基于证据的视野可靠性评估标准
该回顾性研究纳入909名疑似或确诊青光眼受试者的1538只眼共10262次视野检查,采用多水平模型分析假阳性、假阴性、固视丢失和检查时长对预测与实测平均偏差差值的影响,提出按疾病严重程度分层的视野可靠性分级标准。
要点
- 固视丢失对视野可靠性影响很小,任何疾病阶段均未产生≥1 dB的平均偏差差值。
- 假阳性导致实测平均偏差高于预测值,其影响随异常捕获试验比例和疾病严重程度变化。
- 假阴性和检查时长对可靠性有影响但相对较小,影响程度随疾病严重程度和异常捕获试验范围而异。
核心结论
- 固视丢失在已确诊青光眼患者中对视野可靠性影响很小,假阳性、其次假阴性和检查时长显著影响可靠性。
- 假阳性和假阴性的影响随疾病严重程度及异常捕获试验范围而变化。
- 基于研究发现,作者提出基于证据的、按严重程度分层的视野可靠性分级标准,用于临床或研究应用。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入909名疑似或确诊青光眼受试者的1538只眼共10262次视野检查,每只眼至少5次视野检查。
- 采用多水平模型对纵向数据计算预测平均偏差,以预测与实测平均偏差差值(ΔMD)作为可靠性指标。
- 采用多水平模型评估假阳性、假阴性、固视丢失和检查时长对ΔMD的影响。
主要发现
- 固视丢失对ΔMD影响很小,每10%异常捕获试验的ΔMD<0.2分贝(dB),任何疾病阶段均未产生≥1 dB的ΔMD。
- 假阳性在异常捕获试验≤20%时,每10%增量的ΔMD在轻度(MD>-6 dB)、中度(-6≤MD<-12 dB)和重度(-12≤MD≤-20 dB)疾病分别为0.42、0.73和0.66 dB;超过20%异常捕获试验时,ΔMD分别为1.57、2.06和3.53 dB。
- 假阴性在异常捕获试验≤20%时影响很小(各严重程度每10%增量ΔMD>-0.14 dB);超过20%异常捕获试验时,每10%增量的ΔMD在轻度、中度和重度疾病分别为-1.27、-0.53和-0.51 dB。
- |ΔMD|≥1 dB出现在早期疾病假阳性22%和假阴性26%、中度疾病假阳性14%和假阴性34%、重度疾病假阳性16%和假阴性51%时。
- 检查时长每增加1分钟产生的ΔMD在-0.35至-0.40 dB之间。
关键数值与推荐
- 假阳性在异常捕获试验≤20%时,每10%增量对应的ΔMD:轻度0.42 dB、中度0.73 dB、重度0.66 dB。
- 假阳性在异常捕获试验>20%时,对应的ΔMD:轻度1.57 dB、中度2.06 dB、重度3.53 dB。
- 假阴性在异常捕获试验>20%时,每10%增量对应的ΔMD:轻度-1.27 dB、中度-0.53 dB、重度-0.51 dB。
- |ΔMD|≥1 dB对应的假阳性/假阴性比例:早期22%/26%、中度14%/34%、重度16%/51%。
- 检查时长每增加1分钟,ΔMD在-0.35至-0.40 dB之间。
临床怎么用
- 作者基于研究发现提出基于证据的、按严重程度分层的视野可靠性分级标准,用于临床或研究应用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Assess the impact of false-positives (FP), false-negatives (FN), fixation losses (FL), and test duration (TD) on visual field (VF) reliability at different stages of glaucoma severity. DESIGN: Retrospective. PARTICIPANTS: A total of 10 262 VFs from 1538 eyes of 909 subjects with suspect or manifest glaucoma and ≥5 VF examinations. METHODS: Predicted mean deviation (MD) was calculated with multilevel modeling of longitudinal data. Differences between predicted and observed MD (ΔMD) were calculated as a reliability measure. The impact of FP, FN, FL, and TD on ΔMD was assessed using multilevel modeling. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: ΔMD associated with a 10% increment in FP, FN, and FL, or a 1-minute increase in TD. RESULTS: FL had little impact on ΔMD (<0.2 decibels [dB] per 10% abnormal catch trials), and no level of FL produced ≥1 dB of ΔMD at any disease stage. FP yielded greater than expected MD, with a 10% increment in abnormal catch trials associated with a ΔMD = 0.42, 0.73, and 0.66 dB in mild (MD >-6 dB), moderate (-6 ≤MD <-12 dB), and severe (-12 ≤MD ≤-20 dB) disease, respectively, up to 20% abnormal catch trials, and a ΔMD = 1.57, 2.06, and 3.53 dB beyond 20% abnormal catch trials. FNs generally produced observed MDs below expected MDs. FN were minimally impactful up to 20% abnormal catch trials (ΔMD per 10% increment >-0.14 dB at all levels of severity). Beyond 20% abnormal catch trials, each 10% increment in abnormal catch trials was associated with a ΔMD = -1.27, -0.53, and -0.51 dB in mild, moderate, and severe disease, respectively. |ΔMD| ≥1 dB occurred with 22% FP and 26% FN in early, 14% FP and 34% FN in moderate, and 16% FP and 51% FN in severe disease. A 1-minute increment in TD produced ΔMDs between -0.35 and -0.40 dB. CONCLUSIONS: FL have little impact on reliability in patients with established glaucoma. FP, and to a lesser extent FNs and TD, significantly affect reliability. The impact of FP and FN varies with disease severity and over the range of abnormal catch trials. On the basis of our findings, we present evidence-based, severity-specific standards for classifying VF reliability for clinical or research applications.
引用
- Yohannan J, Wang J, Brown J, et al. Evidence-based Criteria for Assessment of Visual Field Reliability. Ophthalmology. 2017. PMID: 28676280. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2017.04.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。