早产儿视网膜病变附加病变:眼别诊断与象限诊断的准确性与可靠性比较
这项多中心队列研究纳入141例早产儿的197张广角视网膜图像,比较6名分级者采用眼别整体评估与四象限分级组合两种方式诊断附加病变的可靠性及准确性。结果显示象限诊断的评分者间一致性低于眼别诊断,且部分分级者存在诊断不足,提示眼别诊断在可靠性和准确性上可能更具优势。
要点
- 象限诊断的评分者间一致性低于眼别诊断(Fleiss κ 0.55 vs 0.75)。
- 6名分级者两种诊断方式的一致性差异较大(Cohen κ 范围0.32-0.75)。
- 4名分级者象限诊断较眼别诊断存在附加病变诊断不足。
核心结论
- 分级者采用四象限分级组合诊断附加病变的可靠性和准确性均低于眼别整体诊断,提示眼别诊断可能更具优势。
- 该结果对附加病变「≥2个象限」标准的精确化定义、临床诊疗、计算机图像分析及所有管理早产儿视网膜病变的眼科医生培训均有启示。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心队列研究,建立来自9家学术机构新生儿重症监护病房的141例早产儿共197张广角视网膜图像数据库,入组时间为2011年7月至2016年12月。
- 每张图像依据基于图像和临床诊断的共识确定参考标准诊断,数据分析时间为2017年2月至2017年9月。
- 6名分级者以随机顺序独立诊断197只眼的4个象限(裁剪图像,象限诊断)及整张图像(眼别诊断);象限诊断在事后组合各象限分级、≥2个象限诊断为附加病变时判定为附加病变。
主要发现
- 141例早产儿中女性65例(46.1%)、白人116例(82.3%),平均(SD)胎龄27.0(2.6)周。
- 6名分级者眼别诊断与象限诊断之间的一致性存在差异(Cohen κ 范围0.32-0.75)。
- 4名分级者象限诊断较眼别诊断存在附加病变诊断不足(McNemar检验)。
- 象限诊断的评分者间一致性低于眼别诊断(Fleiss κ 0.55 [95%CI 0.51-0.59] vs 0.75 [95%CI 0.71-0.78])。
- 眼别诊断与参考标准诊断的准确性为中等至接近完全一致,而象限诊断的准确性对每名分级者仅为中等至中等偏上。
关键数值与推荐
- 附加病变的象限诊断标准为:事后组合各象限分级后,≥2个象限诊断为附加病变。
- 象限诊断评分者间一致性Fleiss κ为0.55(95%CI 0.51-0.59),眼别诊断为0.75(95%CI 0.71-0.78)。
- 眼别诊断与象限诊断之间6名分级者的Cohen κ范围为0.32-0.75。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出眼别诊断在可靠性和准确性上可能优于象限诊断,对附加病变「≥2个象限」标准的精确化定义、临床诊疗、计算机图像分析及眼科医生培训均有启示。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Presence of plus disease in retinopathy of prematurity is the most critical element in identifying treatment-requiring disease. However, there is significant variability in plus disease diagnosis. In particular, plus disease has been defined as 2 or more quadrants of vascular abnormality, and it is not clear whether it is more reliably and accurately diagnosed by eye-based assessment of overall retinal appearance or by quadrant-based assessment combining grades of 4 individual quadrants. OBJECTIVE: To compare eye-based vs quadrant-based diagnosis of plus disease and to provide insight for ophthalmologists about the diagnostic process. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In this multicenter cohort study, we developed a database of 197 wide-angle retinal images from 141 preterm infants from neonatal intensive care units at 9 academic institutions (enrolled from July 2011 to December 2016). Each image was assigned a reference standard diagnosis based on consensus image-based and clinical diagnosis. Data analysis was performed from February 2017 to September 2017. INTERVENTIONS: Six graders independently diagnosed each of the 4 quadrants (cropped images) of the 197 eyes (quadrant-based diagnosis) as well as the entire image (eye-based diagnosis). Images were displayed individually, in random order. Quadrant-based diagnosis of plus disease was made when 2 or more quadrants were diagnosed as indicating plus disease by combining grades of individual quadrants post hoc. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Intragrader and intergrader reliability (absolute agreement and κ statistic) and accuracy compared with the reference standard diagnosis. RESULTS: Of the 141 included preterm infants, 65 (46.1%) were female and 116 (82.3%) white, and the mean (SD) gestational age was 27.0 (2.6) weeks. There was variable agreement between eye-based and quadrant-based diagnosis among the 6 graders (Cohen κ range, 0.32-0.75). Four graders showed underdiagnosis of plus disease with quadrant-based diagnosis compared with eye-based diagnosis (by McNemar test). Intergrader agreement of quadrant-based diagnosis was lower than that of eye-based diagnosis (Fleiss κ, 0.75 [95% CI, 0.71-0.78] vs 0.55 [95% CI, 0.51-0.59]). The accuracy of eye-based diagnosis compared with the reference standard diagnosis was substantial to near-perfect, whereas that of quadrant-based plus disease diagnosis was only moderate to substantial for each grader. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Graders had lower reliability and accuracy using quadrant-based diagnosis combining grades of individual quadrants than with eye-based diagnosis, suggesting that eye-based diagnosis has advantages over quadrant-based diagnosis. This has implications for more precise definitions of plus disease regarding the criterion of 2 or more quadrants, clinical care, computer-based image analysis, and education for all ophthalmologists who manage retinopathy of prematurity.
引用
- Kim SJ, Campbell JP, Kalpathy-Cramer J, et al. Accuracy and Reliability of Eye-Based vs Quadrant-Based Diagnosis of Plus Disease in Retinopathy of Prematurity. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2018. PMID: 29710185. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2018.1195
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。