儿童青光眼不同最优视野检测方法的质量与输出比较
这项横断面观察性研究前瞻性招募了65名5至15岁青光眼患儿(108只患眼),在伦敦两家三级儿童眼科中心比较Humphrey静态视野与Octopus静态/动态联合视野的检测质量与结果。结果显示10岁以上儿童两种策略质量相当,而10岁以下儿童Humphrey静态视野质量更优;静态视野分类评分高度一致,但Octopus静态视野在31%的检测中评为更严重缺损。
要点
- 10岁以上儿童中Humphrey与Octopus视野检测质量相当(McNemar检验,χ2=0.33;P=.56)。
- 10岁以下儿童中Humphrey视野检测质量更优(McNemar检验,χ2=4.0;P=.05)。
- 7例严重视野缺损(5级)中5例动态视野分类评分低于静态视野。
核心结论
- 简单的静态视野检测方法可能在10岁以下儿童中获得高质量结果。
- 对于10岁以上儿童,在不影响质量的前提下,增加动态视野可测量远周边敏感度,对严重视野受限的儿童尤其有用。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面观察性研究,于2013年5月至2015年6月在伦敦两家三级儿童眼科中心(Moorfields Eye Hospital和Great Ormond Street Hospital)前瞻性招募儿童。
- 纳入65名5至15岁青光眼患儿,共108只患眼;由单一检查者按标准化临床方案在一次坐位中完成视野检测。
- 检测方法包括Humphrey静态视野(Swedish Interactive Thresholding Algorithm 24-2 FAST)和Octopus静态趋向性视野/动态视野联合检测(等视线V4e、III4e或I4e)。
- 对19名参与者中的一只患眼用Swedish Interactive Thresholding Algorithm 24-2 FAST和24-2标准算法进行重测。
主要发现
- 65名儿童中女孩33名(50.8%),中位年龄12岁(四分位距9-14岁)。
- Humphrey和Octopus策略的检测质量(Examiner-Based Assessment of Reliability评分)均随年龄增长而改善。
- Octopus与Humphrey静态MD值在劣于或等于-6 dB时存在不一致(Bland-Altman平均差-0.70,一致性界限-7.74至6.35),高于此阈值时具有可比性(平均差-0.03,一致性界限-2.33至2.27)。
- 静态视野检测的视野分类评分显示高度一致(线性加权κ=0.79;95%CI 0.65-0.93),但80次中有25次(31%)Octopus静态视野评为更严重缺损。
- 7例严重视野缺损(5级)中,5例动态视野分类评分低于静态视野。
关键数值与推荐
- 10岁以上儿童两种策略检测质量相当(McNemar检验,χ2=0.33;P=.56)。
- 10岁以下儿童Humphrey视野检测质量更优(McNemar检验,χ2=4.0;P=.05)。
- 静态视野分类评分一致性线性加权κ=0.79(95%CI 0.65-0.93)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论认为简单静态视野检测方法可能在10岁以下儿童中获得高质量结果。
- 原文结论认为对10岁以上儿童增加动态视野可在不牺牲质量的情况下测量远周边敏感度,对严重视野受限儿童尤其有用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: There is limited evidence to support the development of guidance for visual field testing in children with glaucoma. OBJECTIVE: To compare different static and combined static/kinetic perimetry approaches in children with glaucoma. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Cross-sectional, observational study recruiting children prospectively between May 2013 and June 2015 at 2 tertiary specialist pediatric ophthalmology centers in London, England (Moorfields Eye Hospital and Great Ormond Street Hospital). The study included 65 children aged 5 to 15 years with glaucoma (108 affected eyes). MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: A comparison of test quality and outcomes for static and combined static/kinetic techniques, with respect to ability to quantify glaucomatous loss. Children performed perimetric assessments using Humphrey static (Swedish Interactive Thresholding Algorithm 24-2 FAST) and Octopus combined static tendency-oriented perimetry/kinetic perimetry (isopter V4e, III4e, or I4e) in a single sitting, using standardized clinical protocols, administered by a single examiner. Information was collected about test duration, completion, and quality (using automated reliability indices and our qualitative Examiner-Based Assessment of Reliability score). Perimetry outputs were scored using the Aulhorn and Karmeyer classification. One affected eye in 19 participants was retested with Swedish Interactive Thresholding Algorithm 24-2 FAST and 24-2 standard algorithms. RESULTS: Sixty-five children (33 girls [50.8%]), with a median age of 12 years (interquartile range, 9-14 years), were tested. Test quality (Examiner-Based Assessment of Reliability score) improved with increasing age for both Humphrey and Octopus strategies and were equivalent in children older than 10 years (McNemar test, χ2 = 0.33; P = .56), but better-quality tests with Humphrey perimetry were achieved in younger children (McNemar test, χ2 = 4.0; P = .05). Octopus and Humphrey static MD values worse than or equal to -6 dB showed disagreement (Bland-Altman, mean difference, -0.70; limit of agreement, -7.74 to 6.35) but were comparable when greater than this threshold (mean difference, -0.03; limit of agreement, -2.33 to 2.27). Visual field classification scores for static perimetry tests showed substantial agreement (linearly weighted κ, 0.79; 95% CI, 0.65-0.93), although 25 of 80 (31%) were graded with a more severe defect for Octopus static perimetry. Of the 7 severe cases of visual field loss (grade 5), 5 had lower kinetic than static classification scores. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: A simple static perimetry approach potentially yields high-quality results in children younger than 10 years. For children older than 10 years, without penalizing quality, the addition of kinetic perimetry enabled measurement of far-peripheral sensitivity, which is particularly useful in children with severe visual field restriction.
引用
- Patel DE, Cumberland PM, Walters BC, et al. Comparison of Quality and Output of Different Optimal Perimetric Testing Approaches in Children With Glaucoma. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2018. PMID: 29285534. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2017.5898
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。