比较青光眼专家与受训者在立体视盘观察与MatchedFlicker程序下检测青光眼性视盘改变
该研究让3名青光眼专家、2名住院医师和1名青光眼进修医师使用手持立体观察器和MatchedFlicker程序评估同一140对图像(来自100只青光眼/高眼压眼),发现MatchedFlicker程序每对图像平均快8.6秒(26%),且正确识别更多图像对,专家与受训者在速度和总体准确性上无显著差异,但专家在重复图像对上一致性显著更高。
要点
- 使用MatchedFlicker程序较手持立体观察器每对图像平均快8.6秒(26%),p=0.0007。
- 使用MatchedFlicker程序正确识别的图像对更多,p=0.0003。
- 专家与受训者在两种方法的速度和总体准确性上无显著差异,但专家在重复图像对上一致性显著更高(p=0.029)。
核心结论
- 青光眼专家和各阶段受训眼科医生使用MatchedFlicker程序均比手持立体观察器具有更高的准确性和速度。
研究设计与样本
- 来自多家机构的3名经验丰富的青光眼专家、2名住院眼科医师和1名青光眼进修医师独立评估来自100只青光眼/高眼压眼的同一140对图像,使用手持立体观察器和MatchedFlicker程序。
主要发现
- 评估者使用MatchedFlicker程序每对图像平均快8.6秒(26%),相比立体观察器(p=0.0007)。
- 评估者使用MatchedFlicker软件比立体观察器正确识别更多图像对(p=0.0003)。
- 专家与受训者组在两种方法的速度或总体准确性上无显著差异。
- 专家在重复图像对上一致性显著高于受训者(p=0.029)。
- 受训者似乎比专家更不愿将眼别判定为显示青光眼进展。
关键数值与推荐
- 50只眼有进展,由Ocular Hypertension Treatment Study(OHTS)视盘阅读组和终点委员会确定;50只眼为无进展负对照,照片间隔数分钟拍摄。
- 每组20对照片被复制用于评估者变异性分析。
- 初始观察方法随机化,然后每70对图像组交替。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 受训者似乎比专家更不愿将眼别判定为显示青光眼进展。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND/AIMS: The objective of this study is to evaluate the accuracy and speed of trainees and experienced glaucoma specialists using the MatchedFlicker software against the manual examination of stereoscopic disc photographs for detecting glaucomatous optic disc change. METHODS: Three experienced glaucoma specialists, two resident ophthalmologists and one glaucoma fellow from multiple institutions independently evaluated the same 140 image pairs from 100 glaucomatous/ocular hypertensive eyes using a handheld stereo viewer and the MatchedFlicker programme. Fifty had progression to glaucoma as determined by the Ocular Hypertension Treatment Study (OHTS) Optic Disc Reading Group and endpoint committee, and 50 more were negative controls for progression with photos taken a few minutes apart. Twenty photo pairs from each of the two groups were duplicated for reviewer variability analysis. The initial viewing method was randomised and then alternated for each group of 70 image pairs. Reviewer accuracy and evaluation time for each method were measured. RESULTS: Evaluators averaged 8.6 s faster per image pair (26%) with the MatchedFlicker programme than with the stereo viewer (p=0.0007). Evaluators correctly identified more image pairs when using the MatchedFlicker software over the stereo viewer (p=0.0003). There was no significant difference between the expert and trainee group in speed or overall accuracy for either method. Experts were significantly more consistent than trainees with the duplicate image pairs (p=0.029). Trainees appeared more reluctant to designate eyes as showing glaucoma progression than experts. CONCLUSIONS: Both expert glaucoma specialists and ophthalmologists in various stages of training had greater accuracy and speed with the MatchedFlicker programme than with a handheld stereoscopic viewer.
引用
- Schaefer JL, Meyer AM, Rodgers CD, et al. Comparing glaucomatous disc change using stereo disc viewing and the MatchedFlicker programme in glaucoma experts and trainees. Br J Ophthalmol. 2017. PMID: 28814418. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2017-310336
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。