ISNT规则及其变体在人群研究中区分青光眼与正常眼的准确性
基于人群研究评估ISNT规则及变体用视盘照片测量的神经视网膜边缘宽度和SD-OCT测量的RNFL厚度区分正常与青光眼眼的准确性。纳入940名正常者和93例青光眼患者,视盘照片ISNT规则敏感度94.1%、特异度49.2%,IST规则敏感度69.9%、特异度87.0%;RNFL厚度版本诊断指标较低。结论:视盘照片边缘宽度测量的ISNT和IST规则有用且简单,RNFL厚度版本价值有限。
要点
- 视盘照片ISNT规则敏感度高(94.1%)但特异度低(49.2%)。
- 视盘照片IST规则特异度较高(87.0%)但敏感度降至69.9%。
- SD-OCT RNFL厚度版本的ISNT和IST规则诊断价值有限。
核心结论
- 视盘照片测量神经视网膜边缘宽度的ISNT和IST规则是区分正常与青光眼眼的有用且简单工具,而SD-OCT RNFL厚度版本价值有限。
研究设计与样本
- 基于人群的研究,纳入940名正常受试者和93例青光眼患者,用图像处理程序在单眼视盘照片上测量神经视网膜边缘宽度,用SD-OCT测量RNFL厚度。
主要发现
- 视盘照片ISNT规则敏感度94.1%(95%CI 90.2-98.1)、特异度49.2%(46.9-51.6)。
- 视盘照片IST规则敏感度69.9%(62.1-77.6)、特异度87.0%(85.3-88.6)。
- RNFL厚度ISNT规则敏感度79.4%(72.6-86.2)、特异度34.1%(31.9-36.4)。
- RNFL厚度IST规则敏感度50.0%(41.6-58.4)、特异度64.9%(62.7-67.2)。
关键数值与推荐
- 视盘照片ISNT规则:敏感度94.1%(95%CI 90.2-98.1),特异度49.2%(46.9-51.6)。
- 视盘照片IST规则:敏感度69.9%(62.1-77.6),特异度87.0%(85.3-88.6)。
- RNFL厚度ISNT规则:敏感度79.4%(72.6-86.2),特异度34.1%(31.9-36.4)。
- RNFL厚度IST规则:敏感度50.0%(41.6-58.4),特异度64.9%(62.7-67.2)。
临床怎么用
- 临床可用视盘照片测量的神经视网膜边缘宽度应用ISNT或IST规则辅助区分正常与青光眼眼,但需注意ISNT规则特异度低、IST规则敏感度低。
- 不宜将ISNT或IST规则直接套用于SD-OCT RNFL厚度测量来区分正常与青光眼眼。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To evaluate the accuracy of the ISNT rule (I=inferior, S=superior, N=nasal, T=temporal) and its variants with neuroretinal rim width and retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) thickness measurements differentiating normal from glaucomatous eyes. METHODS: The diagnosis accuracy of the ISNT rule and its variants was evaluated in a population-based study. Neuroretinal rim widths were measured on monoscopic optic disc photographs with an image-processing program. RNFL thickness measurements were obtained with spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT). RESULTS: In this study including 940 normal subjects and 93 patients with glaucoma, the sensitivity of the ISNT rule with optic disc photographs was 94.1% (95% CI 90.2 to 98.1), whereas its specificity was 49.2% (46.9 to 51.6). When using the IST rule, the sensitivity decreased to 69.9% (62.1 to 77.6) with a higher specificity, 87.0% (85.3 to 88.6). All the diagnosis indicators were somewhat lower for the different rules using RNFL thickness: the sensitivity of the ISNT rule was 79.4% (72.6 to 86.2) and its specificity was 34.1% (31.9 to 36.4). With the IST rule, the sensitivity decreased to 50.0% (41.6 to 58.4) while the specificity increased to 64.9% (62.7 to 67.2). CONCLUSIONS: The ISNT and IST rules applied to neuroretinal rim width measurement by optic disc photographs are useful and simple tools for differentiating normal from glaucomatous eyes. The translation of these rules to RNFL thickness by SD-OCT is of limited value.
引用
- Maupin E, Baudin F, Arnould L, et al. Accuracy of the ISNT rule and its variants for differentiating glaucomatous from normal eyes in a population-based study. Br J Ophthalmol. 2020. PMID: 31959590. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2019-315554
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。