青光眼手术术后并发症报告标准化建议
该研究基于既往系统综述(CRD42019121226)中青光眼手术试验的并发症名称、定义和时间框架,由评审员独立推荐应纳入的并发症清单,最终从报告并发症中识别出48/111(43.2%)适合纳入,合并后形成32项术后并发症的最终表格,旨在简化报告流程并提高手术试验间的一致性。
要点
- 从111项报告并发症中识别48项(43.2%)适合纳入,合并后形成32项术后并发症清单。
- 25项并发症沿用系统综述中的名称但补充了新定义,5项名称和定义均为新提出,1项保留原名称和定义。
- 16项并发症为既往综述中所有手术方式所共有。
核心结论
- 提出一份修订名称和综合定义的术后并发症表格,以简化青光眼手术后并发症报告流程并提高手术试验间一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 基于既往青光眼手术试验系统综述(注册号CRD42019121226)的文献综述,由评审员独立推荐并发症纳入或排除,并以文献为基础的「手术并发症」定义指导决策,分歧通过共识驱动流程解决。
主要发现
- 从报告并发症中识别48/111(43.2%)适合纳入,其中17项合并入其他含义更广的纳入并发症,最终形成32项术后并发症表格。
- 25项并发症沿用系统综述中的名称但提供了原文未提及的定义,5项并发症的名称和定义均为原文未提及,1项并发症保留原名称和定义。
- 16项并发症为既往综述中所有手术方式所共有。
关键数值与推荐
- 48/111(43.2%)的报告并发症被识别为适合纳入。
- 17项纳入并发症被合并入其他含义更广的纳入并发症,最终表格包含32项术后并发症。
- 25项并发症沿用原名称但定义未在原文提及,5项并发症名称和定义均未在原文提及,1项并发症保留原名称和定义。
- 16项并发症为所有检索到的手术方式所共有。
临床怎么用
- 未来青光眼手术研究和报告可采用该32项术后并发症表格及其修订名称与定义,以统一并发症报告。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To recommend a list of complications of glaucoma surgery to be used in future glaucoma surgery research and reporting by exploring the spectrum of complications' names, the variety of definitions and time frames used for reporting them in glaucoma surgical trials. METHODS: Complications' names, definitions and time frames identified from a previously conducted systematic review of glaucoma surgery trials (registration number: CRD42019121226) were reviewed. Only postoperative complications were considered. Surgical techniques described in the papers from the previous systematic review were retrieved and grouped according their mechanism of action.Reviewers independently recommended each complication's inclusion or exclusion in a list to be proposed as a potential standard for reporting in glaucoma interventions. A literature-based definition of a 'surgical complication' was used to inform these decisions. Recorded complication's details were used to inform the development of clinically relevant definitions, a consensus-driven exercise between reviewers resolved disagreements. RESULTS: We identified 48/111 (43.2%) of the reported complications as suitable for inclusion, of which 17 were merged into other included complications having a broader meaning making up a final table of 32 postoperative complications. For 25 of them, the authors kept 'names' that were previously used in the systematic review, but provided a definition that was not mentioned in these papers. Five included complications were given both 'names' and definitions not previously mentioned. The authors maintained the name and definition for one complication. There were 16 complications that were in common to all the procedures retrieved from the previous review. CONCLUSIONS: We propose a table of revised names and comprehensive definitions of postoperative complications, to simplify the process of reporting complications after glaucoma surgery and to improve consistency among surgical trials.
引用
- Stringa F, Kastner A, Heuer D, et al. Postoperative complications in glaucoma surgery: literature review-based recommendations to improve reporting consistency. Br J Ophthalmol. 2021. PMID: 34162534. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2021-318952
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。