同一威胁,不同应对:COVID-19 大流行对欧洲角膜捐献与供体选择的影响
该调查研究覆盖26个欧洲国家110家眼库中的64家(占欧洲角膜移植活动95%),比较2018至2020年2–5月角膜获取与分配数量。2020年3、4、5月获取量分别较前两年均值下降38%、68%、41%,移植量分别下降28%、68%、56%,三个月对应3866例未治疗患者。各国供体筛选严格程度差异显著,活动下降与筛选严格度相关且独立于疫情严重程度。
要点
- 2020年3–5月角膜获取量较前两年均值下降38%、68%、41%。
- 同期移植量下降28%、68%、56%,三个月对应3866例未治疗患者。
- 各国供体筛选算法差异显著,活动下降与筛选严格度独立于疫情严重程度相关。
核心结论
- 各国基于预防原则的供体筛查算法存在显著差异,导致本已受大量禁忌证限制的供体池进一步缩小。
- 需开展基础研究明确角膜移植传播SARS-CoV-2的风险,以指导循证供体选择推荐并论证其医学与经济影响。
研究设计与样本
- 调查研究,覆盖26个欧洲国家110家眼库中的64家,占欧洲角膜移植活动95%。
- 向眼库发放问卷,收集2018–2020年2–5月获取和分配的角膜数量。
- 主要结局为角膜获取数量,次要结局为各国供体选择算法严格程度及各国疫情严重程度。
- 采用Spearman相关系数两两分析三个月眼库活动下降、供体选择算法严格度与疫情严重程度的关系,并以偏相关控制疫情严重程度。
主要发现
- 2020年3、4、5月角膜获取量分别较前两年均值下降38%、68%、41%。
- 同期移植量分别下降28%、68%、56%,三个月对应3866例未治疗患者。
- 国家间存在显著差异,活动下降与供体选择严格度相关且独立于疫情严重程度。
关键数值与推荐
- 供体选择算法按严格程度分类,涉及有COVID-19病史、疑似COVID-19、无症状及PCR检测的供体。
- 以Spearman相关系数两两分析三个月眼库活动下降、供体选择算法严格度与疫情严重程度的关系。
- 以偏相关分析控制疫情严重程度后活动下降与严格度的关系。
临床怎么用
- 眼库与移植中心应关注供体筛查算法严格度对供体池和移植可及性的影响。
- 在疫情等新发传染病威胁下,需平衡预防原则与循证供体选择,减少不必要的供体排除。
局限性
- 原文未报告调查问卷回收率以外的样本代表性限制。
- 原文未报告PCR检测策略等具体算法细节对结果的影响。
- 原文未报告角膜移植传播SARS-CoV-2风险的直接证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess to which extent the COVID-19 pandemic affected corneal transplantation by virtue of donor selection algorithms in different European countries. DESIGN: Survey. SETTING: 110 eye banks in 26 European countries. PARTICIPANTS: 64 eye banks covering 95% of European corneal transplantation activity. INTERVENTIONS: A questionnaire listing the number of corneas procured and distributed from February to May 2018-2020 was circulated to eye banks. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome was the number of corneal procurements. Additional outcomes were national algorithms for donor selection, classified according to their stringency (donors with COVID-19 history, suspected for COVID-19, asymptomatic, PCR testing) and the pandemic severity in each country. We calculated Spearman's correlation coefficient to determine, two by two, the relationship between the 3-month decline in eye banking activity (procurement), the stringency of donor selection algorithm and the grading of pandemic severity (cases and deaths). A partial correlation was run to determine the relationship between decline and stringency while controlling for pandemic severity. RESULTS: Procurements decreased by 38%, 68% and 41%, respectively, in March, April and May 2020 compared with the mean of the previous 2 years, while grafts decreased, respectively, by 28%, 68% and 56% corresponding to 3866 untreated patients in 3 months. Significant disparities between countries and the decrease in activity correlated with stringency in donor selection independent of pandemic severity. CONCLUSIONS: Our data demonstrate significant differences between countries regarding donor screening algorithms based on precautionary principles and, consequently, a decrease in the donor pool, already constrained by a long list of contraindications. Fundamental studies are needed to determine the risk of SARS-CoV-2 transmission by corneal transplantation and guide evidence-based recommendations for donor selection to justify their substantial medical and economic impact.
引用
- Thuret G, Courrier E, Poinard S, et al. One threat, different answers: the impact of COVID-19 pandemic on cornea donation and donor selection across Europe. Br J Ophthalmol. 2020. PMID: 33243832. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2020-317938
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。