碱性眼外伤视网膜损伤的初步临床观察:全视野视网膜电图特征
回顾性分析22例化学性眼外伤及眼表热烧伤患者(27只眼)的全视野视网膜电图(FERG),其中碱性眼外伤17只眼,并与17只健康眼对照。结果显示碱性眼外伤眼在暗适应不同刺激强度下FERG的a波、b波及振荡电位振幅均较健康眼显著降低,且视力≥0.2与<0.2者间FERG振幅无显著差异。提示碱性眼外伤可累及视网膜视杆和视锥系统,FERG可客观评估视网膜功能。
要点
- 碱性眼外伤眼暗适应FERG a波、b波及振荡电位振幅较健康眼显著下降。
- 视力≥0.2与<0.2的碱性眼外伤眼间FERG振幅无显著差异。
- FERG可用于客观评估碱性眼外伤后的视网膜功能状态。
核心结论
- 碱性眼外伤FERG 6项参数波形振幅普遍下降,提示可造成视网膜视杆系统和视锥系统损伤。
- FERG可客观判断碱性眼外伤患者的视网膜功能状态。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性系列病例研究,纳入2018年5月至2020年1月北京大学第三医院眼科化学性眼外伤及眼表热烧伤患者22例(27只眼)。
- 碱性眼外伤17只眼、热烧伤7只眼、酸性眼外伤3只眼;对照为单眼机械性眼外伤患者的17只健康眼。
- 所有受试者依据国际临床视觉电生理学会标准行不同闪光强度的明、暗适应FERG。
- 组间比较采用单因素方差分析及SNK-q检验,不同视力碱性眼外伤结果比较采用独立样本t检验。
主要发现
- 0.01 cd·s·m-2暗适应FERG b波振幅:碱性眼外伤(135±85)μV、热烧伤(169±55)μV、酸性眼外伤(112±43)μV,健康眼(341±53)μV,差异有统计学意义(F=31.38;q=8.94,5.70,5.45;P均<0.01)。
- 3.00 cd·s·m-2暗适应FERG a波振幅:碱性眼外伤(178±78)μV、热烧伤(172±35)μV、酸性眼外伤(99±53)μV,健康眼(334±60)μV,差异有统计学意义(F=24.33;q=7.04,5.60,5.80;P均<0.01)。
- 3.00 cd·s·m-2暗适应FERG b波振幅:碱性眼外伤(354±79)μV、热烧伤(342±77)μV、酸性眼外伤(352±201)μV,健康眼(600±78)μV,差异有统计学意义(F=27.68;q=8.11,6.51,4.48;P均<0.01)。
- 3.00 cd·s·m-2暗适应FERG振荡电位振幅:碱性眼外伤(97±54)μV、热烧伤(107±41)μV、酸性眼外伤(45±22)μV,健康眼(206±32)μV,差异有统计学意义(F=25.03;q=7.36,5.13,5.96;P均<0.01)。
- 碱性眼外伤后视力≥0.2与视力<0.2的患者FERG 6项反应振幅差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 对碱性眼外伤患者可行FERG检查以客观评估视网膜视杆和视锥系统功能损伤。
- FERG振幅下降可提示视网膜功能受损,辅助临床判断伤情。
局限性
- 回顾性系列病例研究,样本量较小(22例27只眼),碱性眼外伤仅17只眼。
- 对照组为单眼机械性眼外伤患者的健康眼,非完全正常人群。
- 仅14只碱性眼外伤眼有视力记录用于视力分组分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To investigate the features of the full-field electroretinogram (FERG) in patients with ocular surface alkaline injury, and to clarify the clinical significance of FERG examination in alkaline ocular trauma. Methods: Retrospective series of case study. A total of 22 patients with chemical ocular surface injury who were treated in the Department of Ophthalmology of Peking University Third Hospital from May 2018 to January 2020 were selected, including 20 males (25 eyes) and 2 females (2 eyes). The age ranged from 19 to 60 years old (average, 41). There were 17 eyes with alkaline ocular trauma, 7 eyes with thermal burn, and 3 eyes with acid ocular trauma. Seventeen contralateral healthy eyes in patients with unilateral mechanical trauma were used as controls. Fourteen alkaline trauma eyes with visual acuity records were further observed according to the degree of visual impairment. All patients were subjected to different flash intensity stimuli in accordance with a standard of the International Society for Clinical Electrophysiology of Vision for dark-adapted and light-adapted full-field FERG. One-way ANOVA and SNK-q was used for the comparison between groups. The unpaired t test was used for the comparison of patients with different vision. Results: Compared with healthy eyes the injured eyes' amplitude of dark adaption FERG b-wave under the dark stimulation of 0.01 cd·s·m-2 in alkaline ocular trauma, thermal burn, acid ocular trauma was (135±85), (169±55), and (112±43) versus (341±53) μV, respectively; compared with healthy eyes, the differences were statistically significant (F=31.38; q=8.94, 5.70, 5.45;all P<0.01). Compared with healthy eyes the injured eyes' amplitude of dark adaption FERG a-wave under the dark stimulation of 3.00 cd·s·m-2 in alkaline ocular trauma, thermal burn, acid ocular trauma was (178±78), (172±35), and (99±53) versus (334±60) μV, respectively; compared with healthy eyes, the differences were statistically significant (F=24.33; q=7.04, 5.60, 5.80;all P<0.01). Compared with healthy eyes the injured eyes' amplitude of dark adaption FERG b-wave under the dark stimulation of 3.00 cd·s·m-2 in alkaline ocular trauma, thermal burn, acid ocular trauma was (354±79), (342±77), and (352±201) versus (600±78) μV, respectively; compared with healthy eyes, the differences were statistically significant (F=27.68; q=8.11, 6.51, 4.48; all P<0.01). Compared with healthy eyes the injured eyes' amplitude of dark adaption FERG OPs under the dark stimulation of 3.00 cd·s·m-2 in alkaline ocular trauma, thermal burn, acid ocular trauma was (97±54), (107±41), and (45±22) versus (206±32) μV, respectively; compared with healthy eyes, the differences were statistically significant (F=25.03; q=7.36, 5.13, 5.96; all P<0.01).There was no significant difference in FERG between patients with visual acuity≥0.2 and those with visual acuity<0.2 (P>0.05) after alkaline ocular trauma. Conclusions: By detecting the amplitude change of FERG wave form of chemical ocular trauma, in this study, the amplitude of FERG wave form in alkaline ocular trauma was generally decreased. It's suggested that alkaline ocular trauma can cause damage to the rod and cone systems of retinal. (Chin J Ophthalmol, 2020, 56: 514-518). 目的: 探讨碱性眼外伤患者全视野视网膜电图(FERG)的表现,明确FERG检查在碱性眼外伤中的临床意义。 方法: 回顾性系列病例研究。选取2018年5月至2020年1月在北京大学第三医院眼科就诊的化学性眼外伤及眼表热烧伤的患者22例(27只眼),其中男性20例(25只眼),女性2例(2只眼);年龄19~60岁(中位数为41岁)。碱性眼外伤17只眼、热烧伤7只眼、酸性眼外伤3只眼;另纳入单眼机械性眼外伤患者的17只健康眼。选取碱性眼外伤患眼中有视力记录的14只眼按视力损伤程度进一步观察。所有受试者均依据国际临床视觉电生理学会标准在不同闪光强度的光刺激下行双眼明、暗适应FERG,比较其波形特征。不同类型患者组间比较采用单因素方差分析及SNK-q检验,不同视力的碱性眼外伤检查结果比较采用独立样本t检验。 结果: 碱性眼外伤、热烧伤、酸性眼外伤患眼及健康眼在0.01 cd·s·m-2光刺激下暗适应FERG b波振幅分别为(135±85)、(169±55)、(112±43)及(341±53)μV,与健康眼相比,差异均有统计学意义(F=31.38;q=8.94,5.70,5.45;P均<0.01)。碱性眼外伤、热烧伤、酸性眼外伤患眼及健康眼在3.00 cd·s·m-2光刺激下暗适应FERG a波振幅分别为(178±78)、(172±35)、(99±53)及(334±60)μV,与健康眼相比,差异均有统计学意义(F=24.33;q=7.04,5.60,5.80;P均<0.01)。碱性眼外伤、热烧伤、酸性眼外伤患眼及健康眼在3.00 cd·s·m-2光刺激下暗适应FERG b波振幅分别为(354±79)、(342±77)、(352±201)及(600±78)μV,与健康眼相比,差异均有统计学意义(F=27.68;q=8.11,6.51,4.48;P均<0.01)。碱性眼外伤、热烧伤、酸性眼外伤患眼及健康眼在3.00 cd·s·m-2光刺激下暗适应FERG振荡电位振幅分别为(97±54)、(107±41)、(45±22)及(206±32)μV,与健康眼相比,差异均有统计学意义(F=25.03;q=7.36,5.13,5.96;P均<0.01)。碱性眼外伤后,视力≥0.2和视力<0.2的患者FERG 6项反应振幅相比较差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。 结论: 碱性眼外伤FERG 6项参数的波形振幅普遍下降,提示碱性眼外伤可造成视网膜视杆系统和视锥系统损伤。FERG可客观判断碱性眼外伤患者的视网膜功能状态。(中华眼科杂志,2020,56:514-518).
引用
- Xie X, Zhang HL, Wu WY, et al. [Preliminary clinical observations of retina injury in alkaline ocular trauma patients]. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2020. PMID: 32842333. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112142-20200301-00132
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。