文献速递青光眼神经眼科

青光眼视野指数与视野形态分期的关系及其诊断价值

[Relationship between visual field index and visual field morphological stages of glaucoma and their diagnostic value].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi · 2017-01-01

该回顾性系列病例研究纳入274例青光眼患者和100名正常对照,采用Humphrey视野计标准自动检查法将青光眼视野损伤按形态特征分为早期、中期、晚期和末期,分析各期平均缺损(MD)与视野指数(VFI)的分布特征,并用ROC曲线比较两者的分期诊断价值;结果显示各期MD和VFI分布相对集中,VFI的曲线下面积(AUC)大于MD(P<0.05),作者认为VFI稍优于MD。

要点

  • 青光眼视野损伤按形态特征可分为早期、中期、晚期和末期四期。
  • 各期MD分别为-2.83±2.00、-9.70±3.68、-18.46±2.90和-27.96±2.76 dB。
  • VFI的AUC为0.97,大于MD的AUC 0.91(P<0.05),作者认为VFI稍优于MD。

核心结论

  • 采用Humphrey视野计将青光眼视野损伤按形态特征分为早期、中期、晚期和末期是可行且合理的,各期MD和VFI分布相对集中,两者对分期诊断均有较高准确性,作者认为VFI稍优于MD,能更好地反映青光眼视野损伤的轻重程度。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性系列病例研究,纳入2014年3月至9月健康无眼病者100名(正常组)和青光眼患者274例(患者组),采用Humphrey视野计标准自动检查法检查。

主要发现

  • 正常组视野无特征性损伤,MD为-0.06±1.24 dB,VFI为99.15±0.76%。
  • 青光眼各期MD分别为早期-2.83±2.00 dB、中期-9.70±3.68 dB、晚期-18.46±2.90 dB、末期-27.96±2.76 dB。
  • 青光眼各期VFI分别为早期93.84±3.61%、中期75.16±10.85%、晚期49.36±11.26%、末期17.65±10.59%。
  • 正常组与患者组4期之间、MD和VFI各自任意两期之间差异均有统计学意义(MD:F=1 165.53,P<0.01;VFI:F=1 028.04,P<0.01)。
  • MD的AUC为0.91、标准误0.01、95%CI 0.89~0.94;VFI的AUC为0.97、标准误0.01、95%CI 0.94~0.10(原文如此);VFI的AUC大于MD的AUC(P<0.05)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 青光眼视野损伤按形态特征分为早期、中期、晚期和末期四期,各期MD分别为-2.83±2.00、-9.70±3.68、-18.46±2.90和-27.96±2.76 dB。
  • 各期VFI分别为93.84±3.61%、75.16±10.85%、49.36±11.26%和17.65±10.59%。
  • MD的AUC为0.91(标准误0.01,95%CI 0.89~0.94),VFI的AUC为0.97(标准误0.01,95%CI 0.94~0.10,原文如此),VFI的AUC大于MD的AUC(P<0.05)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为采用Humphrey视野计将青光眼视野损伤按形态特征分为早期、中期、晚期和末期是可行且合理的。
  • 作者认为MD和VFI对青光眼视野损伤分期诊断均有较高准确性,VFI稍优于MD,能更好地反映青光眼视野损伤的轻重程度。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To investigate the rationality of visual field morphological stages of glaucoma, its relationship with visual field index and their diagnostic value. Methods: Retrospective series case study. Two hundred and seventy-four glaucoma patients and 100 normal control received visual field examination by Humphrey perimeter using standard automatic perimetry (SAP) program from March 2014 to September 2014. Glaucoma patients were graded into four stages according to characteristic morphological damage of visual field, distribution of mean defect (MD) and visual field index (VFI) of each stage were plotted and receiver operation characteristic curve (ROC) was used to explore its correlation with MD and VFI. The diagnostic value of MD and VFI was also compared. For the comparison of general data of subjects, categorical variables were compared using χ(2) test, numerical variables were compared using F test. MD and VFI were compared using ANOVA among stages according to visual field, followed by multiple comparisons using LSD method. The correlation between MD and VFI and different stages according to visual field defined their diagnostic value, and compared using area under the curve (AUC) of ROC. Results: No characteristic visual field damage was found in normal control group, and MD and VFI was (-0.06±1.24) dB and (99.15±0.76)%, respectively. Glaucomatous visual field damage was graded into early, medium, late and end stage according to morphological characteristic. MD for each stage were (-2.83±2.00) dB, (-9.70±3.68) dB, (-18.46±2.90) dB, and (-27.96±2.76) dB, respectively. VFI for each stage were (93.84±3.61)%, (75.16±10.85)%, (49.36±11.26)% and (17.65±10.59)%, respectively. MD and VFI of each stage of glaucomatous group and normal control group were all significantly different (F=1 165.53 and P<0.01 for MD; F=1 028.04 and P<0.01 for VFI). AUC of ROC was A(MD)=0.91 and Se(MD)=0.01 (95% confident interval was 0.89-0.94) for MD, and A(VFI)=0.97, Se(VFI)=0.01 (95% confident interval was 0.94-0.10) for VFI. So, AUC(VFI)>AUC(MD) (P<0.05). Conclusions: It is feasible and rational of glaucomatous visual field damage to be graded into early, medium, late and end stage using Humphrey perimeter. Distribution of MD and VFI for each stage was relatively concentrative. Both MD and VFI were useful for grading glaucomatous visual field damage with preference for VFI. (Chin J Ophthalmol, 2017, 53: 92-97). 目的: 探讨青光眼视野指数与视野损伤形态分期的关系及其合理性以及视野指数分期诊断的临床价值。 方法: 回顾性系列病例研究。采用Humphrey视野计标准自动检查法,选取2014年3月至9月健康无眼病者100名(正常组)和青光眼患者274例(患者组),患者组依据视野损伤形态特征分为4期,分别观察各组视野平均缺损和视野指数的数据分布特征,采用受试者特性工作曲线(ROC)方法分析视野形态分期与视野指数的匹配关系,并比较两个视野指标的分期诊断价值。对各组受试者一般情况基本数据进行比较,计数资料用χ(2)检验,计量资料用方差分析;各组之间视野平均缺损和视野指数差异的检验均用方差分析检验,多重比较用最小显著差数法;两个视野指数与视野各组之间的关系即视野指数分期诊断性能的评价,采用ROC的分析方法,两个视野指标分期诊断性能的比较,采用曲线下面积(AUC)的比较方法。 结果: 正常组视野无特征性损伤,相应的平均缺损和视野指数分别为平均缺损=(-0.06±1.24)dB,视野指数=(99.15±0.76)%;青光眼视野损伤按照形态特征分为早期、中期、晚期和末期,各期相应的平均缺损分别为平均缺损(早期)=(-2.83±2.00)dB、平均缺损(中期)=(-9.70±3.68)dB、平均缺损(晚期)=(-18.46±2.90)dB、平均缺损(末期)=(-27.96±2.76)dB,视野指数分别为视野指数(早期)=(93.84±3.61)%、视野指数(中期)=(75.16±10.85)%、视野指数(晚期)=(49.36±11.26)%、视野指数(末期)=(17.65±10.59)%;正常组与患者组4期之间、视野平均缺损和视野指数各自任意两期之间,差异均有统计学意义(对平均缺损F=1 165.53,P<0.01;对视野指数F=1 028.04,P<0.01)。平均缺损的ROC的AUC为A(MD)=0.91、标准误为Se(平均缺损)=0.01,视野指数的ROC曲线下面积为A(视野指数)=0.97、标准误为Se(视野指数)=0.01;两个面积的95%可信区间(95%CI)分别为95%CI(平均缺损)=0.89~0.94、95%CI(视野指数)=0.94~0.10,两相比较为A(视野指数)>A(平均缺损)(P<0.05)。 结论: Humphrey视野计青光眼视野损伤形态的临床分期可以分为早期、中期、晚期和末期,各期平均缺损和视野指数的数据分布对于青光眼视野损伤的分期诊断均有较高的准确性,同时视野指数稍优于平均缺损,能够更好地反映青光眼视野损伤的轻重程度。(中华眼科杂志,2017,53:92-97).

来源:Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hou XR, Qin JY, Ren ZQ, et al. [Relationship between visual field index and visual field morphological stages of glaucoma and their diagnostic value]. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2017. PMID: 28260358. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.0412-4081.2017.02.005

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。