圆锥角膜患者专用人工晶状体度数公式的准确性
该回顾性连续病例系列纳入147例圆锥角膜患者147眼,比较了针对圆锥角膜调整的公式(Holladay 2圆锥角膜调整版和Kane圆锥角膜公式)与常规公式(Barrett Universal 2、Haigis、Hoffer Q、Holladay 1、Holladay 2、Kane和SRK/T)预测屈光度的准确性。基于平均绝对预测误差(MAE),Kane圆锥角膜公式(0.81 D)显著低于所有其他公式(P < 0.01)。在3期圆锥角膜中,所有未修改公式均导致远视平均预测误差,范围1.72至3.02 D,且随角膜屈光力增加而恶化。
要点
- Kane圆锥角膜公式的MAE为0.81 D,显著低于所有其他公式(P < 0.01)。
- SRK/T在传统公式中最准确,MAE为1.00 D。
- 3期圆锥角膜中未修改公式远视预测误差达1.72至3.02 D。
核心结论
- Kane圆锥角膜公式在本系列中是最准确的公式。
- SRK/T是传统人工晶状体公式中最准确的。
- 所有常规人工晶状体公式均导致远视屈光结果,且随角膜屈光力增加而恶化。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性连续病例系列,纳入147例圆锥角膜患者147眼。
- 每例符合条件患者随机选择一只眼。
- 根据生物测量最陡角膜屈光力进行亚组分析:1期≤48 D,2期>48 D且≤53 D,3期>53 D。
主要发现
- 基于平均绝对预测误差(MAE),公式排名:Kane圆锥角膜公式(0.81 D)、SRK/T(1.00 D)、Barrett Universal 2(1.03 D)、未修改Kane(1.05 D)、Holladay 1(1.18 D)、未修改Holladay 2(1.19 D)、Haigis(1.22 D)、Hoffer Q(1.30 D)、Holladay 2圆锥角膜调整版(1.32 D)。
- Kane圆锥角膜公式与所有公式相比MAE显著更低(P < 0.01)。
- 在3期圆锥角膜中,所有未修改公式的远视平均预测误差范围为1.72至3.02 D。
关键数值与推荐
- 圆锥角膜分期基于生物测量最陡角膜屈光力:1期≤48 D,2期>48 D且≤53 D,3期>53 D。
- 原文给出了各期圆锥角膜目标屈光度的建议。
临床怎么用
- 对于圆锥角膜患者,优先使用Kane圆锥角膜公式进行人工晶状体度数计算。
- 若使用传统公式,SRK/T相对最准确,但需注意远视误差风险。
- 根据圆锥角膜分期参考原文建议设定目标屈光度。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计。
- 样本量147眼,可能限制亚组分析效力。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To assess the accuracy of intraocular lens (IOL) power formulas modified specifically for patients with keratoconus (Holladay 2 with keratoconus adjustment and Kane keratoconus formula) compared with normal IOL power formulas (Barrett Universal 2, Haigis, Hoffer Q, Holladay 1, Holladay 2, Kane, and SRK/T). DESIGN: Retrospective consecutive case series. PARTICIPANTS: A total of 147 eyes of 147 patients with keratoconus. METHODS: Data from patients with keratoconus who had preoperative IOLMaster biometry were included. A single eye per qualifying patient was randomly selected. The predicted refraction was calculated for each of the formulas and compared with the actual refractive outcome to give the prediction error. Subgroup analysis based on the steepest corneal power measured by biometry (stage 1: ≤48 diopters [D], stage 2: >48 D and ≤53 D, and stage 3: >53 D) was performed. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Prediction error. RESULTS: On the basis of the mean absolute prediction error (MAE), the formulas were ranked as follows: Kane keratoconus formula (0.81 D), SRK/T (1.00 D), Barrett Universal 2 (1.03 D), unmodified Kane (1.05 D), Holladay 1 (1.18 D), unmodified Holladay 2 (1.19 D), Haigis (1.22 D), Hoffer Q (1.30 D), and Holladay 2 with keratoconus adjustment (1.32 D). The Kane keratoconus formula had a statistically significant lower MAE compared with all formulas (P < 0.01). In stage 3 keratoconus, all nonmodified formulas had a hyperopic mean prediction error ranging from 1.72 to 3.02 D. CONCLUSIONS: The Kane keratoconus formula was the most accurate formula in this series. The SRK/T was the most accurate of the traditional IOL formulas. All normal IOL formulas resulted in hyperopic refractive outcomes that worsened as the corneal power increased. Suggestions for target refractive aims in each stage of keratoconus are given.
引用
- Kane JX, Connell B, Yip H, et al. Accuracy of Intraocular Lens Power Formulas Modified for Patients with Keratoconus. Ophthalmology. 2020. PMID: 32279887. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2020.02.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。