2016年美国眼科学会成人白内障首选实践模式指南可靠证据的识别与描述
该横断面研究检索了白内障管理的系统综述,用预设标准评估其可靠性,并映射到2011年AAO成人白内障PPP指南的24个管理类别。99篇系统综述中46篇(46%)被归类为可靠,全部46篇均被2016年AAO PPP指南引用;2010年2月前发表的15篇可靠综述中8篇(53%)被2011年PPP指南引用。Cochrane Eyes and Vision US Satellite与AAO的合作提供了相关可靠系统综述的证据基础,支持稳健高效的临床实践指南制定。
要点
- 99篇白内障管理系统综述中46篇(46%)被归类为可靠。
- 未显示进行全面检索是综述被归类为不可靠的最常见原因。
- 全部46篇可靠系统综述均被2016年AAO PPP指南引用。
核心结论
- Cochrane Eyes and Vision US Satellite与AAO的合作使AAO获得相关可靠系统综述的证据基础,从而支持稳健高效的临床实践指南制定以改善眼科医疗质量。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,检索白内障管理系统综述,将每篇相关系统综述映射到2011年AAO PPP指南管理部分24个管理类别中的1个或多个,用预设标准提取数据判定可靠性,并检查可靠系统综述是否被2016年AAO PPP指南引用。
主要发现
- 从99篇白内障管理系统综述中,46篇(46%)被归类为可靠。
- 未显示进行全面检索是综述被归类为不可靠的最常见原因。
- 全部46篇可靠系统综述均被2016年AAO PPP指南引用。
- 2010年2月前发表的15篇可靠综述中8篇(53%)被2011年PPP指南引用。
关键数值与推荐
- 系统综述可靠性定义为:报告纳入标准、进行全面文献检索、评估纳入研究的方法学质量、使用适当的荟萃分析方法、基于综述发现得出结论。
临床怎么用
- Cochrane Eyes and Vision US Satellite与AAO的合作可提供相关可靠系统综述的证据基础,支持稳健高效的临床实践指南制定。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Trustworthy clinical practice guidelines require reliable systematic reviews of the evidence to support recommendations. Since 2016, the American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO) has partnered with Cochrane Eyes and Vision US Satellite to update their guidelines, the Preferred Practice Patterns (PPP). OBJECTIVE: To describe experiences and findings related to identifying reliable systematic reviews that support topics likely to be addressed in the 2016 update of the 2011 AAO PPP guidelines on cataract in the adult eye. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Cross-sectional study. Systematic reviews on the management of cataract were searched for in an established database. Each relevant systematic review was mapped to 1 or more of the 24 management categories listed under the Management section of the table of contents of the 2011 AAO PPP guidelines. Data were extracted to determine the reliability of each systematic review using prespecified criteria, and the reliable systematic reviews were examined to find whether they were referenced in the 2016 AAO PPP guidelines. For comparison, we assessed whether the reliable systematic reviews published before February 2010 the last search date of the 2011 AAO PPP guidelines were referenced in the 2011 AAO PPP guidelines. Cochrane Eyes and Vision US Satellite did not provide systematic reviews to the AAO during the development of the 2011 AAO PPP guidelines. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Systematic review reliability was defined by reporting eligibility criteria, performing a comprehensive literature search, assessing methodologic quality of included studies, using appropriate methods for meta-analysis, and basing conclusions on review findings. RESULTS: From 99 systematic reviews on management of cataract, 46 (46%) were classified as reliable. No evidence that a comprehensive search had been conducted was the most common reason a review was classified as unreliable. All 46 reliable systematic reviews were cited in the 2016 AAO PPP guidelines, and 8 of 15 available reliable reviews (53%) were cited in the 2011 PPP guidelines. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: The partnership between Cochrane Eyes and Vision US Satellite and the AAO provides the AAO access to an evidence base of relevant and reliable systematic reviews, thereby supporting robust and efficient clinical practice guidelines development to improve the quality of eye care.
引用
- Golozar A, Chen Y, Lindsley K, et al. Identification and Description of Reliable Evidence for 2016 American Academy of Ophthalmology Preferred Practice Pattern Guidelines for Cataract in the Adult Eye. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2018. PMID: 29800249. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2018.0786
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。