Spot与SW800筛查仪在中国4-6岁儿童中的性能比较
结果显示两型仪器与检影验光均呈强相关,Spot与SW800检出弱视危险因素的灵敏度分别为94.0%和88.8%,特异度分别为80.0%和81.1%,ROC分析提示两者性能相近。
要点
- Spot与SW800的屈光及水平偏斜测量与睫状肌麻痹检影、三棱镜遮盖试验均强相关。
- Spot检出弱视危险因素灵敏度94.0%、特异度80.0%;SW800为88.8%和81.1%。
- ROC分析显示两型筛查仪检出弱视危险因素的总体性能非常接近。
核心结论
- Spot与SW800的测量结果与睫状肌麻痹检影验光和棱镜遮盖试验高度一致,两型筛查仪检出弱视危险因素的表现均令人满意且性能相近。
主要发现
- Spot与检影验光呈强线性一致:SE的r=0.95、DS的r=0.97、DC的r=0.84、Hdev的r=0.91,SE总体近视漂移-0.17 D。
- SW800与检影验光显著相关:SE的r=0.90、DS的r=0.93、DC的r=0.82、Hdev的r=0.80,SE总体近视漂移-0.12 D。
- Spot检出弱视危险因素的总体灵敏度和特异度分别为94.0%和80.0%,SW800分别为88.8%和81.1%。
关键数值与推荐
- 弱视危险因素检出按美国小儿眼科与斜视协会(AAPOS)2013年指南判定。
- Spot与SW800的各项相关性检验均p<0.01。
临床怎么用
- 在4-6岁中国儿童中,Spot与SW800均可作为弱视危险因素的筛查工具,结果与睫状肌麻痹检影验光及棱镜遮盖试验一致性良好。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To evaluate the effectiveness of Spot photoscreener and SW800 vision screener in detecting amblyopia risk factors in Chinese children between 4 and 6 years of age. METHODS: One hundred and thirteen children (226 eyes) underwent complete ophthalmologic examination, cycloplegic retinoscopy refraction, prism cover tests and photoscreen using both Spot (v2.1.4) and SW800 (v1.0.1.0) photoscreeners. The agreement of results obtained from photoscreener and retinoscopy was evaluated by paired t-test as well as Pearson correlation test. The sensitivity and specificity of detecting amblyopia risk factors were calculated based on the American Association of Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus 2013 guidelines. The overall effectiveness of detecting amblyopia risk factors by using either photoscreener was analysed by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves. RESULTS: A strong linear agreement was observed between Spot and retinoscopy (p<0.01) in aspects of spherical equivalent (SE, Pearson's r=0.95), dioptre sphere (DS, r=0.97), dioptre cylinder (DC, r=0.84) and horizontal deviation (Hdev, r=0.91), with overall -0.17 D myopic shift of SE. Significant correlation was also shown between SW800 and retinoscopy (p<0.01) in aspects of SE (r=0.90), DS (r=0.93), DC (r=0.82) and Hdev (r=0.80), with overall -0.12 D myopic shift of SE. The overall sensitivity and specificity in detecting amblyopia risk factors were 94.0% and 80.0% for Spot and 88.8% and 81.1% for SW800. CONCLUSION: The measurements of Spot and SW800 photoscreener showed a strong agreement with cycloplegic retinoscopy refraction and prism cover tests. The performance of both screeners in detecting individual amblyopia risk factors is satisfactory. ROC analysis indicates that the Spot and SW800 performed very similarly in detecting amblyopia risk factors.
引用
- Qian X, Li Y, Ding G, et al. Compared performance of Spot and SW800 photoscreeners on Chinese children. Br J Ophthalmol. 2018. PMID: 29986946. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2018-311885
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。