比较光学相干断层扫描径向与立方扫描模式测量青光眼及健康眼Bruch膜开口最小边缘宽度的横断面与纵向分析
纳入60只健康眼和189只青光眼眼,用Spectralis SD-OCT采集视神经乳头立方与径向扫描,比较两种扫描模式测量的Bruch膜开口最小边缘宽度(BMO-MRW)的诊断准确性和变化率。立方扫描BMO-MRW显著小于径向扫描,但两者检测青光眼的AUC均为0.90,BMO-MRW变化率无显著差异。结果提示两种扫描模式的BMO-MRW估计值不可互换,但均可用于纵向监测BMO-MRW变化。
要点
- 健康眼基线全局BMO-MRW:立方扫描301.9±57.8 µm vs 径向扫描334.7±61.8 µm,p<0.003。
- 青光眼眼基线全局BMO-MRW:立方扫描181.2±63.0 µm vs 径向扫描210.2±67.2 µm,p<0.001。
- 两种扫描模式区分健康眼与青光眼眼的AUC均为0.90,BMO-MRW年变化率无显著差异。
核心结论
- 立方扫描BMO-MRW显著小于径向扫描BMO-MRW,但两种扫描模式在检测青光眼、识别BMO位置及测量BMO-MRW变化率方面无显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面与纵向分析,纳入60只健康眼和189只青光眼眼,使用Spectralis SD-OCT采集视神经乳头立方与径向扫描,并用San Diego自动分层分割算法自动勾画BMO-MRW。
主要发现
- 健康眼基线全局BMO-MRW:立方扫描301.9±57.8 µm vs 径向扫描334.7±61.8 µm,p<0.003。
- 青光眼眼基线全局BMO-MRW:立方扫描181.2±63.0 µm vs 径向扫描210.2±67.2 µm,p<0.001。
- 区分健康眼与青光眼眼的受试者工作特征曲线下面积:径向扫描BMO-MRW为0.90,立方扫描BMO-MRW为0.90。
- 健康眼BMO-MRW变化率:立方扫描-1.47 µm/年 vs 径向扫描-1.53 µm/年,p=0.48,平均随访1.6年。
- 青光眼眼BMO-MRW变化率:立方扫描-2.37 µm/年 vs 径向扫描-2.28 µm/年,p=0.45,平均随访2.6年。
关键数值与推荐
- 健康眼基线全局BMO-MRW立方扫描301.9±57.8 µm vs 径向扫描334.7±61.8 µm(p<0.003)。
- 青光眼眼基线全局BMO-MRW立方扫描181.2±63.0 µm vs 径向扫描210.2±67.2 µm(p<0.001)。
- 区分健康眼与青光眼眼的AUC:径向扫描0.90,立方扫描0.90。
- 健康眼BMO-MRW变化率:立方扫描-1.47 µm/年 vs 径向扫描-1.53 µm/年(p=0.48),平均随访1.6年。
- 青光眼眼BMO-MRW变化率:立方扫描-2.37 µm/年 vs 径向扫描-2.28 µm/年(p=0.45),平均随访2.6年。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,两种扫描模式的BMO-MRW估计值不可互换,但均可用于监测BMO-MRW随时间的变化。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To compare the cube and radial scan patterns of the spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) for quantifying the Bruch's membrane opening minimum rim width (BMO-MRW). METHODS: Sixty healthy eyes and 189 glaucomatous eyes were included. The optic nerve head cube and radial pattern scans were acquired using Spectralis SD-OCT. BMO-MRWs were automatically delineated using the San Diego Automated Layer Segmentation Algorithm. The BMO-MRW diagnostic accuracy for glaucoma detection and rates of change derived from the two scan patterns were compared. RESULTS: There was a significant difference between the baseline global BMO-MRW measurements of cube and radial scans for healthy (301.9±57.8 µm and 334.7±61.8 µm, respectively, p<0.003) and glaucoma eyes (181.2±63.0 µm and 210.2±67.2 µm, respectively, p<0.001). The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for differentiating between healthy and glaucoma eyes was 0.90 for both the radial scan-based and cube scan-based BMO-MRW. No significant difference in the rate of BMO-MRW change (mean follow-up years) by scan pattern was found among both healthy (cube: -1.47 µm/year, radial: -1.53 µm/year; p=0.48) (1.6 years) and glaucoma eyes (cube: -2.37 µm/year, radial: -2.28 µm/year; p=0.45) (2.6 years). CONCLUSION: Although the cube scan-based BMO-MRW was significantly smaller than the radial scan-based BMO-MRW, we found no significant difference between the two scan patterns for detecting glaucoma, identifying BMO location and measuring the rate of BMO-MRW change. These results suggest that although BMO-MRW estimates are not interchangeable, both scan patterns can be used for monitoring BMO-MRW changes over time.
引用
- Kabbara SW, Zangwill LM, Mundae R, et al. Comparing optical coherence tomography radial and cube scan patterns for measuring Bruch's membrane opening minimum rim width (BMO-MRW) in glaucoma and healthy eyes: cross-sectional and longitudinal analysis. Br J Ophthalmol. 2017. PMID: 28774935. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2016-310111
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。