文献速递白内障与屈光手术

FS-LASIK、WF-LASIK与SMILE矫正近视散光术后1年视觉质量比较

[Comparison of the visual quality at 1 year following femtosecond laser-assisted LASIK, wavefront-guided femtosecond LASIK and small incision lenticule extraction for myopia and astigmatism].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi · 2020-01-01

病例对照研究纳入108例(212只眼)近视散光患者,比较FS-LASIK、WF-LASIK与SMILE术后12个月的视力、角膜参数、高阶像差与对比敏感度。三种术式均获理想视力,WF-LASIK角膜对称性最好、高阶像差增加最少、视觉质量最好。

要点

  • 三种术式术后12个月裸眼视力≥1.0比例均约96%以上
  • WF-LASIK角膜表面规则指数降低且低于FS-LASIK与SMILE
  • WF-LASIK在12.0周/度暗环境及眩光对比敏感度均高于另两组

核心结论

  • FS-LASIK、WF-LASIK及SMILE术后12个月均可获得理想视力。
  • WF-LASIK术后角膜对称性最好,高阶像差增加最少,视觉质量最好。

研究设计与样本

  • 病例对照研究,纳入2014年9月至2016年9月单纯近视或复性近视散光患者108例(212只眼)。
  • 男性34例(66只眼),女性74例(146只眼),年龄27(24,32)岁。
  • FS-LASIK组37例(71只眼),WF-LASIK组35例(69只眼),SMILE组36例(72只眼)。
  • 术前及术后12个月记录屈光度、角膜参数、高阶像差及对比敏感度,组间比较用秩和检验。

主要发现

  • 术后12个月裸眼视力≥1.0:FS-LASIK组69只眼(97.18%),WF-LASIK组67只眼(97.10%),SMILE组69只眼(95.83%)。
  • 术后裸眼视力好于术前最佳矫正视力:FS-LASIK组59只眼(83.10%),WF-LASIK组60只眼(86.96%),SMILE组61只眼(84.72%)。
  • WF-LASIK组总高阶像差均方根值增加幅度低于FS-LASIK组和SMILE组。
  • FS-LASIK组和WF-LASIK组球差增加,均高于SMILE组。

关键数值与推荐

  • WF-LASIK组角膜表面规则指数由0.11(0.07,0.28)降至0.07(0.06,0.20)(Z=-2.662,P=0.008),低于FS-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-3.236,-3.118;P=0.001,0.000)。
  • WF-LASIK组角膜表面不对称指数由0.34(0.25,0.43)升至0.38(0.30,0.52)(Z=-2.140,P=0.032),低于FS-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-2.910,-3.779;P=0.004,0.000)。
  • FS-LASIK组总高阶像差均方根值由0.32(0.27,0.41)升至0.53(0.40,0.65)(Z=-6.228,P=0.000),高于WF-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-3.595,-4.806;P=0.000,0.000)。
  • WF-LASIK组彗差由0.16(0.11,0.24)升至0.26(0.15,0.37)(Z=-3.816,P=0.000),低于FS-LASIK组(Z=-3.528,P=0.000)。
  • WF-LASIK组12.0周/度暗环境对比敏感度由1.34(1.18,1.48)升至1.48(1.34,1.63)(Z=-2.985,P=0.003),高于FS-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-3.194,-2.977;P=0.001,0.003)。

临床怎么用

  • 对高阶像差与视觉质量要求高的近视散光患者,可优先考虑WF-LASIK。
  • 术后评估应结合角膜地形图对称性指标与高阶像差、对比敏感度综合判断视觉质量。

局限性

  • 原文未报告

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To investigate mesopic contrast sensitivity (CS) and high-order aberrations after femtosecond laser-assisted LASIK (FS-LASIK), wavefront-guided femtosecond LASIK (WF-LASIK) and small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) for myopia and astigmatism. Methods: In this case-control study, 212 eyes of 108 patients with myopia and astigmatism from September 2014 to September 2016 were treated by refractive surgery. There were 34 males (66 eyes) and 74 females (146 = eyes), aged 27 (24, 32) years. They were divided into 3 groups, with 37 patients (71 eyes), 35 patients (69 eyes) and 36 patients (72 eyes) treated by FS-LASIK, WF-LASIK and SMILE, respectively. Refraction diopters, corneal tomography, wavefront aberrations and contrast sensitivity were evaluated before and at 12 months after surgery. The results of different groups were compared by rank sum test. Results: At 12 = months of follow-up, 69 eyes (97.18%) treated by FS-LASIK, 67 eyes (97.10%) by WF-LASIK and 69 eyes (95.83%) by SMILE had the uncorrected distance visual acuity of 20/20 or better. Fifty-nine eyes (83.10%) treated by FS-LASIK, 60 eyes (86.96%) by WF-LASIK and 61 eyes (84.72%) by SMILE had better postoperative uncorrected distance visual acuity than preoperative corrected distance visual acuity. Surface regularity index of the WF-LASIK group decreased from 0.11 (0.07, 0.28) to 0.07 (0.06, 0.20) (Z=-2.662, P=0.008), which was less than that of the FS-LASIK and SMILE groups (Z=-3.236, -3.118, P=0.001, 0.000). Surface asymmetry index of the WF-LASIK group increased from 0.34 (0.25, 0.43) to 0.38 (0.30, 0.52) (Z=-2.140, P=0.032), which was less than that of the FS-LASIK and SMILE groups (Z=-2.910, -3.779, P=0.004, 0.000). The root mean square of high-order of the FS-LASIK group increased from 0.32 (0.27, 0.41) to 0.53 (0.40, 0.65) (Z=-6.228, P=0.000), which was more than that of the WF-LASIK and SMILE groups (Z=-3.595, -4.806, P=0.000, 0.000). Coma of the WF-LASIK group increased from 0.16 (0.11, 0.24) to 0.26 (0.15, 0.37) (Z=-3.816, P=0.000), which was less than that of the FS-LASIK group (Z=-3.528, P=0.000). Spherical aberration of the FS-LASIK and WF-LASIK groups increased from 0.10 (0.05, 0.21) and 0.08 (0.04, 0.12) to 0.24 (0.13, 0.34) and 0.15 (0.09, 0.26), respectively (Z=-5.141, -4.864, P=0.000, 0.000), which were more than that of the SMILE group (Z=-2.549, -4.682, P=0.011, 0.000). CS of the WF-LASIK group at 12 cycles per degree (c/d) increased from 1.34 (1.18, 1.48) to 1.48 (1.34, 1.63) (Z=-2.985, P=0.003), which was more than that of the FS-LASIK and SMILE groups (Z=-3.194, -2.977, P=0.001, 0.003). CS with glare of the WF-LASIK group at 12.0 c/d increased from 1.26 (1.18, 1.34) to 1.34 (1.34, 1.63) (Z=-3.608, P=0.000), which was more than that of the FS-LASIK and SMILE groups (Z=-4.033, -2.913, P=0.000, 0.004). Conclusions: FS-LASIK, WF-LASIK and SMILE achieved ideal visual outcomes at 12 months postoperatively. WF-LASIK treated eyes showed the best corneal symmetry, the least increase of high-order aberrations and the best visual quality among three kinds of surgeries. (Chin J Ophthalmol, 2020, 56: 118-125). 目的: 探讨飞秒激光制瓣的LASIK(FS-LASIK)、波前像差引导的LASIK(WF-LASIK)和飞秒激光小切口角膜基质透镜取出术(SMILE)矫正近视散光后的视觉质量及高阶像差。 方法: 病例对照研究。本研究纳入2014年9月至2016年9月来北京同仁医院屈光中心手术的108例(212只眼)单纯近视或复性近视散光患者进行研究,其中男性34例(66只眼),女性74例(146只眼);年龄27(24,32)岁。按术式将患者分为3个组,其中FS-LASIK组37例(71只眼),WF-LASIK组35例(69只眼),SMILE组36例(72只眼)。术前及术后12个月记录患者的屈光度、角膜参数、高阶像差值以及对比敏感度值,并进行秩和检验比较不同时间的差异。 结果: 术后12个月时,FS-LASIK组、WF-LASIK组和SMILE组分别有69(97.18%)、67(97.10%)和69只眼(95.83%)裸眼视力≥1.0,3个组分别有59(83.10%)、60(86.96%)和61只眼(84.72%)术后裸眼视力好于术前最佳矫正视力。WF-LASIK组角膜表面规则指数(SRI)从0.11(0.07,0.28)降低为0.07(0.06,0.20)(Z=-2.662,P=0.008),低于FS-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-3.236,-3.118;P=0.001,0.000),角膜表面不对称指数(SAI)从0.34(0.25,0.43)增加为0.38(0.30,0.52)(Z=-2.140,P=0.032),均低于FS-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-2.910,-3.779;P=0.004,0.000)。FS-LASIK组总高阶像差均方根值从0.32(0.27,0.41)增加为0.53(0.40,0.65)(Z=-6.228,P=0.000),高于WF-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-3.595,-4.086;P=0.000,0.000),WF-LASIK组彗差从0.16(0.11,0.24)增加为0.26(0.15,0.37)(Z=-3.816,P=0.000),低于FS-LASIK组(Z=-3.528,P=0.000),FS-LASIK组和WF-LASIK组分别球差从0.10(0.05,0.21)和0.08(0.04,0.12)增加到0.24(0.13,0.34)和0.15(0.09,0.26)(Z=-5.141,-4.864;P=0.000,0.000),高于SMILE组(Z=-2.549,-4.682;P=0.011,0.000)。术后12个月时,WF-LASIK组在12.0周/度空间频率下暗环境对比敏感度从1.34(1.18,1.48)增加为1.48(1.34,1.63)(Z=-2.985,P=0.003),高于FS-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-3.194,-2.977;P=0.001,0.003),有眩光对比敏感度在12.0周/度空间频率下从1.26(1.18,1.34)增加为1.34(1.34,1.63)(Z=-3.608,P=0.000),高于FS-LASIK组和SMILE组(Z=-4.033,-2.913;P=0.000,0.004)。 结论: FS-LASIK、WF-LASIK及SMILE术后12个月均可获得理想的视力,其中WF-LASIK术后角膜对称性最好,高阶像差增加最少,视觉质量最好。(中华眼科杂志,2020,56:118-125).

来源:Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zheng Y, Zhou YH, Zhang J, et al. [Comparison of the visual quality at 1 year following femtosecond laser-assisted LASIK, wavefront-guided femtosecond LASIK and small incision lenticule extraction for myopia and astigmatism]. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2020. PMID: 32074822. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0412-4081.2020.02.007

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。