白内障术后屈光结局评估方法的比较研究
该研究基于连续5年白内障手术病例数据库,比较球镜、等效球镜、柱镜标量、柱镜矢量及复合球柱镜等多种方法评估术后屈光偏差与离群值的效能。结果显示,将预期屈光结局按复合球柱镜计算时离群值比例最高(233眼,2.59%),提示该方法能提高检出有临床意义屈光离群值的精确性。
要点
- 按复合球柱镜计算预期与术后屈光误差差异,离群值检出为233眼(2.59%)。
- 分别按球镜、等效球镜、柱镜标量、柱镜矢量计算时,离群值比例分别为0.91%、0.51%、1.28%、0.85%。
- 将预期屈光结局视为球柱镜可提高检出临床显著屈光离群值的精确性。
核心结论
- 将预期屈光结局按复合球柱镜处理,可提高检测有临床意义屈光离群值的精确性。
研究设计与样本
- 白内障术后屈光结局评估方法的病例系列数据库研究,纳入连续5年接受顺利白内障手术的患者共9000例,排除12例数据缺失者。
主要发现
- 预期屈光结局为-0.12+0.12×2(95% LCL -1.94+1.06×44;95% UCL +0.77+1.05×140)。
- 术后实际屈光为-0.30+0.47×6(95% LCL -2.36+1.31×36;95% UCL +1.00+1.18×148)。
- 实际与预期差值为-0.18+0.35×7(95% LCL -1.91+1.22×38;95% UCL +0.75+1.09×145)。
- 按球镜、等效球镜、柱镜标量、柱镜矢量计算的离群值分别为82眼(0.91%)、46眼(0.51%)、115眼(1.28%)、76眼(0.85%)。
- 按复合球柱镜计算时离群值为233眼(2.59%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 离群值定义为预期与术后屈光误差之差超过均值3个标准差(SD)的患者。
临床怎么用
- 评估白内障术后屈光结局时,可考虑将预期屈光结局作为复合球柱镜计算,以提高离群值检出精确性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To compare methods for evaluating refractive outcomes after cataract surgery to detect outliers. DESIGN: Case series database study of the evaluation of diagnostic technology. PARTICIPANTS: Consecutive patients who had uneventful cataract operations over a 5-year period. METHODS: The intended and postoperative refractive outcome and differences between these were analyzed as a spherical equivalent, cylinder, and spherocylinder. The average keratometry and differences between steep and flat keratometric meridians were used to calculate the intended refractive error. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Outliers were defined as patients for whom the difference between the intended and postoperative refractive errors was more than 3 standard deviations (SDs) away from the mean. RESULTS: A total of 9000 patients were included. Twelve patients had missing data and were excluded. The mean intended refractive outcome was -0.12+0.12×2 (95% lower confidence limit [LCL], -1.94+1.06×44; 95% upper confidence limit [UCL], +0.77+1.05×140). The actual postoperative refractive error was -0.30+0.47×6 (95% LCL, -2.36+1.31×36; 95% UCL, +1.00+1.18×148) with a difference from the intended of -0.18+0.35×7 (95% LCL, -1.91+1.22×38; 95% UCL, +0.75+1.09×145). Treating the components of the refractive error independently, outliers were observed in 82 eyes (0.91%) based on the sphere, 46 eyes (0.51%) based on the spherical equivalent, 115 eyes (1.28%) based on treating the cylinder as a scalar, and 76 eyes (0.85%) based on treating the cylinder as a vector. When the differences between the intended and postoperative refractive errors were calculated as a compound spherocylinder, outliers were observed for 233 eyes (2.59%). CONCLUSIONS: Treating the intended refractive outcome as a spherocylinder improves the precision for detecting clinically significant refractive outliers.
引用
- Aristodemou P, Sparrow JM, Kaye S, et al. Evaluating Refractive Outcomes after Cataract Surgery. Ophthalmology. 2018. PMID: 30153943. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2018.07.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。