基于结构与功能工具评估青光眼谱系患者5年疾病进展
研究纳入122例成人青光眼可疑者与患者,比较SD-OCT的GPA-OCT与视野GPA及VFI在至少5年内检测进展的一致性。结果显示GPA-OCT在可疑者中检出进展更多,但与GPA一致性差;视野进展者在两组中RNFL厚度百分比变化相似,可疑者绝对变化更大。结论认为结构变化对可疑者进展检测更有用,功能变化在疾病进展后更好,RNFL百分比变化优于绝对变化。
要点
- 18例进展为青光眼的可疑者中,GPA-OCT检出13例,GPA检出4例,VFI检出7例。
- GPA-OCT与GPA在可疑者中一致性差(Kappa 0.15;p=0.13),在患者中亦差(Kappa 0.10;p=0.45)。
- 视野进展者中,可疑者RNFL绝对变化显著大于患者(-8.75µ vs -6.4µ p=0.03)。
核心结论
- 结构变化似乎对检测青光眼可疑者的进展更有用,而功能变化在疾病进展后是更好的指标。
- RNFL厚度较基线的百分比变化是比绝对变化更好的测量指标。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入基线时具有SD-OCT RNFL厚度和可靠Humphrey视野(HFA)检查的成人青光眼可疑者与患者,基线检查在2010年3月之前。
- 共纳入122名受试者,其中青光眼可疑者63例,青光眼患者59例。
- 比较至少5年内的功能与结构进展,分别使用HFA的GPA和VFI以及SD-OCT的GPA-OCT评估。
- 使用κ统计量计算两种模态检测进展的一致性。
主要发现
- 18例进展为青光眼的可疑者中,13例经GPA-OCT显示进展,4例经GPA显示进展,7例经VFI显示进展,2例一致。
- 14例进展的青光眼患者中,GPA-OCT检出6例进展,GPA检出5例,VFI检出6例。
- GPA-OCT与GPA在青光眼可疑者中一致性差(Kappa 0.15;p=0.13),在青光眼患者中一致性差(Kappa 0.10;p=0.45)。
- VFI与GPA-OCT在青光眼可疑者中一致性较好(Kappa 0.34;p=0.01),在青光眼患者中一致性差(Kappa 0.12;p=0.36)。
- 两组中经视野判定为进展者的RNFL厚度较基线百分比变化相似(-9.9% vs -8.6% p=0.46),但可疑者的绝对变化显著更大(-8.75µ vs -6.4µ p=0.03)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Assessment of spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) compared with visual fields, to detect progression across the glaucoma spectrum. METHODS: In this study, adult glaucoma suspects and patients, with baseline retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) thickness on SD-OCT and reliable visual field (VF) tests on Humphrey Field Analyser (HFA) prior to March 2010, were recruited. Functional and structural progression over at least 5 years was compared using Glaucoma Progression Analysis (GPA) and VF index (VFI) on HFA and Guided Progression Analysis (GPA-OCT) on SD-OCT, respectively. Agreement of progression detection between the two modalities was computed using κ statistics. RESULTS: 122 subjects (63 glaucoma suspects; 59 glaucoma patients) were enrolled. Of 18 suspects who progressed to glaucoma, 13 showed progression by GPA-OCT, 4 by GPA, 7 by VFI and 2 were concordant. In the 14 glaucoma patients who progressed, GPA-OCT detected progression in 6, GPA in five and VFI in six. GPA-OCT had poor agreement with GPA in glaucoma suspects (Kappa 0.15; p=0.13) and patients (Kappa 0.10; p=0.45). VFI had better agreement with GPA-OCT in glaucoma suspects (Kappa 0.34; p=0.01) than glaucoma patients (Kappa 0.12; p=0.36). Progressors by VF in both groups had similar percentage change from baseline RNFL thickness (-9.9% vs -8.6% p=0.46), even though the absolute change was significantly greater in suspects(-8.75µ vs-6.4µ p=0.03). CONCLUSION: Structural change appears to be more useful to detect progression in glaucoma suspects, while functional change is a better indicator as the disease progresses. Percentage change from baseline RNFL thickness was a better measure than absolute change in RNFL.
引用
- Seth NG, Kaushik S, Kaur S, et al. 5-year disease progression of patients across the glaucoma spectrum assessed by structural and functional tools. Br J Ophthalmol. 2017. PMID: 28939691. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2017-310731
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。