白内障盲与服务的不平等:超越社会地位的单维分析
研究利用巴基斯坦(2001-2004年,n=16507)和尼日利亚(2005-2007年,n=13591)的全国盲症横断面调查数据,按性别、居住地、识字情况三个社会变量构建八个亚组,分析白内障盲、白内障手术覆盖率(CSC)和有效白内障手术覆盖率(eCSC)的社会分布。结果显示弱势亚组白内障盲患病率更高、CSC和eCSC更低,eCSC的相对不平等约为CSC的两倍,且每增加一个弱势维度结局进一步恶化。
要点
- 弱势亚组在两国均呈现更高的白内障盲患病率、更低的CSC和eCSC。
- eCSC的相对不平等约为CSC的两倍(巴基斯坦:eCSC RR 2.7 vs CSC RR 1.3;尼日利亚:eCSC RR 8.7 vs CSC RR 4.1)。
- 每增加一个弱势维度,所有结局均进一步恶化;不识字农村女性在两国均表现最差。
核心结论
- 每增加一层社会弱势,各结局倾向于更差;不识字农村女性在两国均表现最差。
- 超越社会地位的单维分析可识别最需要干预的亚组,从而对白内障盲的不平等分布作出更细致的应对。
研究设计与样本
- 利用巴基斯坦(2001-2004年;n=16507)和尼日利亚(2005-2007年;n=13591)的全国盲症横断面调查数据。
- 三个二分社会变量(性别:男/女;居住地:城市/农村;识字:识字/不识字)构建八个亚组,并预先选定弱势亚组(女性、农村居民、不识字者)。
- 在每个数据集中分析白内障盲、CSC和eCSC的社会分布,采用率差和率比(RR)比较最优与最差亚组,并用逻辑回归评估多重弱势的累积效应。
主要发现
- 弱势亚组在两国均呈现更高的白内障盲患病率、更低的CSC和更低的eCSC。
- CSC和eCSC存在社会梯度,覆盖率随社会地位改善而升高。
- eCSC的相对不平等约为CSC的两倍(巴基斯坦:eCSC RR 2.7 vs CSC RR 1.3;尼日利亚:eCSC RR 8.7 vs CSC RR 4.1)。
- 所有结局均观察到累积弱势,每增加一个弱势维度结局进一步恶化。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Inequalities in cataract blindness are well known, but data are rarely disaggregated to explore the combined effects of a range of axes describing social disadvantage. We examined inequalities in cataract blindness and services at the intersection of three social axes. METHODS: Three dichotomous social variables (sex (male/female); place of residence (urban/rural); literacy (literate/illiterate)) from cross-sectional national blindness surveys in Pakistan (2001-2004; n=16 507) and Nigeria (2005-2007; n=13 591) were used to construct eight subgroups, with disadvantaged subgroups selected a priori (ie, women, rural dwellers, illiterate). In each data set, the social distribution of cataract blindness, cataract surgical coverage (CSC) and effective cataract surgical coverage (eCSC) were examined. Inequalities were assessed comparing the best-off and worst-off subgroups using rate differences and rate ratios (RRs). Logistic regression was used to assess cumulative effects of multiple disadvantage. RESULTS: Disadvantaged subgroups experienced higher prevalence of cataract blindness, lower CSC and lower eCSC in both countries. A social gradient was present for CSC and eCSC, with coverage increasing as social position improved. Relative inequality in eCSC was approximately twice as high as CSC (Pakistan: eCSC RR 2.7 vs CSC RR 1.3; Nigeria: eCSC RR 8.7 vs CSC RR 4.1). Cumulative disadvantage was observed for all outcomes, deteriorating further with each additional axis along which disadvantage was experienced. CONCLUSIONS: Each outcome tended to be worse with the addition of each layer of social disadvantage. Illiterate, rural women fared worst in both settings. Moving beyond unidimensional analyses of social position identified subgroups in most need; this permits a more nuanced response to addressing the inequitable distribution of cataract blindness.
引用
- Ramke J, Zwi AB, Lee AC, et al. Inequality in cataract blindness and services: moving beyond unidimensional analyses of social position. Br J Ophthalmol. 2017. PMID: 28228412. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2016-309691
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。