文献速递白内障与屈光手术角膜与眼表疾病

2006年至2015年美国眼科医疗职业责任索赔审查

Review of Ophthalmology Medical Professional Liability Claims in the United States from 2006 through 2015.
PubMed 文献 · Ophthalmology · 2018-01-17

该研究回顾性分析了2006至2015年美国医师保险公司协会数据共享项目中已结案的眼科医疗职业责任索赔特征,并与全部医疗专科比较。眼科索赔占已结案索赔的2.6%,仅24%结案索赔导致赔付,白内障和角膜手术是最常见且赔付总额最高的手术类别。作者认为需进一步研究白内障和角膜手术索赔更常见及角膜手术平均赔付更高的原因。

要点

  • 2006至2015年眼科已结案索赔仅24%导致赔付,三分之二被撤销、撤回或驳回。
  • 白内障和角膜手术合计占眼科索赔的50%,赔付总额分别为47,641,376美元和32,570,148美元。
  • 角膜手术平均赔付304,476美元,高于玻璃体视网膜手术的270,141美元。

核心结论

  • 与其他医疗专科相比,眼科报告的医疗事故索赔数量相对较少,平均赔付和辩护支出也较少。
  • 作者认为需进一步研究白内障和角膜手术相关索赔更常见以及角膜手术平均赔付高于玻璃体视网膜或眼整形手术的原因。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析2006年至2015年美国医师保险公司协会(PIAA)数据共享项目(DSP)中已结案的医疗职业责任(MPL)索赔,比较眼科与全部医疗专科的医师人口学、已结案索赔的患病率和费用及索赔解决情况。
  • 2006年至2015年共结案90,743例医疗职业责任索赔,其中2.6%(2325/90,743)的已结案索赔和2.2%(564/24,670)的所有赔付索赔针对眼科医师。
  • 比较2006至2010年与2011至2015年两个时期眼科索赔中最常见的首席医疗因素、就诊医疗状况、手术操作、结局和解决情况。

主要发现

  • 针对眼科医师的已结案索赔中仅24%导致赔付,三分之二被撤销、撤回或驳回,获得裁决的索赔中90%对眼科医师有利。
  • 白内障和角膜手术是最常见且费用最高的手术操作,分别占所有索赔的50%,赔付总额分别为47,641,376美元和32,570,148美元。
  • 角膜手术的平均赔付(304,476美元)高于玻璃体视网膜手术(270,141美元)、眼睑眼整形手术(222,471美元)或眼眶和眼球眼整形手术(183,467美元)。
  • 眼内炎相关索赔的患病率和费用从2006至2010年(n=38/1160[3.3%];平均赔付516,875美元)下降至2011至2015年(n=26/1165[2.2%];平均赔付247,083美元)。
  • 与全部医疗专科相比,眼科医师的平均赔付(280,227美元 vs. 335,578美元)和法律辩护支出(41,450美元 vs. 46,391美元)略低。

关键数值与推荐

  • 眼科已结案索赔导致赔付的比例为24%。
  • 获得裁决的索赔中90%对眼科医师有利。
  • 白内障手术赔付总额47,641,376美元,角膜手术赔付总额32,570,148美元,分别占所有索赔的50%。
  • 角膜手术平均赔付304,476美元,玻璃体视网膜手术270,141美元,眼睑眼整形手术222,471美元,眼眶和眼球眼整形手术183,467美元。
  • 眼内炎相关索赔2006至2010年n=38/1160(3.3%)、平均赔付516,875美元,2011至2015年n=26/1165(2.2%)、平均赔付247,083美元。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: To describe characteristics of closed medical professional liability (MPL) claims against ophthalmologists in the United States. DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of MPL claims from 2006-2015. Data were obtained from the Physician Insurers Association of America (PIAA) Data Sharing Project (DSP). Comparison was made between ophthalmology and all healthcare specialties for physician demographics, prevalence and costs associated with closed claims, and resolution of claims. The most prevalent chief medical factor, presenting medical condition, operative procedure, outcomes, and resolution of ophthalmology claims were compared between the 2006-2010 and 2011-2015 periods. PARTICIPANTS: From 2006-2015, 90 743 MPL claims were closed: 2.6% (2325/90 743) of closed claims and 2.2% (564/24 670) of all paid claims were against ophthalmologists. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of MPL claims captured by the PIAA DSP over a 10-year period. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Subspecialty pertaining to the claim, number of claims closed and paid, indemnity paid, allocated loss adjustment expenses, chief medical factor, presenting medical condition, operative procedure, outcome, and resolution. RESULTS: Only 24% of closed claims against ophthalmologists resulted in payment. Two-thirds were dropped, withdrawn, or dismissed. Ninety percent of claims that received a verdict were favorable toward the ophthalmologist. Cataract and cornea surgeries were the most prevalent and most costly operative procedures, accounting for 50% of all claims and $47 641 376 and $32 570 148 in total paid indemnity, respectively. Average indemnity was higher for corneal procedures ($304 476) than vitreoretinal procedures ($270 141) or oculoplastic procedures on the eyelid ($222 471) or orbit and eyeball ($183 467). The prevalence and cost of claims related to endophthalmitis declined from 2006-2010 (n = 38/1160 [3.3%]; average indemnity, $516 875) period to the 2011-2015 (n = 26/1165 [2.2%]; average indemnity, $247 083) period. Average indemnity paid ($280 227 vs. $335 578) and amount spent on legal defense ($41 450 vs. $46 391) was slightly lower among ophthalmologists compared with all healthcare specialties, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Ophthalmology has a relatively low number of malpractice claims reported compared with other healthcare specialties and shows less spending on average indemnity and defense. Further studies are needed to investigate the reasons for the higher prevalence of claims related to cataract and corneal surgeries and the higher average indemnity paid for corneal procedures relative to vitreoretinal or oculoplastic procedures.

来源:Ophthalmology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Thompson AC, Parikh PD, Lad EM, et al. Review of Ophthalmology Medical Professional Liability Claims in the United States from 2006 through 2015. Ophthalmology. 2018. PMID: 29342439. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2017.11.018

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。