高(LV)中位数0.95 mm分为小LV与大LV亚组,比较7种人工晶状体计算公式的屈光预测误差。结论:大LV眼中Haigis与Hoffer QST公式误差反而更大,而同时纳入前房深度与晶状体厚度的Barrett与Kane公式在各亚组均表现良好。
要点
- 短眼轴与正常眼轴组中Barrett和Kane公式的平均绝对误差最小。
- 大LV亚组中Haigis公式误差显著增大,其次为Hoffer QST。
- 除Barrett与Kane外,各公式预测误差随LV增大呈术后远视漂移。
核心结论
- 在浅前房眼中,大LV时Haigis与Hoffer QST公式预测误差更大,而纳入前房深度与晶状体厚度的Barrett与Kane公式在小LV和大LV亚组均保持良好准确性。
- 选择人工晶状体计算公式时,除术前前房深度外,晶状体拱高也值得考虑。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性病例系列,共纳入409只前房深度浅于3.0 mm且行超声乳化的眼。
- 按眼轴分短眼轴组(<22.00 mm)与正常眼轴组(22.00≤AL<24.50 mm),各组再按术前LV中位数0.95 mm分为小LV(<0.95 mm)与大LV(≥0.95 mm)亚组。
- 术后3个月测量屈光,计算并比较各公式的平均绝对误差(MAE),并分析LV与各公式平均数值误差的相关性。
主要发现
- 整体上Barrett与Kane公式在短眼轴组和正常眼轴组产生的MAE均最小(P<.05)。
- 短眼轴小LV眼中Haigis公式优于其他传统公式(P<.05);正常眼轴小LV眼中Barrett与Kane准确性更高(P<.05),其他公式相近。
- 大LV亚组中Haigis公式MAE显著更高(P<.001),其次为Hoffer QST。
- 除Barrett与Kane公式外,各公式预测的平均数值误差与LV呈正相关(P<.001),提示LV增大时出现术后远视漂移。
关键数值与推荐
- 分组阈值:前房深度<3.0 mm;短眼轴<22.00 mm;正常眼轴22.00≤AL<24.50 mm;LV亚组以0.95 mm为界。
- 屈光结局测量时间为术后3个月,主要比较指标为MAE。
- 大LV亚组中Haigis公式MAE显著更高(P<.001),其次为Hoffer QST。
临床怎么用
- 浅前房且LV较大的眼,选用公式时应警惕Haigis与Hoffer QST预测误差偏大。
- Barrett与Kane公式因同时纳入前房深度与晶状体厚度,在LV大小不同的浅前房眼中均显示良好准确性,可作为优先选择参考。
局限性
- 原文未报告研究局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To explore the impact of preoperative lens vault (LV) on the accuracy of the Barrett Universal Ⅱ, Haigis, Hoffer Q, Hoffer QST, Holladay 1, Kane, and SRK/T formulas in eyes with a shallow anterior chamber. DESIGN: Retrospective case series. METHODS: Included were 409 eyes with anterior chamber depth (ACD) shallower than 3.0 mm that underwent phacoemulsification. Eyes were divided into a short axial length (AL) group (<22.00 mm) and a normal AL group (22.00 ≤ AL < 24.50 mm). Each group was further divided into a small LV subgroup (LV <0.95 mm) and a large LV subgroup (LV ≥0.95 mm) according to the median of the preoperative LV. Postoperative refraction was measured 3 months after surgery. Mean absolute error (MAE) was calculated and compared for each formula. The correlation between LV and the mean numeric error predicted by each formula was analyzed. RESULTS: Overall, the Barrett and Kane formulas generated the smallest MAE in both short AL and normal AL groups (P < .05 for both). In short AL eyes with small LV, the Haigis formula performed better than other traditional formulas (P < .05 for all). In normal AL eyes with a small LV, the Barrett and Kane formulas showed higher accuracy (P < .05 for all), and other formulas were comparable. In either subgroup with a large LV, the Haigis formula created a significant higher MAE (P < .001 for all), followed by Hoffer QST. Positive correlations were found between LV and mean numeric errors predicted by all formulas, except for Barrett and Kane formulas (P < .001 for all), indicating a postoperative hyperopic shift with an increased LV. CONCLUSIONS: In shallow anterior chamber eyes with a large LV, the Haigis and Hoffer QST formulas taking preoperative ACD into calculation surprisingly showed a larger prediction error. However, the Barrett and the Kane formulas, which include both ACD and lens thickness as predictive parameters, showed good accuracy in both small and large LV subgroups. Therefore, although formulas referring to preoperative ACD are generally believed to achieve better refractive results in patients with a shallow anterior chamber, LV may be valuable to consider when choosing an IOL power calculation formula.
引用
- Yan C, Yao K. Effect of Lens Vault on the Accuracy of Intraocular Lens Calculation Formulas in Shallow Anterior Chamber Eyes. Am J Ophthalmol. 2021. PMID: 34293335. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2021.07.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。