基于眼轴长度与角膜屈光力范围评估611眼人工晶状体公式准确性
该研究回顾性分析611只白内障手术眼,按眼轴长度和角膜屈光力分组,比较Haigis、Hoffer Q、Holladay 1和SRK/T公式的预测误差。结果显示Haigis公式在多数亚组中≤0.5D的比例最高,但短眼伴平均K时Hoffer Q的MedAE最低,短眼伴陡K时Holladay 1的MedAE最低,长眼伴平均K时SRK/T的MedAE最低。结论强调选择公式需关注眼轴和角膜屈光力,尤其在不寻常生物测量时。
要点
- Haigis公式在短眼陡K、平均眼轴陡K及长眼平K/平均K中≤0.5D比例最高。
- 短眼平均K时Hoffer Q的MedAE最低(0.30D),短眼陡K时Holladay 1最低(0.24D)。
- 长眼平均K时SRK/T的MedAE最低(0.29D)且≤0.5D比例最高(68.1%)。
核心结论
- 总体Haigis公式在多数亚组中结果准确。
- 选择IOL公式时需关注眼轴长度和角膜屈光力,尤其在不寻常生物测量眼。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析611只白内障手术眼,按眼轴长度和角膜屈光力分组。
- 计算预测残余屈光误差,比较Haigis、Hoffer Q、Holladay 1和SRK/T公式的准确性。
主要发现
- Haigis公式在短眼陡K中≤0.5D比例达90%,平均眼轴陡K中73.2%,长眼平K和平均K中分别为65%和72.7%。
- Hoffer Q在短眼平均K中MedAE最低为0.30D。
- Holladay 1在短眼陡K中MedAE最低为0.24D。
- SRK/T在长眼平均眼轴平K和平均K中≤0.5D比例分别为80.5%和68.1%,长眼平均K中MedAE最低为0.29D。
关键数值与推荐
- 记录≤±0.25D、≤±0.5D和1D预测误差的百分比。
- 短眼陡K中Haigis公式≤0.5D比例为90%。
- 短眼平均K中Hoffer Q的MedAE为0.30D。
- 短眼陡K中Holladay 1的MedAE为0.24D。
- 长眼平均K中SRK/T的MedAE为0.29D。
临床怎么用
- 根据眼轴长度和角膜屈光力选择IOL公式,不寻常生物测量眼需特别关注。
- 短眼伴陡K可考虑Holladay 1,短眼伴平均K可考虑Hoffer Q。
- 长眼伴平均K可考虑SRK/T,多数亚组Haigis公式表现准确。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To provide clinical guidance on the use of intraocular lens (IOL) power calculation formulas according to the biometric parameters. METHODS: 611 eyes that underwent cataract surgery were retrospectively analysed in subgroups according to the axial length (AL) and corneal power (K). The predicted residual refractive error was calculated and compared to evaluate the accuracy of the following formulas: Haigis, Hoffer Q, Holladay 1 and SRK/T. Furthermore, the percentages of eyes with ≤±0.25, ≤±0.5 and 1 dioptres (D) of the prediction error were recorded. RESULTS: The Haigis formula showed the highest percentage of cases with ≤0.5 D in eyes with a short AL and steep K (90%), average AL and steep cornea (73.2%) but also in long eyes with a flat and average K (65% and 72.7%, respectively). The Hoffer Q formula delivered the lowest median absolute error (MedAE) in short eyes with an average K (0.30 D) and Holladay 1 in short eyes with a steep K (Holladay 1 0.24 D). SRK/T presented the highest percentage of cases with ≤0.5 D in average long eyes with a flat and average K (80.5% and 68.1%, respectively) and the lowest MedAE in long eyes with an average K (0.29 D). CONCLUSION: Overall, the Haigis formula shows accurate results in most subgroups. However, attention must be paid to the axial eye length as well as the corneal power when choosing the appropriate formula to calculate an IOL power, especially in eyes with an unusual biometry.
引用
- Röggla V, Langenbucher A, Leydolt C, et al. Accuracy of common IOL power formulas in 611 eyes based on axial length and corneal power ranges. Br J Ophthalmol. 2020. PMID: 32998904. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2020-315882
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。