原发性开角型青光眼与正常眼压性青光眼视神经功能-结构损伤模式
该横断面研究纳入POAG 84眼、NTG 69眼及健康对照23眼,按视野MD分期,用Humphrey 24-2和OCT按Garway-Heath六区法分析视野与RNFL厚度对应关系。发现POAG与NTG各期缺损模式不同,POAG功能-结构最强相关为视野上旁弓-RNFL颞下区(r=0.630),NTG为视野下旁弓-RNFL颞上区(r=0.645)。
要点
- POAG中期下半侧视野缺损更重,晚期上半侧更重;NTG各期上下半侧无显著差异。
- POAG的RNFL缺损最重区域从颞下进展到颞上,NTG从颞下到鼻下再到颞上。
- POAG功能-结构最强相关为视野上旁弓-RNFL颞下区,NTG为视野下旁弓-RNFL颞上区。
核心结论
- POAG与NTG早、中、晚期视野和RNFL损伤模式存在明显不同的加重规律。
- POAG功能-结构最强相关区域为视野上旁弓-RNFL颞下区(r=0.630,P<0.001)。
- NTG功能-结构最强相关区域为视野下旁弓-RNFL颞上区(r=0.645,P<0.001)。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,2008年2月至2017年5月复旦大学附属眼耳鼻喉科医院眼科纳入POAG 84例84眼、NTG 69例69眼、健康对照23名23眼。
- 所有对象行基本眼科检查、Humphrey中央24-2阈值测试和OCT,患者按视野MD分为早、中、晚期。
- 按Garway-Heath六区法将视野模式偏差图和RNFL分为6个对应区域,用Kruskal-Wallis检验比较各区域MD和RNFL厚度,Pearson系数分析相关性。
主要发现
- POAG中期下半侧视野缺损比上半侧严重(t=21.62,P=0.000),晚期上半侧比下半侧严重(t=-3.28,P=0.003);NTG各期上下半侧视野缺损差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05)。
- POAG随疾病进展,上旁弓区视野缺损加重最多;NTG先为上旁弓区加重最多,后为下旁弓区。
- POAG随疾病进展,RNFL缺损最严重区域从颞下发展到颞上;NTG从颞下发展到鼻下,再到颞上。
关键数值与推荐
- 对照组上周弓区、上旁弓区、下周弓区、下旁弓区、颞侧区及中心区视野MD(反对数值)分别为0.87(0.63~1.11)/L、0.74(0.61~0.83)/L、0.72(0.55~0.97)/L、0.65(0.51~0.87)/L、0.69(0.57~0.97)/L、0.82(0.54~0.93)/L。
- 对照组区域1NI、2TI、3NS、4TS、5N、6T的RNFL厚度分别为112.76(63.54~150.99)μm、134.89(89.44~198.55)μm、96.52(57.32~158.79)μm、120.96(69.25~148.48)μm、71.85(65.03~95.47)μm、66.24(55.44~90.97)μm。
- POAG早期与对照组视野MD差异有统计学意义的区域为上旁弓区[0.61(0.18~0.92)/L,H=21.58],RNFL为2TI[109.17(43.77~173.86)μm,H=31.50]。
- NTG早期与对照组视野MD差异有统计学意义的区域为上旁弓区[0.54(0.19~0.80)/L,H=20.93],RNFL为2TI[78.97(47.77~131.45)μm,H=28.86]。
临床怎么用
- 判读POAG与NTG视野和OCT时需注意两者不同的分区损伤进展模式。
- POAG可重点关注视野上旁弓与RNFL颞下区的对应关系,NTG可重点关注视野下旁弓与RNFL颞上区的对应关系。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To investigate the characteristics of impairment of the visual field (VF) and retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) and the differences of progression pattern of early, middle and late stages of primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) and normal-tension glaucoma (NTG) , and to analyze the correspondence of structure and function. Methods: Cross-sectional study. POAG patients, NTG patients and healthy volunteers who were enrolled from February 2008 to May 2017 at Department of Ophthalmology, Eye & ENT Hospital of Fudan University, underwent basic ophthalmic examination, Humphrey central 24-2 threshold test and optical coherence tomography. Patients were divided into early, middle and late stages according to the mean defect (MD) index of the VF test. According to the RNFL distributional characteristics, the pattern deviation map and RNFL were divided into 6 sectors. The differences of each sector's MD and RNFL thickness in the healthy group and groups of patients at 3 stages were analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test, and the correlation of MD and RNFL thickness of each sector was analyzed using the Pearson coefficient. Results: In the POAG group, there were 84 cases (84 eyes) including 35 eyes of early stage, 20 eyes of middle stage and 29 eyes of late stage, with a male/female ratio of 43∶41, aged (45±15) years. In the NTG group, 69 cases (69 eyes) included 30 eyes of early stage, 20 eyes of middle stage and 19 eyes of late stage, with a male/female ratio of 33∶36, aged (49±13) years. The control group had 23 cases (23 eyes), with a male/female ratio of 16∶17 and an age of (44±10) years. There was no significant difference in male/female ratio, age or best corrected visual acuity among the three groups. (1) In the middle stage of POAG, the VF defects of inferior hemi-fields were more severe than the superior (t=21.62, P=0.000), which was opposite to the late stage of POAG (t=-3.28, P=0.003). In each stage of NTG, there was no significant difference between two hemi-fields. In the control group, the MD values(antilog) of VF in the superior peripheral arch (PEA), superior paracentral arch (PAA), inferior PEA and PAA, temporal and central regions were 0.87 (0.63-1.11)/L, 0.74 (0.61-0.83)/L, 0.72 (0.55-0.97)/L, 0.65 (0.51-0.87)/L, 0.69 (0.57-0.97)/L, and 0.82 (0.54-0.93)/L, respectively. The sectoral MD values in the VF sectors of POAG were significant compared with the control group (P<0.05): superior PAA for early stage [0.61 (0.18-0.92)/L, H=21.58], superior PEA and PAA for middle stage [0.61 (0.15-0.87)/L, 0.21 (0.00-0.78)/L, H=25.99, 34.91], superior PEA and PAA, inferior PEA and PAA for late stage [0.01 (0.00-1.13)/L, 0.00 (0.00-0.76)/L, 0.41 (0.00-1.07)/L, 0.21 (0.00-0.95)/L, H=46.27, 54.19, 25.64, 28.10]. With the aggravation of POAG, superior PAA had the largest reduction percentage of sectoral MD. The sectoral MD values in the VF sectors of NTG were significant compared with the control group (P<0.05): superior PAA for early stage [0.54 (0.19-0.80)/L, H=20.93], superior PAA for middle stage [0.60 (0.02-1.01)/L, H=22.13], superior PEA and PAA, inferior PEA and PAA for late stage [0.33 (0.00-0.90)/L, 0.05 (0.00-0.92)/L, 0.16 (0.01-0.87)/L, 0.64 (0.02-1.10)/L, H=37.66, 42.78, 35.15, 37.15]. With the aggravation of NTG, the largest reduction percentage of sectoral MD was found in superior PAA at the beginning but in inferior PAA at last. (2) The RNFL thickness of the control group in Region 1NI, 2TI, 3NS, 4TS, 5N, and 6T was 112.76 (63.54-150.99) μm, 134.89 (89.44-198.55) μm, 96.52 (57.32-158.79) μm, 120.96 (69.25-148.48) μm, 71.85 (65.03-95.47) μm, and 66.24 (55.44-90.97) μm, respectively. The sectoral thickness in the RNFL sectors of POAG were significant compared with the control group (P<0.05): 2TI for early stage [109.17 (43.77-173.86) μm, H=31.50], 1NI, 2TI and 4TS for middle stage [71.54 (49.92-94.98) μm, 62.92 (42.33-102.73) μm, 84.20 (45.98-120.13) μm, H=38.91, 49.89, 30.60], 1NI, 2TI, 3NS, 4TS, 5N and 6T for late stage [61.76 (39.32-97.99) μm, 59.59 (42.80-108.69) μm, 67.28 (42.56-117.96) μm, 65.16 (41.96-138.02) μm, 59.45 (21.04-78.48) μm, 53.74 (27.88-92.71) μm, H=52.76, 55.06, 35.76, 41.72, 41.32, 29.93]. With the aggravation of POAG, at the beginning 2TI had the largest reduction percentage of RNFL thickness but 4TS had it at last. The sectoral thickness in the RNFL sectors of NTG were significantly different from the control group (P<0.05): 2TI for early stage [78.97 (47.77-131.45) μm, H=28.86], 1NI, 2TI, 3NS and 4TS for middle stage [61.46 (49.69-97.38) μm, 74.51 (40.25-135.16) μm, 86.36 (42.70-105.06) μm, 83.60 (54.75-117.35) μm, H=38.76, 35.64, 22.47, 24.14], 1NI, 2TI, 3NS, 4TS and 6T for late stage [61.45 (49.09-92.64) μm, 54.35 (37.40-102.62) μm, 63.72 (28.68-105.55) μm, 61.00 (44.92-108.49) μm, 50.33 (35.62-82.09) μm, H=42.56, 51.50, 36.11, 47.44, 25.50]. With the aggravation of NTG, the sector with the largest reduction percentage of thickness changed from 2TI to NI and 4TS. (3) The VF superior PAA-RNFL 2TI had the highest Pearson correlation coefficient in POAG (r=0.630, P<0.001), while it was the inferior PAA-4TS in NTG (r=0.645, P<0.001). Conclusions: The impairment patterns of VF and RNFL in each stage of POAG and NTG are distinctly different from certain rules of aggravation. The sector with the strongest correlation of function-structure is the VF superior PAA-RNFL inferior temporal sector in POAG and inferior PAA-superior temporal sector in NTG. (Chin J Ophthalmol, 2018, 54: 811-819). 目的: 研究原发性开角型青光眼(POAG)与正常眼压性青光眼(NTG)早、中、晚期视野缺损和视网膜神经纤维层(RNFL)丢失的特点,并分析结构与功能对应特征。 方法: 横断面研究。选取2008年2月至2017年5月在复旦大学附属眼耳鼻喉科医院眼科就诊的POAG患者(POAG组)、NTG患者(NTG组)以及健康志愿者(对照组)进行Humphrey 24-2标准自动视野检查和视网膜相干光层析成像术(OCT)检查,患者组按视野的平均缺损值分为早、中、晚期。将视野模式偏差图和视盘按Garway-Heath六区法分区,即按照RNFL走行特点将两者分为6个对应区域。采用Kruskal-Wallis检验比较对照组与患者组早、中、晚期每个区域视野平均缺损和盘周RNFL厚度值的差异,采用Pearson相关系数分析每个区域视野平均缺损和盘周RNFL厚度的相关性。 结果: POAG组84例(84只眼),男女比例为43∶41,年龄(45±15)岁,早、中、晚期分别为35、20、29只眼;NTG组69例(69只眼),男女比例为33∶36,年龄(49±13)岁,早、中、晚期分别为30、20、19只眼;对照组23名(23只眼),男女比例为16∶17,年龄(44±10)岁。3组性别、年龄、矫正视力差异均无统计学意义。(1)POAG早期上、下半侧视野缺损差异无统计学意义,中期下半侧缺损比上半侧严重(t=21.62,P=0.000),晚期上半侧比下半侧严重(t=-3.28,P=0.003);NTG各期上、下半侧视野缺损间差异均无统计学意义(均P>0.05)。对照组上周弓区、上旁弓区、下周弓区、下旁弓区、颞侧区及中心区视野平均缺损(反对数值)分别为0.87(0.63~1.11)/L、0.74(0.61~0.83)/L、0.72(0.55~0.97)/L、0.65(0.51~0.87)/L、0.69(0.57~0.97)/L、0.82(0.54~0.93)/L。POAG组早、中、晚期与对照组视野平均缺损比较差异有统计学意义(均P<0.05)的区域是:早期为上旁弓区[0.61(0.18~0.92)/L,H=21.58];中期为上周弓区、上旁弓区[0.61(0.15~0.87)/L、0.21(0.00~0.78)/L,H=25.99、34.91];晚期为上周弓区、上旁弓区、下周弓区、下旁弓区[0.01(0.00~1.13)/L、0.00(0.00~0.76)/L、0.41(0.00~1.07)/L、0.21(0.00~0.95)/L,H=46.27、54.19、25.64、28.10];随疾病进展,早、中、晚期始终为上旁弓区视野缺损加重最多。NTG组早、中、晚期与对照组视野平均缺损比较差异有统计学意义(均P<0.05)的区域是:早期为上旁弓区[0.54(0.19~0.80)/L,H=20.93];中期为上旁弓区[0.60(0.02~1.01)/L,H=22.13];晚期为上周弓区、上旁弓区、下周弓区、下旁弓区[0.33(0.00~0.90)/L、0.05(0.00~0.92)/L、0.16(0.01~0.87)/L、0.64(0.02~1.10)/L,H=37.66、42.78、35.15、37.15];随疾病进展,先为上旁弓区视野缺损加重最多,后为下旁弓区。(2)对照组区域1NI、2TI、3NS、4TS、5N、6T的RNFL厚度分别为112.76(63.54~150.99)μm、134.89(89.44~198.55)μm、96.52(57.32~158.79)μm、120.96(69.25~148.48)μm、71.85(65.03~95.47)μm、66.24(55.44~90.97)μm。POAG组早、中、晚期与对照组RNFL厚度比较差异有统计学意义(均P<0.05)的区域是:早期为区域2TI [109.17(43.77~173.86)μm,H=31.50];中期为区域1NI、2TI、4TS[71.54(49.92~94.98)μm、62.92(42.33~102.73)μm、84.20(45.98~120.13)μm,H=38.91、49.89、30.60];晚期为区域1NI、2TI、3NS、4TS、5N、6T[61.76(39.32~97.99)μm、59.59(42.80~108.69)μm、67.28(42.56~117.96)μm、65.16(41.96~138.02)μm、59.45(21.04~78.48)μm、53.74(27.88~92.71)μm,H=52.76、55.06、35.76、41.72、41.32、29.93];随疾病进展,RNFL缺损最严重的区域从颞下发展到颞上。NTG组早、中、晚期与对照组RNFL厚度比较差异有统计学意义(均P<0.05)的区域是:早期为区域2TI[78.97(47.77~131.45)μm,H=28.86],中期为区域1NI、2TI、3NS、4TS[61.46(49.69~97.38)μm、74.51(40.25~135.16)μm、86.36(42.70~105.06)μm、83.60(54.75~117.35)μm,H=38.76、35.64、22.47、24.14],晚期为区域1NI、2TI、3NS、4TS、6T[61.45(49.09~92.64)μm、54.35(37.40~102.62)μm、63.72(28.68~105.55)μm、61.00(44.92~108.49)μm、50.33(35.62~82.09)μm,H=42.56、51.50、36.11、47.44、25.50];RNFL缺损最严重的区域从颞下发展到鼻下,再到颞上。(3)视野平均缺损与RNFL相关分析显示,POAG组相关系数最高的区域为视野上旁弓-RNFL颞下区(r=0.630,P<0.001),NTG组为视野下旁弓-RNFL颞上区(r=0.645,P<0.001)。 结论: 各期POAG和NTG的视野和盘周RNFL损伤特点均存在明显不同且有一定的发展规律,结构与功能对应性最强的部位分别是POAG视野上旁弓区-颞下RNFL、NTG视野下旁弓区-颞上RNFL。(中华眼科杂志,2018,54:811-819).
引用
- Wang XM, Sun XH, Dai Y, et al. [The function-structure impairment pattern of optic nerves in primary open-angle glaucoma and normal-tension glaucoma]. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2018. PMID: 30440151. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0412-4081.2018.11.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。