儿童视乳头水肿与假性视乳头水肿鉴别影像方法:美国眼科学会报告
美国眼科学会综述儿童视乳头水肿与假性视乳头水肿鉴别的影像方法,检索354篇摘要,纳入6项III级证据研究。荧光素血管造影、两种OCT协议组合及多色共聚焦扫描激光检眼镜显示与临床诊断的阳性百分比协议和阴性百分比协议均达92%-100%,但样本量小、置信区间宽且缺乏高质量证据,无影像方法能确切鉴别。
要点
- 荧光素血管造影、OCT协议组合和多色共聚焦扫描激光检眼镜与临床诊断的阳性及阴性百分比协议均达92%-100%。
- 超声测量显示高阳性百分比协议(高达95%)伴低阴性百分比协议(低至58%)或相反模式。
- 自荧光和眼底照相的阳性百分比协议为40%-60%,阴性百分比协议为57%,鉴别准确性较低。
核心结论
- 尽管多种影像方法显示与临床诊断的高阳性及阴性百分比协议,但因缺乏高质量证据,无眼科影像方法能确切鉴别儿童视乳头水肿与假性视乳头水肿。
- 临床医生必须继续通过详尽病史采集和检查,并合理使用辅助检查来决定哪些儿童需要进一步检查视乳头水肿。
研究设计与样本
- 美国眼科学会报告,于2020年1月在PubMed和Cochrane Library数据库检索英文文献,无日期限制。
- 检索共获得354篇摘要,全文审阅17篇,最终纳入6项研究,所有研究均被评为III级证据。
主要发现
- 荧光素血管造影、两种OCT协议组合和多色共聚焦扫描激光检眼镜(Spectralis SD-OCT)与临床诊断的阳性百分比协议为92%-100%(95%CI 69%-100%),阴性百分比协议为92%-100%(95%CI 70%-100%)。
- 超声测量显示高阳性百分比协议(高达95%)伴低阴性百分比协议(低至58%)或相反模式。
- 自荧光和眼底照相显示较低的阳性百分比协议(40%-60%)和阴性百分比协议(57%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 荧光素血管造影、OCT协议组合和多色共聚焦扫描激光检眼镜的阳性及阴性百分比协议均达92%-100%,但每种方法仅1项研究。
- 超声测量的阳性百分比协议高达95%,阴性百分比协议低至58%。
- 自荧光和眼底照相的阳性百分比协议为40%-60%,阴性百分比协议为57%。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应继续以详尽病史和检查为基础,合理使用辅助检查,而非单独依赖影像方法鉴别儿童视乳头水肿与假性视乳头水肿。
- 对影像结果需谨慎解读,尤其注意样本量小和方法学局限性导致的宽置信区间。
局限性
- 所有纳入研究均为III级证据,缺乏高质量证据。
- 样本量小导致置信区间宽,且每种影像方法或协议仅1项研究,整体数据缺乏。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To review the published literature on the accuracy of ophthalmic imaging methods to differentiate between papilledema and pseudopapilledema in children. METHODS: Literature searches were conducted in January 2020 in the PubMed database for English-language studies with no date restrictions and in the Cochrane Library database without any restrictions. The combined searches yielded 354 abstracts, of which 17 were reviewed in full text. Six of these were considered appropriate for inclusion in this assessment and were assigned a level of evidence rating by the panel methodologist. All 6 included studies were rated as level III evidence. RESULTS: Fluorescein angiography, a combination of 2 OCT protocols, and multicolor confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscopy (Spectralis SD-OCT; Heidelberg Engineering, Heidelberg, Germany) demonstrated the highest positive percent agreement (92%-100%; 95% confidence interval [CI], 69%-100%) and negative percent agreement (92%-100%; 95% CI, 70%-100%) with a clinical diagnosis of papilledema in children. However, results must be interpreted with caution owing to methodologic limitations, including a small sample size leading to wide CIs and an overall lack of data (there was only 1 study each for the above methods and protocols). Ultrasonographic measures showed either a high positive percent agreement (up to 95%) with low negative percent agreement (as low as 58%) or vice versa. Autofluorescence and fundus photography showed a lower positive (40%-60%) and negative (57%) percent agreement. CONCLUSIONS: Although several imaging methods demonstrated high positive and negative percent agreement with clinical diagnosis, no ophthalmic imaging method conclusively differentiated papilledema from pseudopapilledema in children because of the lack of high-quality evidence. Clinicians must continue to conduct thorough history-taking and examination and make judicious use of ancillary testing to determine which children warrant further workup for papilledema.
引用
- Chang MY, Binenbaum G, Heidary G, et al. Imaging Methods for Differentiating Pediatric Papilledema from Pseudopapilledema: A Report by the American Academy of Ophthalmology. Ophthalmology. 2020. PMID: 32386809. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2020.03.027
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。