青光眼专科医师视盘缘、盘沿缘与盘沿宽度判读不一致
本研究为观察者间可靠性分析,5名青光眼专科医师对214例青光眼或高眼压受试者的立体照片判读视盘缘与盘沿缘,并按12个30度扇区计算盘沿宽度与杯盘比。结果显示盘沿缘与盘沿宽度的变异较大,扇区杯盘比组内相关系数为0.566至0.668,提示专科医师间判读不一致常见且程度可观。
要点
- 各扇区盘沿宽度中位变异系数为26%至30%,盘沿缘半径为20%至25%。
- 扇区杯盘比组内相关系数范围为0.566至0.668。
- 至少1名医师怀疑盘沿变薄的1724个扇区中,仅499个(29%)5名医师杯盘比均≥0.7。
核心结论
- 在本研究中,青光眼专科医师对视盘缘、盘沿缘与盘沿宽度的判读不一致常见且程度可观,即使在怀疑盘沿变薄的扇区亦然。
研究设计与样本
- 观察者间可靠性分析,5名青光眼专科医师判读214例青光眼或高眼压受试者的立体照片,并数字标记视盘缘与盘沿缘。
主要发现
- 各扇区中位变异系数:视盘缘半径3%至5%,盘沿缘半径20%至25%,盘沿宽度26%至30%。
- 扇区杯盘比组内相关系数范围为0.566至0.668。
- 至少1名医师怀疑盘沿变薄(杯盘比≥0.7)的1724个扇区中,5名医师杯盘比均≥0.7者仅499个(29%),5名医师中有2名未检出盘沿变薄(杯盘比<0.7)者442个(26%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 盘沿变薄的可疑标准为杯盘比≥0.7。
- 各扇区中位变异系数:视盘缘半径3%至5%,盘沿缘半径20%至25%,盘沿宽度26%至30%。
- 扇区杯盘比组内相关系数为0.566至0.668。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To quantify the variability of 5 glaucoma specialists' optic disc margin (DM), rim margin (RM), and rim width (RW) estimates. DESIGN: Inter-observer reliability analysis. METHODS: Clinicians viewed stereo-photographs from 214 subjects with glaucoma or ocular hypertension and digitally marked the DM and RM. For each photograph, the centroid of each clinician's DM was calculated, and an averaged DMcentroid was determined. The axis between the DMcentroid and the fovea was used to establish 12 30-degree sectors. Measurements from the DMcentroid to each clinician's DM (DMradius) and RM (RMradius) were used to generate a RW (DMradius-RMradius) and cup-to-disc ratio (CDR) (RMradius/DMradius) by sector. Parameter means, standard deviations, and coefficient of variations (COVs) were calculated across all clinicians for each eye. Parameter means for each clinician, and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC), were calculated across all eyes by sector. RESULTS: Among all eyes, the median COV by sector ranged from 3% to 5% for DMradius, 20% to 25% for RMradius, and 26% to 30% for RW. Sectoral ICCs for CDR ranged from 0.566 to 0.668. Sectors suspicious for rim thinning by 1 clinician were frequently overlooked by others. Among 1724 sectors in which at least 1 clinician was suspicious for rim thinning (CDR ≥ 0.7), all 5 clinicians' CDRs were ≥ 0.7 in only 499 (29%), and 2 of the 5 clinicians failed to detect rim thinning (CDR < 0.7) in 442 (26%). CONCLUSION: In this study, glaucoma specialist RM, DM, and RW discordance was frequent and substantial, even in sectors that were suspicious for rim thinning.
引用
- Hong SW, Koenigsman H, Ren R, et al. Glaucoma Specialist Optic Disc Margin, Rim Margin, and Rim Width Discordance in Glaucoma and Glaucoma Suspect Eyes. Am J Ophthalmol. 2018. PMID: 29750947. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2018.04.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。