放射状角膜切开术后白内障手术人工晶状体度数计算方法比较
该回顾性病例系列纳入同一机构52眼(34例)放射状角膜切开术后白内障手术眼,比较7种人工晶状体计算公式。有屈光史时True K [History]最准确;无屈光史时True K [No History]与Haigis公式表现较好,DK-Holladay-IOLM与Potvin-Hill最不准确。
要点
- 有屈光史时True K [History]的MedAE最低,为0.275。
- True K [Partial History]的MedAE为0.382,75.0%-76.6%患眼在±0.50 D内。
- 无屈光史时True K [No History]与Haigis公式69.2%在±0.50 D内。
核心结论
- 知晓屈光史可显著提高放射状角膜切开术后白内障手术人工晶状体度数计算的准确性。
- 放射状角膜切开术后屈光状态似乎是最重要参数,纳入放射状角膜切开术前屈光可进一步轻度改善MedAE。
- 无屈光史时True K [No History]与Haigis公式均表现良好,且无需来自单独生物测量设备的数据。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性病例系列,纳入同一机构由2名术者之一完成序贯放射状角膜切开与白内障手术的34例患者52眼。
- 评估7种人工晶状体计算公式:True K [History]、True K [Partial History]、True K [No History]、Double-K Holladay 1(DK-Holladay-IOLM)、Potvin-Hill、Haigis及Haigis联合-0.50屈光度(D)偏移。
- 生物测量采用IOLMaster 500(Carl Zeiss Meditec AG,耶拿,德国)与Pentacam(OCULUS Inc,阿灵顿,华盛顿州)设备,术后4至6周行主觉验光。
- 将实现的等效球镜结果与目标结果比较,计算每眼每种公式的绝对误差。
主要发现
- True K [History]取得最佳结果。
- True K [Partial History]的MedAE高于True K [History](0.382 vs 0.275),但达到±0.50 D目标的比例相似(75.0%-76.6%)。
- 在不需屈光史的方法中,True K [No History]与未调整Haigis最准确(69.2%在±0.50 D目标内),True K [No History]的MedAE最低但更倾向远视(ME +0.269 vs Haigis的-0.006)。
- DK-Holladay-IOLM与Potvin-Hill方法最不准确。
关键数值与推荐
- True K [History]的MedAE为0.275;True K [Partial History]的MedAE为0.382,75.0%-76.6%在±0.50 D内。
- 无屈光史时True K [No History]与Haigis公式69.2%在±0.50 D内,True K [No History]的ME为+0.269,Haigis的ME为-0.006。
- DK-Holladay-IOLM与Potvin-Hill方法最不准确。
临床怎么用
- 行放射状角膜切开术后白内障手术人工晶状体度数计算时,知晓屈光史可显著提高准确性,True K [History]取得最佳结果。
- 无屈光史时True K [No History]与Haigis公式均表现良好,且无需来自单独生物测量设备的数据。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To compare methods of calculating the required intraocular lens (IOL) power for patients undergoing cataract surgery after radial keratotomy (RK), including the 2016 update of the True K formula. DESIGN: Retrospective case series. PARTICIPANTS: A total of 52 eyes of 34 patients who had sequential RK and cataract surgery performed in the same institution by 1 of 2 surgeons. METHODS: Seven IOL calculation formulae were evaluated: True K [History], True K [Partial History], True K [No History], Double-K Holladay 1 (DK-Holladay-IOLM), Potvin-Hill, Haigis, and Haigis with a -0.50 diopter (D) offset. Biometry was obtained with the IOLMaster 500 (Carl Zeiss Meditec AG, Jena, Germany) and Pentacam (OCULUS Inc, Arlington, WA) devices. Subjective refraction was performed at 4 to 6 weeks postoperatively. The achieved spherical equivalent outcome was compared with the target outcome to calculate the absolute error for each eye with each formula. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Median absolute error (MedAE) and mean absolute error (MAE), and percentage of patients within ±0.50 D, ±0.75 D, and ±1.00 D of refractive target. Mean error (ME) was also calculated to demonstrate whether a formula tended toward more myopic or hyperopic outcomes. RESULTS: Best results were achieved with the True K [History]. The MedAE was higher (0.382 vs. 0.275) with the True K [Partial History], but a similar percentage of patients (75.0%-76.6%) achieved within ±0.50 D of target. Of the methods that do not require refractive history, the True K [No History] and unadjusted Haigis were most accurate (69.2% within ±0.50 D of target), with the True K [No History] returning the lowest MedAE but also more of a tendency toward hyperopia (ME +0.269 vs. -0.006 for Haigis). The DK-Holladay-IOLM and Potvin-Hill methods were the least accurate. CONCLUSIONS: Knowledge of the refractive history significantly improves the accuracy of IOL calculations in patients undergoing cataract surgery after previous RK. The post-RK refraction appears to be the most important parameter, with inclusion of the pre-RK refraction offering a further slight improvement in MedAE. When no refractive history is available, the True K [No History] and Haigis formulae both perform well, with the added advantage of not requiring data from separate biometric devices.
引用
- Turnbull AMJ, Crawford GJ, Barrett GD, et al. Methods for Intraocular Lens Power Calculation in Cataract Surgery after Radial Keratotomy. Ophthalmology. 2019. PMID: 31561878. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2019.08.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。