教学项目中术前向患者告知住院医师角色与白内障手术知情同意的关系
本研究由主治医师按脚本向96例社区私立诊所白内障患者完整告知住院医师参与手术的角色,术后访谈分析知情同意过程体验。56.3%(95%CI 45.7%-66.4%)同意住院医师参与,基线特征与同意率无确定关联。同意者提及对主治医师的信任、贡献教育和监督,拒绝者提及恐惧和感知风险。
要点
- 96例患者中56.3%(95%CI 45.7%-66.4%)同意住院医师参与白内障手术。
- 白人患者同意率60%(45/75)vs 非白人患者30.8%(4/13),差异29.2%(95%CI -0.7%至57.3%;Fisher精确检验P=0.07)。
- 同意者提及信任主治医师、贡献教育和监督;拒绝者提及恐惧和感知风险。
核心结论
- 结果提示45.7%至66.4%的社区私立诊所患者会同意住院医师手术。
- 同意率与人口学因素无关联。
- 由于私立诊所患者较少获得住院医师手术机会,这可能代表住院医师教育的资源。
研究设计与样本
- 由主治医师按脚本完整告知住院医师在白内障手术中的角色。
- 术后对患者进行录音访谈,采用定量与主题定性方法分析知情同意过程体验及是否允许住院医师参与的选择。
- 通过私立社区办公室招募患者,手术在 routinely 开展住院医师培训的单一医院进行。
- 纳入18岁以上全身状况良好、有手术性白内障、无既往眼手术史、英语流利、能参与知情同意决策和术后访谈的患者。
- 排除单眼白内障、需额外同时手术、有眼外伤史或白内障手术技术难度超出住院医师常规技能水平的患者。
主要发现
- 96例患者参与,年龄50至88岁,男性53例(55.2%),白人75例(85.2%)。
- 96例中54例(56.3%;95%CI 45.7%-66.4%)同意住院医师参与。
- 基线特征与同意住院医师参与之间未发现任何置信度的关联,包括种族/族裔(白人患者60%[45/75] vs 非白人患者30.8%[4/13];差异29.2%;95%CI -0.7%至57.3%;Fisher精确检验P=0.07)。
- 同意者列出对主治医师的信任、贡献教育和监督作为促成因素。
- 拒绝者陈述恐惧和感知风险作为原因。
关键数值与推荐
- 96例中54例(56.3%;95%CI 45.7%-66.4%)同意住院医师参与。
- 白人患者同意率60%(45/75)vs 非白人患者30.8%(4/13),差异29.2%(95%CI -0.7%至57.3%;Fisher精确检验P=0.07)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Cataract surgery is the most commonly performed intraocular surgery. Academic centers have mandates to train the next surgeon generation, but resident roles are often hidden in the consent process. OBJECTIVE: To investigate associations of full preoperative disclosure of the resident role with patient consent rates and subjective experience of the consent process. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Full scripted disclosure of residents' roles in cataract surgery was delivered by the attending surgeon. Qualitative analysis was conducted from recorded interviews of patients postoperatively regarding consent process experience and choice of whether to allow resident participation. Associations were sought regarding demographic characteristics and consent rates. Patients were recruited though a private community office. Surgery was performed at a single hospital where resident training was routinely conducted. The study included systemically well patients older than 18 years with surgical cataract. They had no previous eye surgery, English fluency, and ability to engage in informed consent decision-making and postsurgery interview. Patients were ineligible if they had monocular cataracts, required additional simultaneous procedures, had history of ocular trauma, or had cataracts that were surgically technically challenging beyond the usual resident skill level. INTERVENTIONS: Eligible patients received an informed consent conversation by the attending physician in accordance with a script describing projected resident involvement in their cataract surgery. Postoperatively, patients were interviewed and responses were analyzed with a quantitative and thematic qualitative approach. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Consent rates to resident participation and qualitative experience of full disclosure process. RESULTS: Ninety-six patients participated. Participants were between ages 50 and 88 years, 53 were men (55.2%), and 75 were white (85.2%). A total of 54 of 96 participants (56.3%; 95% CI, 45.7%-66.4%) agreed to resident involvement. There were no associations between baseline characteristics and consent to resident involvement identified with any confidence, including race/ethnicity (60% [45 of 75] in white patients vs 30.8% [4 of 13] in nonwhite patients; difference, 29.2%; 95% CI, -0.7% to 57.3%; Fisher exact P = .07). Thematically, those who agreed to resident involvement listed trust in the attending surgeon, contributing to education, and supervision as contributing factors. Patients who declined stated fear and perceived risk as reasons. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Our results suggest 45.7% to 66.4% of community private practice patients would consent to resident surgery. Consent rates were not associated with demographic factors. Because residents are less often offered the opportunity to do surgery on private practice patients vs academic center patients, this may represent a resource for resident education.
引用
- Corwin AM, Rajkumar JN, Markovitz BJ, et al. Association of Preoperative Disclosure of Resident Roles With Informed Consent for Cataract Surgery in a Teaching Program. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2019. PMID: 31343672. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2019.1919
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。