重新评估当前棱镜标准并建议提高斜视测量准确性
该研究通过几何光学分析和光学平台测量,计算玻璃与丙烯酸棱镜的有效棱镜度(EPP),比较标准临床位置下的误差。结果显示丙烯酸棱镜在正面平面位置下测量≤50 PD时误差<5%,而玻璃棱镜在远大于10 PD时产生显著误差。建议弃用或限制玻璃棱镜用于小角度测量。
要点
- 丙烯酸棱镜正面平面位置测量≤50 PD误差可接受(<5%)
- 玻璃棱镜在远大于10 PD测量中产生显著误差
- 建议弃用当前校准的玻璃棱镜或仅限小角度测量
核心结论
- 当前校准的玻璃棱镜应被弃用或至少限制于小角度测量。
- 丙烯酸棱镜在注意位置时可产生可接受的误差。
研究设计与样本
- 可靠性与有效性分析,采用几何光学计算玻璃和丙烯酸棱镜的有效棱镜度(EPP),并用光学平台测量验证,不涉及患者。
主要发现
- 有效棱镜度随旋转角变化的曲线显示正面平面位置位于曲线较平缓段,Prentice位置位于较陡峭段。
- 丙烯酸棱镜在正面平面位置下,棱镜度至50 PD时误差<5%。
- 玻璃棱镜在测量远大于10 PD时可产生显著误差。
关键数值与推荐
- 丙烯酸棱镜正面平面位置下,棱镜度≤50 PD时误差<5%。
- 玻璃棱镜在测量远大于10 PD时产生显著误差。
临床怎么用
- 临床测量斜视时优先使用丙烯酸棱镜并注意保持正面平面位置。
- 避免使用玻璃棱镜进行大于10 PD的测量,或弃用当前校准的玻璃棱镜。
局限性
- 研究仅基于几何光学计算和光学平台测量,未涉及患者临床验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To critically evaluate the traditional standards for holding single prisms in measuring strabismus, with the specific goal being to increase the overall accuracy of clinical measurements. DESIGN: Reliability and validity analysis. METHODS: Using an analysis involving geometric optics, the effective prism power (EPP), measured in prism diopters (PD), was calculated for glass and acrylic prisms and was the main outcome measure. These results were also validated using optical bench measurements. No patients were involved. RESULTS: Plotting the calculated effective prism power as a function of rotational angle produced curves demonstrating that the frontal plane position lies along the flatter portions of the curves, while the Prentice position lies along the steeper portions of the curves. Calculated values of prism power for the standard clinical positions as well as the percentage errors from accepted standards were compared. Acrylic prisms can be held in the frontal plane position with acceptable amounts of error (<5%) for prisms up to 50 PD. Glass prisms are capable of producing significant errors for measurements much greater than 10 PD. CONCLUSIONS: The use of glass prisms as currently calibrated should be abandoned or at least limited to small measurements. Acrylic prisms produce acceptable errors if careful attention is given to their position.
引用
- Freedman K, Ray C, Kirk D, et al. Reevaluation of Current Prism Standards With Recommendations to Increase Accuracy in the Measurement of Strabismus. Am J Ophthalmol. 2018. PMID: 30240722. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2018.09.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。