SLIT2:一种新的翼状胬肉分级系统的提出与验证
这项前瞻性横断面研究纳入217例翼状胬肉患者,由两名分级者独立对裂隙灯照片进行两次分级,评估8个参数并赋予1–4分。结果显示各参数组内和组间信度多为良好至优秀,据此提出包含8个成分的SLIT2分级系统,用于标准化翼状胬肉严重程度和复发的报告。
要点
- SLIT2系统包含8个成分,涵盖结膜与角膜各4项参数。
- 结膜大小与角膜各参数的组内信度优秀(κ=0.84–0.92)。
- 结膜体长度组间信度中等(κ=0.54–0.57),其余多为良好至优秀。
核心结论
- 提出的SLIT2分级系统由8个成分组成,可能作为标准化报告翼状胬肉严重程度和疾病复发的可靠工具,用于临床和研究。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性横断面研究,纳入217例翼状胬肉患者,所有患者接受裂隙灯检查。
- 裂隙灯照片由两名分级者独立分级两次,共完成868次独立评估。
- 评估8个参数,每个参数赋分1–4分(正常至重度),采用加权Cohen kappa分析信度。
主要发现
- 结膜评估组内信度:体厚度κ=0.81–0.89、角膜缘大小κ=0.87–0.92为优秀,体血管性κ=0.72–0.86为良好至优秀,体长度κ=0.57–0.81为中等至优秀。
- 结膜评估组间信度:角膜缘大小κ=0.86为优秀,体厚度κ=0.72–0.73和体血管性κ=0.66–0.75为良好,体长度κ=0.54–0.57为中等。
- 角膜评估组内信度:全部四个参数κ=0.84–0.90为优秀。
- 角膜评估组间信度:头长度κ=0.86–0.87为优秀,头血管性κ=0.78–0.82为良好至优秀,Stocker线κ=0.79–0.80为良好,头厚度κ=0.67–0.69为良好。
关键数值与推荐
- SLIT2命名对应:S为Stocker线,S为角膜缘大小,L为头/体长度,I为体/头充血/血管性,T为体/头厚度。
- 每个参数评分范围为1–4分(正常至重度)。
临床怎么用
- 临床可依据SLIT2的8个成分对翼状胬肉严重程度进行标准化分级记录。
- 该分级系统可能有助于统一临床和研究中对翼状胬肉严重程度及复发的报告。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND/AIMS: To propose and validate a new pterygium grading system based on slit-lamp evaluation. METHODS: This prospective cross-sectional study included 217 patients with pterygium. All patients underwent slit-lamp examination, and slit-lamp photographs were independently graded by two graders twice. A total of eight parameters were evaluated and all parameters were assigned with a score of 1-4 (normal-severe). Intra-rater and inter-rater reliability as determined by weighted Cohen's kappa analysis. RESULTS: A total of 868 independent assessment, based on 217 slit-lamp images, were performed by two graders. For conjunctival assessment, the intra-rater reliability was excellent for body thickness (κ=0.81-0.89) and size at limbus (κ=0.87-0.92), substantial-to-excellent for body vascularity (κ=0.72-0.86), and moderate-to-excellent for body length (κ=0.57-0.81), whereas the inter-rater reliability was excellent for size at limbus (κ=0.86), substantial for body thickness (κ=0.72-0.73) and body vascularity (κ=0.66-0.75), and moderate for body length (κ=0.54-0.57). For corneal assessment, the intra-rater reliability was excellent for all four parameters (κ=0.84-0.90) whereas the inter-rater reliability was excellent for head length (κ=0.86-0.87), substantial-to-excellent for head vascularity (κ=0.78-0.82), substantial for Stocker's line (κ=0.79-0.80) and head thickness (κ=0.67-0.69). The grading system was named SLIT2, which included S tocker's line, S ize at limbus, L ength of head/body, I njection/vascularity of body/head, and T hickness of body/head. CONCLUSION: The proposed SLIT2 grading system, consisting of eight components, may serve as a reliable tool to standardise the reporting of pterygium severity and disease recurrence for clinical and research applications.
引用
- Ting DSJ, Liu YC, Patil M, et al. Proposal and validation of a new grading system for pterygium (SLIT2). Br J Ophthalmol. 2020. PMID: 32788329. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2020-315831
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。