Van Herick法检测房角关闭敏感性低且与检查者经验无关
本研究在131例≥50岁青光眼转诊患者中评估Van Herick评估(VHA)诊断房角关闭的性能。与金标准房角镜相比,技师、住院医师和青光眼专科医生的VHA敏感性分别为57.9%、78.9%和68.4%,特异性约88%。结论认为VHA即使由经验丰富的眼科医生操作也会漏诊大量房角关闭,临床前房角评估最好采用房角镜。
要点
- VHA检测房角关闭的敏感性在技师、住院医师和专科医生中分别为57.9%、78.9%和68.4%。
- VHA特异性约88%,约1/8的开放角被误判为关闭。
- 住院医师与专科医生房角镜检查一致性极好(κ=0.94)。
核心结论
- VHA即使由经验丰富的眼科医生操作,也会漏诊相当比例的房角关闭,并将约1/8的开放角误判为关闭。
- 临床前房角构型评估最好采用房角镜检查。
研究设计与样本
- 可靠性分析,纳入131例≥50岁、无既往眼手术或虹膜周切术的青光眼转诊门诊患者。
- 由11名训练有素的眼科技师、15名眼科住院医师和4名青光眼专科主治医师进行单眼VHA和间接房角镜检查,检查者设盲。
主要发现
- 患者平均年龄62.0±8.7岁,56%为男性,84%为非裔美国人。
- 房角镜下14.5%的眼睛存在房角关闭。
- 技师或住院医师VHA与主治医师VHA的一致性为中等(κ=0.48和κ=0.56)。
- 住院医师与主治医师房角镜检查一致性极好(κ=0.94)。
- 技师、住院医师和主治医师VHA检测房角关闭的敏感性分别为57.9%(95%CI 34.0%-78.9%)、78.9%(53.9%-93.0%)和68.4%(43.5%-86.4%),特异性分别为88.5%(80.3%-93.6%)、88.2%(80.3%-93.3%)和87.5%(79.6%-92.8%)。
关键数值与推荐
- VHA检测房角关闭的敏感性:技师57.9%(95%CI 34.0%-78.9%),住院医师78.9%(53.9%-93.0%),主治医师68.4%(43.5%-86.4%)。
- VHA检测房角关闭的特异性:技师88.5%(80.3%-93.6%),住院医师88.2%(80.3%-93.3%),主治医师87.5%(79.6%-92.8%)。
- VHA与主治医师VHA的一致性:技师κ=0.48,住院医师κ=0.56;房角镜一致性:住院医师与主治医师κ=0.94。
临床怎么用
- VHA不宜作为排除房角关闭的独立筛查工具,阴性结果不能可靠排除房角关闭。
- 对怀疑房角关闭的患者应进行房角镜检查以明确诊断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To evaluate the diagnostic performance characteristics of the Van Herick assessment (VHA) for identifying angle closure compared to gold-standard gonioscopy, as conducted by trained observers of varying expertise. DESIGN: Reliability analysis. METHODS: Patients (n = 131) from a glaucoma referral clinic aged ≥50 years without prior ocular surgery or iridotomy underwent unilateral VHA by 1 of 11 trained ophthalmic technicians, followed by VHA and indirect gonioscopy by 1 of 15 ophthalmology residents and 1 of 4 glaucoma specialist attending physicians. Observers were masked to others' gradings. Cohen's kappa (κ) assessed test reproducibility. VHA sensitivity and specificity for identifying gonioscopic angle closure were calculated. RESULTS: Mean patient age was 62.0 ± 8.7 years, 56% of patients were male, and 84% were African American. Angles were gonioscopically closed in 14.5% of eyes. Moderate agreement was observed comparing technician or resident VHA to attending VHA (κ = 0.48 and κ = 0.56, respectively). Resident and attending gonioscopy demonstrated excellent agreement (κ = 0.94). Sensitivities of technician, resident, and attending VHA for detecting angle closure were 57.9% (95% confidence interval: 34.0%-78.9%), 78.9% (53.9%-93.0%), and 68.4% (43.5%-86.4%), respectively. Specificities were 88.5% (80.3%-93.6%), 88.2% (80.3%-93.3%), and 87.5% (79.6%-92.8%), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: VHA, even when performed by experienced ophthalmologists, misses a substantial proportion of angle closure while incorrectly identifying roughly 1 in 8 open-angle eyes as closed. These results suggest that clinical assessment of anterior chamber angle configuration is best accomplished with gonioscopy.
引用
- Johnson TV, Ramulu PY, Quigley HA, et al. Low Sensitivity of the Van Herick Method for Detecting Gonioscopic Angle Closure Independent of Observer Expertise. Am J Ophthalmol. 2018. PMID: 30071210. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2018.07.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。