多学会立场声明:可复用眼科设备是否需要高水平消毒
美国及国外监管机构要求对接触眼表的可复用设备(如Goldmann压平眼压计头、前房角镜、激光镜)进行常规高水平消毒(HLD)。一个多学会工作组评估后认为,没有已发表证据表明这些设备传播威胁视力的感染,或HLD比低水平消毒更能减少感染传播。工作组同意大多数(88%)受访眼科医生的观点,即常规临床中不应要求HLD,仅在高风险情形下酌情考虑。
要点
- 无证据表明接触眼表的可复用设备传播威胁视力的感染。
- HLD相比低水平消毒未显示减少感染传播,且可能损害设备。
- 工作组同意88%受访眼科医生意见:常规临床不应要求HLD。
核心结论
- 工作组认为没有已发表证据表明接触眼表的可复用设备传播威胁视力的感染,或HLD比低水平消毒更能减少感染传播。
- 工作组同意大多数(88%)受访眼科医生的观点,即常规临床中不应要求对这些可复用设备进行HLD。
- HLD应仅在高风险情形下酌情考虑,例如在疑似感染患者使用这些设备后。
研究设计与样本
- 多学会工作组评估HLD必要性,并进行了包含1000余名眼科医生受访者的调查。
- 该论文呈现了经美国眼科学会董事会批准并由四个亚专业学会认可的立场声明摘要建议。
主要发现
- 工作组未发现已发表证据表明这些设备传播威胁视力的感染或HLD比低水平消毒更能减少感染传播。
- 常规使用化学HLD降低诊所效率、增加医疗成本和废物,并可能损坏设备表面而潜在影响患者护理。
- 调查中,Goldmann压平眼压计头最常见的再处理方法为酒精擦拭,诊断或激光镜为酒精擦拭或肥皂水清洗。
- 许多使用化学HLD的受访者报告了不良效应,包括眼表化学毒性和设备损坏。
- 尽管HLD使用不频繁,报告的感染传播极为罕见且通常限于自限性腺病毒性结膜炎。
关键数值与推荐
- 88%的受访眼科医生同意常规临床中不应要求对这些可复用设备进行HLD。
- HLD应作为高风险情形(如疑似感染患者使用后)下的酌情考虑。
临床怎么用
- 常规临床中,对Goldmann压平眼压计头、前房角镜、激光镜等接触眼表的可复用设备不要求HLD。
- 可采用酒精擦拭(压平眼压计头)或酒精擦拭/肥皂水清洗(诊断或激光镜)等低水平消毒方法。
- 仅在疑似感染患者使用设备后等高风险情形下酌情考虑HLD。
局限性
- 原文未报告
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Regulatory agencies in the United States and abroad are increasingly citing clinics and surgical facilities for what they deem to be inadequate disinfection of Goldmann applanation tonometry (GAT) tips, gonioscopy lenses, laser lenses, and other reusable clinic devices that contact the ocular surface. These regulators require routine high-level disinfection (HLD) of these reusable devices to prevent infection transmission. A multisociety task force formed to assess the necessity of HLD found no published evidence that these devices transmit sight-threatening infections or that HLD reduces infection transmission compared with lower-level disinfection methods. Meanwhile, routine use of chemical HLD reduces clinic efficiency, increases healthcare costs and waste, and may damage device surfaces potentially affecting patient care. Underlying these mandates for HLD is the nearly century-old Spaulding classification system, which inappropriately groups the ocular surface with heavily contaminated mucous membranes. A task force survey with more than 1000 ophthalmologist respondents found that the most common reprocessing methods were alcohol wiping for GAT tips and either alcohol wiping or soap and water for diagnostic or laser lenses. Many respondents using chemical HLD reported adverse effects, including ocular surface chemical toxicity and device damage. Despite infrequent use of HLD, reported infection transmission was exceedingly rare and generally limited to self-limited adenoviral conjunctivitis. The task force agreed with the majority (88%) of ophthalmologists surveyed that HLD should not be required for these reusable devices in routine clinical care. Instead, HLD should be a discretionary consideration in higher-risk circumstances, such as following use of these devices in patients with suspected infection. This paper presents the summary recommendations of a policy statement approved by the American Academy of Ophthalmology Board of Trustees and endorsed by four subspecialty societies.
引用
- Kuo IC, Chang DF, Schein OD, et al. Assessment of the Necessity for High-Level Disinfection (HLD) of Reusable Ophthalmic Devices: A Multisociety Position Paper. Ophthalmology. 2026. PMID: 42854853. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2026.10.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。