PCR与培养诊断棘阿米巴角膜炎的前瞻性比较研究
该前瞻性研究纳入1217份疑似棘阿米巴角膜炎的角膜刮片样本,比较五种PCR assay与培养的诊断性能。潜伏类别分析显示AK估计患病率为1.32%,各PCR敏感性73.3%至86.7%与培养66.7%无显著差异,联合两或三种assay可将敏感性提高至93.8%或100%,T4为优势基因型(84.6%)。
要点
- 单一PCR或培养均可能漏诊AK,联合两或三种PCR assay可提高敏感性至93.8%或100%。
- 各PCR assay敏感性73.3%至86.7%,与培养66.7%无显著差异。
- PCR特异性99.3%至100%因assay而异,T4为优势基因型(84.6%)。
核心结论
- 培养和单一PCR assay均可能导致棘阿米巴角膜炎漏诊。
- 联合不同PCR assay并改善样本质量可提高诊断敏感性。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入1217份疑似AK患者的角膜刮片样本,同时进行分子诊断与培养。
- 采用五种PCR assay:三种终点PCR(Nelson、ACARNA、JDP1-JDP2引物对)和两种实时PCR(Acant引物探针),实时PCR共扩增人DNA和内参。
- 无金标准情况下采用潜伏类别分析评估各检测性能,并对分离株进行基因型鉴定。
主要发现
- AK估计患病率为1.32%。
- Acanthamoeba诊断PCR敏感性为73.3%至86.7%,与培养66.7%无显著差异,亦不因靶序列或技术不同而异。
- 联合两种或三种assay可将敏感性分别提高至93.8%或100%。
- PCR特异性为99.3%至100%,各assay间存在差异。
- T4为优势Acanthamoeba基因型(84.6%)。
临床怎么用
- 临床怀疑AK时不宜仅依赖培养或单一PCR assay,应考虑联合多种PCR assay以提高诊断敏感性。
- 需重视角膜刮片样本质量,实时PCR中人DNA和内参共扩增有助于确保样本质量及排除抑制物。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND/AIMS: Acanthamoeba keratitis (AK) is a rare but sight-threatening infection. Molecular diagnosis of corneal scraping has improved the diagnosis of AK. Different molecular targets and conditions have been used in diagnosis thus far. In this study, we prospectively compared the performance of five PCR assays on corneal samples for the diagnosis of AK. METHODS: 1217 corneal scraping samples were obtained from patients, for whom an AK was suspected. Sample processing involved both molecular diagnostics and culture. Acanthamoeba PCR assays detected different regions of the Acanthamoeba nuclear small-subunit rRNA gene: three final point PCR assays using Nelson, ACARNA and JDP1-JDP2 pairs of primers, and two real-time PCR assays using Acant primer-probe. Human DNA and internal control were co-amplified in the real-time PCR assay to ensure scraping quality and the absence of inhibitors. In the absence of a gold standard, the performance of each test was evaluated using latent class analysis. Genotypes of Acanthamoeba isolates were also characterised. RESULTS: Estimated prevalence of AK was 1.32%. The sensitivity of Acanthamoeba diagnostic PCRs (73.3% to 86.7%) did not differ significantly from that of culture (66.7%), or according to the target sequence or the technology. Sensitivity could be increased to 93.8% or 100% by combining two or three assays, respectively. PCR specificity (99.3% to 100%) differed between the assays. T4 was the predominant Acanthamoeba genotype (84.6%). CONCLUSIONS: Culture and a single PCR assay could lead to misdiagnosing AK. A combination of different PCR assays and improved sample quality could increase diagnosis sensitivity.
引用
- Yera H, Ok V, Lee Koy Kuet F, et al. PCR and culture for diagnosis of Acanthamoeba keratitis. Br J Ophthalmol. 2020. PMID: 33099504. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2020-316730
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。