文献速递白内障与屈光手术

白内障治疗系统综述摘要中的「夸大表述」评估

Evaluation of spin in the abstracts of systematic reviews and meta-analyses focused on cataract therapies.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Ophthalmol · 2021-04-03

该横断面研究检索 MEDLINE 与 Embase 中与白内障治疗相关的系统综述和荟萃分析,最终纳入 110 篇,采用既往建立的分类系统评估 9 种最严重形式的夸大表述(spin),并由两人重复提取数据、以 AMSTAR-2 量表评价方法学质量。结果显示 30.0%(33/110)的纳入系统综述存在至少 1 种形式的夸大表述,最常见为类型 3(18.2%,20/110),且夸大表述与 AMSTAR-2 评价及所提取的研究特征均无显著关联。

要点

  • 约三成白内障治疗相关系统综述摘要存在至少 1 种形式的夸大表述。
  • 最常见的夸大表述为类型 3,占 18.2%(20/110)。
  • 夸大表述与 AMSTAR-2 方法学质量评价及研究特征无显著关联。

核心结论

  • 在评估的白内障手术及其并发症相关系统综述与荟萃分析中,约三分之一的摘要存在夸大表述。
  • 夸大表述与 AMSTAR-2 评价及所提取的研究特征之间未发现显著关联。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面研究,检索 MEDLINE 和 Embase 中与白内障治疗相关的系统综述与荟萃分析。
  • 检索共获得 2059 条记录,其中 110 篇符合纳入标准并完成数据提取。
  • 采用既往建立的分类系统评估 9 种最严重形式的夸大表述,由两人重复评估并以 16 个问题的 AMSTAR-2 量表评价方法学质量。

主要发现

  • 30.0%(33/110)的纳入系统综述存在至少 1 种形式的夸大表述。
  • 9 种夸大表述类型中,样本内识别出 6 种,最常见为类型 3,占摘要的 18.2%(20/110)。
  • 摘要中的夸大表述与 AMSTAR-2 评价及任何所提取的研究特征均无显著关联。

关键数值与推荐

  • 夸大表述判定采用既往建立的分类系统,聚焦 9 种最严重形式。
  • 方法学质量评价采用 16 个问题的 AMSTAR-2 量表。

临床怎么用

  • 阅读白内障相关系统综述摘要时,应警惕约三成摘要可能存在夸大表述而影响疗效判断。
  • 不能仅凭 AMSTAR-2 方法学质量评价高低来推断摘要是否存在夸大表述。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Spin-the misrepresentation of study findings such that the beneficial effects of an intervention are magnified beyond what the results actually show-is a reporting practice that has been shown to influence perceptions of treatment efficacy and clinical decision making. We evaluated the extent of spin in the abstracts of systematic reviews of cataract surgery and its complications. We also evaluated whether particular study attributes were associated with spin. DESIGN: Cross-sectional study. METHODS: We searched MEDLINE and Embase for systematic reviews and meta-analyses relating to cataract treatment. From these search records, screening for eligible studies was done in duplicate. Using a previously developed classification system for spin, we assessed the systematic reviews that met our eligibility criteria for the occurrence of the 9 most severe forms of spin. We performed the evaluation of spin, extracted study characteristics, and appraised the methodological quality of each study using the 16-question AMSTAR-2 scale in duplicate. RESULTS: Searches retrieved 2,059 studies, of which 110 were eligible for data extraction. We found at least 1 form of spin in 30.0% of included systematic reviews (33/110). Six of the 9 types of spin were identified in our sample, the most common being type 3 in 18.2% (20/110) of abstracts. We found no significant association between spin in abstracts, AMSTAR-2 appraisal, and any of the extracted study characteristics. CONCLUSION: Spin was evident in approximately one-third of the abstracts of evaluated systematic reviews and meta-analyses of cataract surgery and associated complications.

来源:Am J Ophthalmol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Demla S, Shinn E, Ottwell R, et al. Evaluation of spin in the abstracts of systematic reviews and meta-analyses focused on cataract therapies. Am J Ophthalmol. 2021. PMID: 33823157. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2021.03.032

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。