圆锥角膜中Scheimpflug成像与超声测厚仪中央角膜厚度测量一致性的影响因素
本研究基于前瞻性观察性非随机研究的post hoc分析,纳入794只进展性圆锥角膜眼,评估Scheimpflug成像与超声测厚仪测量中央角膜厚度(CCT)的一致性。结果显示两者一致性中等(ICC 74.9%,Bland-Altman界限-48.5至+62.5 μm),圆锥偏中心和Kmax是影响一致性的显著因素。结论认为在圆锥角膜中两者CCT测量不可互换,尤其在陡峭角膜和偏中心圆锥者。
要点
- 圆锥角膜中Scheimpflug与超声测厚CCT一致性中等,ICC为74.9%。
- 圆锥偏中心每增加1 mm,设备间CCT差异平均增加10.13 μm。
- Kmax每增加10D,设备间CCT差异平均增加6.8 μm。
核心结论
- 圆锥角膜中Scheimpflug成像与超声测厚仪CCT测量一致性中等。
- 圆锥偏中心和Kmax是影响设备间CCT一致性的显著因素。
- 在陡峭角膜和偏中心圆锥者中,两种CCT测量不可互换使用。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为前瞻性观察性非随机研究的post hoc分析,地点为加拿大多伦多Kensington Eye Institute。
- 纳入进展性圆锥角膜的交叉链接候选者,共794只眼(456名受试者),平均年龄27.6±8.0岁。
主要发现
- 设备间一致性中等:组内相关系数74.9%,Bland-Altman一致性界限-48.5 μm至+62.5 μm。
- 多变量分析中,圆锥偏中心(p<0.001,系数+10.13,95%CI +6.73至+13.53)与一致性显著相关。
- Kmax(p<0.001,系数+0.68,95%CI +0.46至+0.90)与一致性显著相关。
- 圆锥偏中心每增加1 mm,设备间CCT差异平均增加10.13 μm;Kmax每增加10D,差异平均增加6.8 μm。
- 年龄、角膜散光和等效球镜为统计学显著但非临床显著的影响因素。
关键数值与推荐
- 一致性中等定义为组内相关系数74.9%,Bland-Altman一致性界限-48.5 μm至+62.5 μm。
- 圆锥偏中心与设备间CCT差异的回归系数为+10.13 μm/mm(95%CI +6.73至+13.53,p<0.001)。
- Kmax与设备间CCT差异的回归系数为+0.68 μm/D(95%CI +0.46至+0.90,p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 在圆锥角膜患者中,不应将Scheimpflug成像与超声测厚仪的CCT测量值互换使用。
- 对于陡峭角膜(高Kmax)和偏中心圆锥的角膜,尤其需注意设备间CCT差异,以确保交叉链接安全。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To evaluate the agreement of central corneal thickness (CCT) measurement between Scheimpflug imaging and ultrasound (U/S) pachymetry in keratoconic eyes, and investigate factors that affect the agreement. METHODS: This post hoc analysis within a prospective, observational non-randomised study preformed at the Kensington Eye Institute, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, included crosslinking candidates with progressive keratoconus (KC). Main outcome measures were the agreement of CCT measurement between Scheimpflug imaging (Pentacam Oculus, Wetzlar, Germany) and U/S pachymetry (PachPen 24-5100, Accutome Inc., Malvern, Pennsylvania, USA), and factors that affect the agreement. RESULTS: A total of 794 keratoconic eyes of 456 subjects with a mean age of 27.6±8.0 years (69.7% males and 49.6% right eyes) were included. Agreement between devices was moderate (intraclass correlation coefficient: 74.9%, Bland-Altman limits of agreement: -48.5 μm to +62.5 μm). In a multivariable analysis, cone decentration (p<0.001, coefficient +10.13 [+6.73 to +13.53 95% CIs]) and Kmax (p<0.001, coefficient +0.68 [+0.46 to +0.90 95% CIs]) were significantly associated (both clinically and statistically) with the level of agreement between the devices; the discrepancy in CCT between the devices increased on average by 10.13 μm for every mm of cone decentration, and by 6.8 μm for every 10D of Kmax. Age, corneal astigmatism and spherical equivalent were statistically but not clinically significant factors affecting agreement. CONCLUSION: The agreement of CCT measurement between Scheimpflug imaging and U/S pachymetry in KC was moderate. To ensure the safety of crosslinking in keratoconic corneas, Scheimpflug and U/S CCT measurements should not be used interchangeably, especially in steep corneas and corneas with decentred cones.
引用
- Sorkin N, Ohri A, Jung H, et al. Factors affecting central corneal thickness measurement agreement between Scheimpflug imaging and ultrasound pachymetry in keratoconus. Br J Ophthalmol. 2020. PMID: 32972916. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2020-317111
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。