文献速递神经眼科

基于MRI测量视神经蛛网膜下腔截面积两种方法的可重复性及比较研究

[Reproducibility and comparison study of two methods evaluating the optic nerve subarachnoid space sectional area using MRI].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi · 2017-01-01

横断面研究纳入10名健康志愿者(20只眼),于2016年3月至10月间隔1周行两次MRI扫描,比较优化方法与传统方法测量球后3、9、15 mm处视神经蛛网膜下腔截面积的优质图像获取率与可重复性。优化方法优质图像获取率更高,在球后9 mm和15 mm处所测截面积小于传统方法且差异有统计学意义,两次扫描间及两名测量者间的ICC均高于传统方法。

要点

  • 优化方法在球后3、9、15 mm的优质图像获取率分别为100%、83%、78%,高于传统方法的80%、78%、70%。
  • 优化方法所测球后3、9、15 mm截面积均小于传统方法,球后9 mm和15 mm处差异有统计学意义。
  • 优化方法两次扫描间及两名测量者间的ICC均高于传统方法。

核心结论

  • 优化的基于MRI测量视神经蛛网膜下腔间隙截面积的方法可以获得视神经的垂直截面,优质图像获取率高,测量视神经垂直截面的可重复性优于传统方法。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面研究,2016年3月至10月招募健康志愿者10名(20只眼),平均年龄43.8±13.1岁,男女比1∶1。
  • 对眼球后3、9、15 mm的垂直视神经截面行两次MRI扫描,间隔1周,每次扫描分别用新方法和传统方法获取图像。
  • 所得图像由两名经过培训的眼科医师进行后处理;优质图像获取率组间比较采用配对卡方检验,球后不同位置组间差异采用重复测量数据的方差分析,并计算类内相关系数(ICC)。

主要发现

  • 新方法在球后3、9、15 mm的优质图像获取率(100%,83%,78%)高于传统方法(80%,78%,70%),球后3 mm处差异有统计学意义(P=0.005)。
  • 新方法所测球后3、9、15 mm视神经蛛网膜下腔间隙截面积[(7.2±1.8)、(6.1±1.8)、(5.9±1.4)mm²]小于传统方法[(9.0±2.9)、(7.6±2.4)、(7.1±1.6)mm²],球后9 mm(F=4.30,P=0.048)和15 mm(F=5.67,P=0.026)处差异有统计学意义。
  • 新方法3个位置两次扫描间的ICC(0.879,0.857,0.857)高于传统方法(0.741,0.762,0.639)。
  • 新方法两测量者间的ICC(0.864,0.890,0.894)高于传统方法(0.785,0.609,0.753)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To optimize the method of acquiring the ONSAS parameter and to access the repeatability of the new method comparing with the traditional one. Methods: This is a cross-sectional study. Standard operation procedure of an optimized method of acquiring the ONSAS sectional area was made against the defect of the traditional method. Ten healthy volunteers (20 eyes) in different ages were recruited from March 2016 to October. Two times of MRI scan were proceeded with the interval of one week. The optimized and traditional methods were both applied for each scanning. The images were analyzed by two ophthalmologists. The rate of high quality images between two groups was compared with matching chi-square test. The orbital subarachnoid space areas between groups at different locations were compared using analysis of variance of repeated measurement data. The ICC between different scans and different ophthalmologists was calculated. Results: The mean age of the volunteers was 43.8±13.1 years old. Male/Female was 1∶1. The rates of high quality images from the optimized method (100%, 83%, 78%) was higher than those of the traditional method(80%, 78%, 70%). The orbital subarachnoid space area at 3 mm, 9 mm and 15 mm behind the eye ball acquired from the new method(7.2±1.8, 6.1±1.8, 5.9±1.4 mm(2)) were bigger than those of the traditional method (9.0±2.9, 7.6±2.4, 7.1±1.6 mm(2)). Statistical significances were found at 9 mm(F=4.30, P=0.048) and 15 mm(F=5.67, P=0.026) behind the eye ball. The ICC between two different scans (0.879, 0.857, 0.857 vs 0.741, 0.762, 0.639) and two different ophthalmologists (0.864, 0.890, 0.894 vs 0.785, 0.609, 0.753) were higher in the new method group than in the traditional method group. Conclusions: The optimized method of acquiring the parameters of optic nerve subarachnoid space is easier to get the sectional cross area. The measuring reproducibility is better than the traditional one. (Chin J Ophthalmol, 2017, 53: 440-444). 目的: 比较一种优化的基于MRI测量视神经蛛网膜下腔间隙截面积的方法(新方法)与传统方法的可重复性。 方法: 横断面研究。针对目前利用MRI检测视神经蛛网膜下腔间隙方法存在的不足进行优化,2016年3月至10月招募健康志愿者10名(20只眼),对眼球后3、9、15 mm的垂直视神经截面进行两次MRI扫描,间隔时间1周,每次扫描分别用新方法和已报道方法获得图像,所得图像由两名经过培训的眼科医师进行后处理。优质图像获取率的组间比较采用配对卡方检验,球后不同位置的组间差异采用重复测量数据的方差分析,分别计算两种方法两测量者间的类内相关系数(ICC)比较操作者间的重复性,计算测量者A两方法前后两次扫描所得结果的ICC比较时间重复性。 结果: 纳入的10名健康志愿者平均年龄(43.8±13.1)岁,男女比1∶1,新方法在球后3、9、15 mm的优质图像的获取率(100%,83%,78%)明显高于传统方法(80%,78%,70%),在球后3 mm处差异有统计学意义(P=0.005);将10名(20只眼)新方法和传统方法所得的不同位置视神经蛛网膜下腔间隙截面积进行比较,发现新方法所得结果[(7.2±1.8)、(6.1±1.8)、(5.9±1.4)mm(2)]比传统方法所得结果[(9.0±2.9)、(7.6± 2.4)、(7.1±1.6)mm(2)]小,在球后9 mm(F=4.30,P=0.048)和15 mm(F=5.67,P=0.026)处差异有统计学意义;新方法3个位置两次扫描间的ICC (0.879 ,0.857 ,0.857)高于传统方法(0.741 ,0.762 ,0.639 );新方法两测量者间的ICC (0.864 ,0.890 ,0.894)高于传统方法(0.785 ,0.609 ,0.753)。 结论: 优化的基于MRI测量视神经蛛网膜下腔间隙截面积的方法可以获得视神经的垂直截面,优质图像获取率高,测量视神经垂直截面的可重复性优于传统方法。(中华眼科杂志,2017,53:440-444).

来源:Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chen WW, Xie XB, Zuo ZT, et al. [Reproducibility and comparison study of two methods evaluating the optic nerve subarachnoid space sectional area using MRI]. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2017. PMID: 28606266. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0412-4081.2017.06.009

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。