文献速递青光眼

Compass眼底视野计与Humphrey视野分析仪的比较

A Comparison between the Compass Fundus Perimeter and the Humphrey Field Analyzer.
PubMed 文献 · Ophthalmology · 2018-08-14

本研究为多中心横断面病例对照研究,纳入499例青光眼患者和444例正常受试者比较Compass与HFA检测青光眼性视神经病变的诊断精度,另用44例患者和54例正常者评估重测变异性。两种设备诊断精度相当,Compass的平均敏感度重测变异性优于HFA。

要点

  • Compass与HFA对青光眼性视神经病变的相对诊断精度相当。
  • 正常受试者中Compass视网膜敏感度平均比HFA低1.85±0.06 dB(P<0.001)。
  • 青光眼患者中Compass平均敏感度重测一致性界限比HFA减小13%,正常者减小49%。

核心结论

  • Compass与HFA检测青光眼性视神经病变的相对诊断精度相当。
  • Compass的平均敏感度重测变异性优于HFA。

研究设计与样本

  • 多中心、横断面、病例对照研究。
  • 诊断精度分析纳入499例青光眼患者和444例正常受试者。
  • 重测变异性分析纳入44例青光眼患者和54例正常受试者。
  • 每名受试者一只眼接受HFA(SITA标准策略)和Compass(ZEST策略)24-2网格测试。
  • 以眼底照片或OCT的专家评估作为青光眼性视神经病变参考标准,独立于视野检查。

主要发现

  • 正常受试者中Compass视网膜敏感度平均比HFA低1.85±0.06 dB(平均值±标准误,P<0.001)。
  • 青光眼患者中Compass视网膜敏感度平均比HFA低1.46±0.05 dB(平均值±标准误,P<0.001)。
  • 两种设备显示相似的判别能力。
  • MD指标的判别能力Compass略优(pAUC差值±标准误为0.019±0.009,P=0.035)。
  • 平均敏感度的95%一致性界限Compass较HFA在青光眼患者中减小13%,在正常受试者中减小49%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 使用部分受试者工作特征曲线和部分曲线下面积比较诊断精度。
  • 以MD及每个视野中低于5%或低于1%总偏差限值的点数作为分类指标。
  • 通过正常组线性回归计算随年龄的敏感度下降以得出点对点总偏差值和MD。

临床怎么用

  • Compass可作为HFA的等效替代用于青光眼性视神经病变的视野诊断。
  • Compass的平均敏感度重测变异性更小,可能有助于随访监测。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: To evaluate relative diagnostic precision and test-retest variability of 2 devices, the Compass (CMP, CenterVue, Padova, Italy) fundus perimeter and the Humphrey Field Analyzer (HFA, Zeiss, Dublin, CA), in detecting glaucomatous optic neuropathy (GON). DESIGN: Multicenter, cross-sectional, case-control study. PARTICIPANTS: We sequentially enrolled 499 patients with glaucoma and 444 normal subjects to analyze relative precision. A separate group of 44 patients with glaucoma and 54 normal subjects was analyzed to assess test-retest variability. METHODS: One eye of recruited subjects was tested with the index tests: HFA (Swedish interactive thresholding algorithm [SITA] standard strategy) and CMP (Zippy Estimation by Sequential Testing [ZEST] strategy), 24-2 grid. The reference test for GON was specialist evaluation of fundus photographs or OCT, independent of the visual field (VF). For both devices, linear regression was used to calculate the sensitivity decrease with age in the normal group to compute pointwise total deviation (TD) values and mean deviation (MD). We derived 5% and 1% pointwise normative limits. The MD and the total number of TD values below 5% (TD 5%) or 1% (TD 1%) limits per field were used as classifiers. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: We used partial receiver operating characteristic (pROC) curves and partial area under the curve (pAUC) to compare the diagnostic precision of the devices. Pointwise mean absolute deviation and Bland-Altman plots for the mean sensitivity (MS) were computed to assess test-retest variability. RESULTS: Retinal sensitivity was generally lower with CMP, with an average mean difference of 1.85±0.06 decibels (dB) (mean ± standard error, P < 0.001) in healthy subjects and 1.46±0.05 dB (mean ± standard error, P < 0.001) in patients with glaucoma. Both devices showed similar discriminative power. The MD metric had marginally better discrimination with CMP (pAUC difference ± standard error, 0.019±0.009, P = 0.035). The 95% limits of agreement for the MS were reduced by 13% in CMP compared with HFA in participants with glaucoma and by 49% in normal participants. Mean absolute deviation was similar, with no significant differences. CONCLUSIONS: Relative diagnostic precision of the 2 devices is equivalent. Test-retest variability of MS for CMP was better than for HFA.

来源:Ophthalmology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Montesano G, Bryan SR, Crabb DP, et al. A Comparison between the Compass Fundus Perimeter and the Humphrey Field Analyzer. Ophthalmology. 2018. PMID: 30114416. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2018.08.010

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。