文献速递白内障与屈光手术

两种计算器对Toric人工晶状体矫正效果的影响

[The influence of two calculation methods on the outcomes of Toric intraocular lenses].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi · 2019-01-01

前瞻性随机对照双盲研究纳入64例(81只眼)拟行超声乳化白内障吸除联合IOL植入术患者,随机分为Barrett计算器组和老版AcrySof计算器组,比较术后1个月和3个月散光矫正误差。结果显示Barrett计算器组散光矫正误差的大小误差绝对值和矢量误差均小于AcrySof计算器组,差异有统计学意义,提示Barrett计算器可减小散光矫正误差、提高Toric IOL矫正效果。

要点

  • Barrett计算器组术后1、3个月散光矫正误差大小误差绝对值均小于AcrySof计算器组。
  • 术后1、3个月Barrett计算器组总体、顺规及逆规散光矢量误差均小于AcrySof计算器组。
  • 与老版AcrySof计算器相比,Barrett计算器选择Toric IOL可减小散光矫正误差。

核心结论

  • 与老版AcrySof计算器相比,采用Barrett计算器计算选择Toric IOL可以减小散光矫正误差(ERA),提高Toric IOL矫正效果。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性随机对照双盲研究,纳入2017年1月至2018年3月天津医科大学眼科医院拟行超声乳化白内障吸除联合IOL植入术患者64例(81只眼),随机分为Barrett计算器组34例(41只眼)和AcrySof计算器组30例(40只眼)。
  • 术前使用Lenstar LS900进行眼部生物测量,两组分别使用Barrett计算器和老版AcrySof计算器对Toric IOL进行规划后行超声乳化白内障吸除联合IOL植入术。
  • 取随访资料完整者55例(70只眼)进行分析,其中男性20例(25只眼),女性35例(45只眼),年龄(72±10)岁;Barrett计算器组29例(35只眼),AcrySof计算器组26例(35只眼)。

主要发现

  • 术后1、3个月Barrett计算器组ERA的大小误差绝对值分别为(0.19±0.16)D、(0.28±0.24)D,AcrySof计算器组分别为(0.36±0.28)D、(0.46±0.41)D,两组间差异均有统计学意义(t=-3.050、-2.036,均P<0.05)。
  • 术后1个月Barrett计算器组总体、顺规散光、逆规散光ERA的EV分别为(0.30±0.21)D、(0.26±0.22)D、(0.37±0.26)D,AcrySof计算器组分别为(0.47±0.33)D、(0.51±0.34)D、(0.52±0.38)D,两组间差异均有统计学意义(t=-2.533、-2.436、-2.150,均P<0.05)。
  • 术后3个月Barrett计算器组总体、顺规散光、逆规散光ERA的EV分别为(0.37±0.28)D、(0.29±0.17)D、(0.35±0.27)D,AcrySof计算器组分别为(0.59±0.46)D、(0.54±0.37)D、(0.64±0.52)D,两组间差异均有统计学意义(t=-2.142、-2.038、-2.481,均P<0.05)。
  • 术后1个月两组间X(EV)差异有统计学意义[-0.13(-0.36~0.80)D与0.19(-1.01~0.71)D比较,Z=-2.965,P<0.01],Y(EV)差异有统计学意义[-0.02(-0.51~0.64)D与-0.15(-0.88~1.10)D比较,Z=-2.076,P<0.05]。
  • 术后3个月两组间X(EV)、Y(EV)差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05)。

临床怎么用

  • 在白内障合并散光患者行Toric IOL规划时,可优先考虑使用Barrett计算器以减小散光矫正误差。
  • 术后1个月和3个月均应通过主觉验光和裂隙灯检查评估残余散光及Toric IOL轴位。

局限性

  • 研究仅比较Barrett计算器与老版AcrySof计算器,未涉及其他新型计算器。
  • 随访资料完整者仅55例(70只眼),样本量有限。
  • 术后随访时间仅至3个月,缺乏长期结果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To evaluate the influence of Barrett calculator and AcrySof calculator on astigmatism correction effect. Methods: This is a randomized prospective study. A total of 64 cases (81 eyes) who planed to undergo phacoemulsification at Tianjin Medical University Eye Hospital during January 2017 and March 2018 were enrolled and divided into two groups randomly, including of the Barrett calculator group of 34 cases (41 eyes) and the AcrySof calculator group of 30 cases (40 eyes). Preoperative ocular biological parameters were measured using Lenstar LS900. The Toric intraocular lenses (IOL) plans were determined based on Barrett calculator and the AcrySof calculator for the two groups respectively. Subjective optometry was performed by phoropter and Toric IOL alignment was detected by slitlamp examination at 1 and 3 months postoperatively. Statistical analysis was taken with the data of 29 cases (35 eyes) in the Barrett calculator group and 26 cases (35 eyes) in the AcrySof calculator group, there were 20 males (25 eyes) and 35 females (45 eyes) with an average age of (72±10) years. The difference between the predicted residual astigmatism by the two calculators and the residual astigmatism obtained by postoperative optometry is the error of refractive astigmatism (ERA). The magnitude error is the algebraic difference of ERA. Vector error(VE) is a vector difference of ERA. Statistical analysis of magnitude error and VE between the two groups were taken by student's t test or rank sum test. Results: At 1 months and 3 months, the magnitude error absolute value of Barrett calculator group were (0.19±0.16)D, (0.28±0.24)D, and those of AcrySof calculator group were (0.36±0.28)D, (0.46±0.41)D, and the differences were statistically significant (t=-3.050, -2.036, both P<0.05). At 1 month postoperatively, the overall, with-the-rule astigmatism, and against-the-rule astigmatism VE of the Barrett calculator group were (0.30±0.21)D, (0.26±0.22)D, (0.37±0.26)D respectively, and those of the AcrySof calculator group were (0.47±0.33)D, (0.51±0.34)D and (0.52±0.38)D respectively, the differences between the two groups were statistically significant (t=-2.533, -2.436, -2.150, all P<0.05). At 3 months postoperatively, the overall, with-the-rule astigmatism, and against-the-rule astigmatism VE of the Barrett calculator group were (0.37±0.28)D, (0.29±0.17)D, (0.35±0.27)D respectively, and those of the AcrySof calculator group were (0.59±0.46)D, (0.54±0.37)D, (0.64±0.52)D respectively, the differences between the two groups were statistically significant (t=-2.142, -2.038, -2.481, all P<0.05).The difference of X(EV) between the Barrett calculator group and the AcrySof calculator group was statistically significant[-0.13(-0.36-0.80)D vs. 0.19(-1.01-0.71)D, Z=-2.965,P<0.01], and the difference of Y(EV) was statistically significant [-0.02(-0.51-0.64)D vs. -0.15(-0.88-1.10)D, Z=-2.076, P<0.05] at 1 months. There was no significant difference in X(EV) and Y(EV) (both P>0.05) at 3 months. Conelusion: As compared to AcrySof Toric calculator, the application of Barrett calculator in selecting Toric IOL may reduce ERA and improve Toric IOL correction outcomes. (Chin J Ophthalmol, 2019, 55:208-213). 目的: 评价Barrett计算器和老版AcrySof计算器两种计算方法对散光矫正型(Toric)人工晶状体(IOL)矫正效果的影响。 方法: 前瞻性随机对照双盲研究。选择2017年1月至2018年3月在天津医科大学眼科医院拟行超声乳化白内障吸除联合IOL植入术患者64例(81只眼),采用随机数字表法分为两组,其中Barrett计算器组34例(41只眼),AcrySof计算器组30例(40只眼)。术前使用Lenstar LS900进行眼部生物测量,两组患者分别使用Barrett计算器和老版AcrySof计算器对Toric IOL进行规划后行超声乳化白内障吸除联合IOL植入术。术后1个月和3个月使用综合验光仪进行主觉验光,并检查Toric IOL轴位。取随访资料完整者55例(70只眼)进行分析,其中男性20例(25只眼),女性35例(45只眼),年龄(72±10)岁;Barrett计算器组29例(35只眼),AcrySof计算器组26例(35只眼)。计算器计算得出的预期残余散光度数与术后验光得到的残余散光度数差值即散光矫正误差(ERA)。大小误差为ERA的代数差,矢量误差(EV)为ERA的矢量差。采用t检验或秩和检验对两组患者术后ERA的大小误差和EV进行比较。 结果: 术后1、3个月Barrett计算器组ERA的大小误差绝对值分别为(0.19±0.16)D、(0.28±0.24)D;AcrySof计算器组分别为(0.36±0.28)D、(0.46±0.41)D,两组间比较差异均有统计学意义(t=-3.050、-2.036,均P<0.05)。术后1个月Barrett计算器组总体、顺规散光、逆规散光ERA的EV分别为(0.30±0.21)D、(0.26±0.22)D、(0.37±0.26)D,AcrySof计算器组分别为(0.47±0.33)D、(0.51±0.34)D、(0.52±0.38)D;术后3个月Barrett计算器组总体、顺规散光、逆规散光ERA的EV分别为(0.37±0.28)D、(0.29±0.17)D、(0.35±0.27)D,AcrySof计算器组分别为(0.59±0.46)D、(0.54±0.37)D、(0.64±0.52)D;两组间比较差异均有统计学意义(术后1个月t=-2.533、-2.436、-2.150,术后3个月t=-2.142、-2.038、-2.481,均P<0.05)。将Barrett计算器组与AcrySof计算器组EV按照矢量进行分解后比较,术后1个月两组间X(EV)差异有统计学意义[-0.13(-0.36~0.80)D与0.19(-1.01~0.71)D比较,Z=-2.965,P<0.01],Y(EV)差异有统计学意义[-0.02(-0.51~0.64)D与-0.15(-0.88~1.10)D比较,Z=-2.076,P<0.05];术后3个月两组间X(EV)、Y(EV)差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05)。 结论: 与老版AcrySof计算器相比,采用Barrett计算器计算选择Toric IOL可以减小ERA,提高Toric IOL矫正效果。(中华眼科杂志,2019,55:208-213).

来源:Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Yang XT, Zhang H, Liang JL, et al. [The influence of two calculation methods on the outcomes of Toric intraocular lenses]. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2019. PMID: 30841688. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0412-4081.2019.03.010

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。