角膜胶原交联前后圆锥角膜进展速率的对比评估
本研究对比圆锥角膜在角膜胶原交联(CXL)前后的疾病进展速率,145只眼未行CXL随访中位31个月,45只眼在加速去上皮CXL前后共随访41个月。结果显示CXL前组多项角膜参数进展速率与未CXL组有统计学差异,CXL后进展速率与未CXL组相当,未CXL组全部角膜参数在随访期间保持稳定。
要点
- CXL前组与未CXL组在前表面平坦角膜曲率、前表面平均角膜曲率、后表面平坦角膜曲率、后表面平均角膜曲率的进展速率上有统计学显著差异(P≤0.045)。
- CXL后组进展速率与未CXL组相当,未CXL组全部角膜参数在随访期间保持稳定。
- 作者认为,对于角膜参数随时间稳定的病例,可考虑密切监测而非胶原交联。
核心结论
- 系列断层扫描检查有助于记录CXL前后的疾病进展;本研究中CXL后角膜参数进展速率下降;对于角膜参数随时间稳定的病例,可考虑密切监测而非胶原交联。
研究设计与样本
- 145只眼未行CXL(未CXL组)随访中位31个月,45只眼在加速去上皮CXL前(CXL前组)和CXL后(CXL后组)共随访41个月。
- 采用扫频源光学相干断层扫描测量前表面陡峭角膜曲率、前表面平坦角膜曲率、前表面平均角膜曲率、后表面陡峭角膜曲率、后表面平坦角膜曲率、后表面平均角膜曲率及角膜厚度。
- 进展定义为线性混合效应模型对时间发现的显著斜率。
主要发现
- CXL前组患者年龄26.3±5.48岁,显著年轻于未CXL组的32.7±10.24岁(P=0.004)。
- 基线检查时,除前表面柱镜和后表面柱镜外,CXL前组与未CXL组所有参数均有显著差异(P≤0.035)。
- 观察期间,CXL前组与未CXL组在前表面平坦角膜曲率、前表面平均角膜曲率、后表面平坦角膜曲率、后表面平均角膜曲率的进展速率上有统计学显著差异(P≤0.045)。
- CXL后组进展速率与未CXL组相当,未CXL组全部角膜参数在整个随访期间保持稳定。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,对于角膜参数随时间稳定的病例,可考虑密切监测而非胶原交联。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To compare the rate of disease progression in keratoconus before and after corneal collagen crosslinking (CXL). METHODS: 145 eyes were followed without CXL (no-CXL group) for a median duration of 31 months whereas 45 eyes were followed up for 41 months before (pre-CXL) and after (post-CXL) accelerated, epithelium-off crosslinking. Progression was defined based on significant slope found in linear mixed effect models against time. Swept-source optical coherence tomography was used for measurement of anterior steep keratometry, anterior flat keratometry (Ant Kf), anterior average keratometry (Ant Avg K); posterior steep keratometry, posteriorflat keratometry (Post Kf), posterior average keratometry (Post Avg K) and corneal thickness. RESULTS: The patients in pre-CXL group were significantly younger (26.3±5.48 years) compared with the patients in no-CXL group (32.7±10.24 years) (P=0.004). Significant differences were observed during baseline examination for all parameters (P≤0.035) between pre-CXL and no-CXL groups except Ant Cyl and Post Cyl. During observation period, statistically significant differences were noted between pre-CXL and no-CXL groups in the progression rate of Ant Kf, Ant Avg K, Post Kf and Post Avg K (P≤0.045). After CXL, the progression rate in post-CXL group was comparable to that in no-CXL group. All corneal parameters remained stable in no-CXL group throughout the follow-up period. CONCLUSIONS: Serial tomographic examination is useful to document disease progression before and after CXL. In our study, a decrease in progression rate of corneal parameters was noted after CXL. In cases with stable corneal parameters over time, careful monitoring can be considered instead of collagen crosslinking.
引用
- Wang YM, Chan TC, Yu MCY, et al. Comparative evaluation of progression rate in keratoconus before and after collagen crosslinking. Br J Ophthalmol. 2017. PMID: 29122823. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2017-311017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。