圆锥角膜筛查指数及其区分正常角膜与扩张性角膜的诊断能力
该研究纳入42只正常眼、37只亚临床圆锥角膜眼和51只圆锥角膜眼,比较Pentacam、Galilei和Sirius三种Scheimpflug设备筛查指数的诊断能力。三种设备参数均能有效区分圆锥角膜与正常角膜(AUC>0.9),但区分亚临床与正常角膜可能需要新的截断值。
要点
- Pentacam有6个参数诊断圆锥角膜灵敏度达100%,Galilei有1个,Sirius无参数达100%。
- Pentacam有2个参数诊断亚临床圆锥角膜灵敏度达100%,Galilei和Sirius无参数达100%。
- BAD-D与Galilei的KPI和Kprob(P=.27)及Sirius的4.5 mm RMS/A back(P=.55)AUC统计学相似。
核心结论
- 三种设备测量的圆锥角膜指数均能有效区分圆锥角膜与正常角膜,但区分亚临床与正常角膜可能需要新的截断值。
研究设计与样本
- 比较诊断仪器准确性的研究,纳入42只正常眼、37只亚临床圆锥角膜眼和51只圆锥角膜眼,评估Pentacam、Galilei和Sirius的圆锥角膜筛查指数。
主要发现
- 诊断圆锥角膜最高灵敏度(100%)见于Pentacam的6个参数和Galilei的1个参数,Sirius无参数达100%。
- 诊断亚临床圆锥角膜最高灵敏度(100%)见于Pentacam的2个参数,Galilei和Sirius无参数达100%。
- 所有参数区分圆锥角膜的AUC均>0.9。
- Pentacam的BAD-D和ISV的AUC与Galilei的KPI和Kprob统计学相似(P=.27),与Sirius的4.5 mm RMS/A back统计学相似(P=.55)。
- 区分亚临床与正常角膜时,BAD-D与Galilei的SRI统计学相似(P=.78),但显著大于Sirius的8 mm RMS/A back(P=.002)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To compare the diagnostic ability of 3 Scheimpflug devices in differentiating normal from ectatic corneas. DESIGN: Comparison of diagnostic instrument accuracy. METHODS: This study included 42 normal, 37 subclinical keratoconic, and 51 keratoconic eyes seen in a tertiary eye care institute. Keratoconus screening indices were evaluated using the Pentacam (Oculus, Wetzlar, Germany), Galilei (Ziemer, Biel, Switzerland), and Sirius (Costruzione Strumenti Oftalmici, Florence, Italy). Sensitivity, specificity, and area under receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) were calculated. RESULTS: Highest sensitivity (100%) to diagnose keratoconus was seen for 6 parameters on Pentacam and 1 on Galilei. None of the indices in Sirius reached 100% sensitivity. For subclinical keratoconus, the highest sensitivity (100%) was seen for 2 parameters on Pentacam but for none of them on Galilei and Sirius. All parameters were strong enough to differentiate keratoconus (AUC > 0.9). On comparing the best parameters of all 3 machines, the AUC of the Belin/Ambrosio enhanced ectasia total derivation (BAD-D) and the inferior-superior value (ISV) of Pentacam were statistically similar to that of the keratoconus prediction index (KPI) and keratoconus probability (Kprob) of Galilei (P = .27) and 4.5 mm root mean square per unit area (RMS/A) back of Sirius (P = .55). When differentiating subclinical from normal corneas, BAD-D was similar to the surface regularity index (SRI) of Galilei (P = .78) but was significantly greater than the 8 mm RMS/A back of Sirius (P = .002). CONCLUSION: Keratoconus indices measured by all 3 machines can effectively differentiate keratoconus from normal corneas. However, new cutoff values might be needed to differentiate subclinical from normal corneas.
引用
- Shetty R, Rao H, Khamar P, et al. Keratoconus Screening Indices and Their Diagnostic Ability to Distinguish Normal From Ectatic Corneas. Am J Ophthalmol. 2017. PMID: 28687218. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2017.06.031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。