文献速递青光眼

六种视野进展分析算法的一致性及不一致预测因素

Agreement and Predictors of Discordance of 6 Visual Field Progression Algorithms.
PubMed 文献 · Ophthalmology · 2019-02-04

结果显示算法间一致性差至中等(κ 0.12-0.52),基于至少4种算法11.7%的眼进展;初始MD更低、首份视野年龄更大、随访视野数更多、随访年数更长及机构差异与不一致相关。

要点

  • 6种视野进展算法直接比较的一致性差至中等,κ值范围0.12-0.52。
  • 基于至少4种算法判定,11.7%的眼表现为进展。
  • 初始MD更低和首份视野年龄更大是不一致的主要预测因素(P<0.01)。

核心结论

  • 现有视野进展算法间一致性有限,且一致性随临床参数(包括机构)变化。
  • 这些局限凸显了进展算法临床应用的挑战及将大数据结果外推至个体实践的困难。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性纵向队列研究,分析美国5家主要眼科机构的视野数据。
  • 纳入至少5次符合可靠性标准的Swedish interactive threshold algorithm标准24-2视野的患眼。

主要发现

  • 6种算法(MD斜率、VFI斜率、AGIS、CIGTS、PLR、PoPLR)直接比较的κ值范围为0.12-0.52。
  • 基于至少4种算法判定,11.7%的眼为进展。
  • 不一致的主要预测因素为初始MD更低(P<0.01)和首份视野年龄更大(P<0.01)。
  • 更多视野数(P<0.01)、更长随访年数(P<0.01)和眼科机构(P=0.03)也与不一致相关。

临床怎么用

  • 临床判读视野进展时应意识到不同算法间一致性有限,避免单一算法结论。
  • 对初始MD较低、年龄较大、随访时间较长的患者,算法间不一致可能性更高,需结合临床综合判断。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: To determine the agreement of 6 established visual field (VF) progression algorithms in a large dataset of VFs from multiple institutions and to determine predictors of discordance among these algorithms. DESIGN: Retrospective longitudinal cohort study. PARTICIPANTS: Visual fields from 5 major eye care institutions in the United States were analyzed, including a subset of eyes with at least 5 Swedish interactive threshold algorithm standard 24-2 VFs that met our reliability criteria. Of a total of 831 240 VFs, a subset of 90 713 VFs from 13 156 eyes of 8499 patients met the inclusion criteria. METHODS: Six commonly used VF progression algorithms (mean deviation [MD] slope, VF index slope, Advanced Glaucoma Intervention Study, Collaborative Initial Glaucoma Treatment Study, pointwise linear regression, and permutation of pointwise linear regression) were applied to this cohort, and each eye was determined to be stable or progressing using each measure. Agreement between individual algorithms was tested using Cohen's κ coefficient. Bivariate and multivariate analyses were used to determine predictors of discordance (3 algorithms progressing and 3 algorithms stable). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Agreement and discordance between algorithms. RESULTS: Individual algorithms showed poor to moderate agreement with each other when compared directly (κ range, 0.12-0.52). Based on at least 4 algorithms, 11.7% of eyes progressed. Major predictors of discordance or lack of agreement among algorithms were more depressed initial MD (P < 0.01) and older age at first available VF (P < 0.01). A greater number of VFs (P < 0.01), more years of follow-up (P < 0.01), and eye care institution (P = 0.03) also were associated with discordance. CONCLUSIONS: This extremely large comparative series demonstrated that existing algorithms have limited agreement and that agreement varies with clinical parameters, including institution. These issues underscore the challenges to the clinical use and application of progression algorithms and of applying big-data results to individual practices.

来源:Ophthalmology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Saeedi OJ, Elze T, D'Acunto L, et al. Agreement and Predictors of Discordance of 6 Visual Field Progression Algorithms. Ophthalmology. 2019. PMID: 30731101. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2019.01.029

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。