HOTV与Tumbling E视力测试在儿童视力筛查中的比较
这项横断面观察研究纳入995名3至15岁儿童,随机顺序使用HOTV和Tumbling E logMAR表测未矫正视力。HOTV平均视力优于Tumbling E,差异随年龄减小;在183名学龄前儿童中,HOTV转诊率更低、真阳性率和特异性更高。结论支持8岁以下儿童使用HOTV测试。
要点
- HOTV平均未矫正视力0.15 logMAR优于Tumbling E的0.20 logMAR(P<.001)。
- 两测试差异随年龄减小,8岁及以上降至1个字母以内。
- 学龄前儿童HOTV转诊率18.6%低于Tumbling E的31.2%。
核心结论
- 研究结果支持8岁以下儿童使用HOTV测试进行视力筛查。
- HOTV可减少不必要的转诊,尤其在全球重视儿童视力筛查和近视早期检测的背景下。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面观察研究,在中国上海开展,属于中国全国多中心队列研究的一部分。
- 995名3至15岁儿童完成HOTV和Tumbling E logMAR视力测试、睫状肌麻痹验光和全面眼科检查。
- 两种测试随机顺序进行,间隔30分钟休息以减少疲劳。
主要发现
- 总体平均(SD)未矫正视力:HOTV为0.15(0.22)(20/25),Tumbling E为0.20(0.20)(20/32),95%CI为-0.07至-0.02,P<.001。
- 两测试差异随年龄减小:3至<4岁 initially 1 logMAR行,<8岁超过3个字母,8岁及以上降至1个字母或更少。
- 183名学龄前儿童中,HOTV转诊率18.6%(n=34)低于Tumbling E的31.2%(n=57),平均差异-12.6%(95%CI,-19.2%至-5.9%;P<.001)。
- 学龄前儿童中HOTV真阳性率0.68高于Tumbling E的0.44(P<.001),特异性0.93高于0.79(P<.001)。
- 年龄较大儿童中两测试的转诊率、真阳性率和特异性相似。
关键数值与推荐
- 学龄前儿童HOTV转诊率18.6% vs Tumbling E 31.2%,平均差异-12.6%(95%CI,-19.2%至-5.9%;P<.001)。
- 学龄前儿童HOTV真阳性率0.68 vs 0.44(P<.001),特异性0.93 vs 0.79(P<.001)。
临床怎么用
- 对8岁以下儿童视力筛查优先选用HOTV测试,以降低不必要的转诊。
- 8岁及以上儿童两种测试筛查表现相似,可酌情选择。
- HOTV认知需求较低,更适合低龄儿童。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Accurate assessment of uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) is fundamental to pediatric vision screening. Although the HOTV letter-matching test is recommended for pediatric vision screening, the tumbling E test remains widely used globally despite its higher cognitive demands for young children. Evidence directly comparing UCVA outcomes between the 2 tests across pediatric age groups is limited. OBJECTIVE: To compare UCVA outcomes from HOTV and tumbling E vision tests and evaluate their suitability for pediatric vision screening. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In this cross-sectional observational study, each participant underwent UCVA testing with both HOTV and tumbling E logMAR charts in a randomized sequence, with a 30-minute rest period between tests to minimize fatigue. The study was conducted in Shanghai as part of a national multicenter cohort study in China. Participants included 995 children aged 3 to 15 years who completed both vision tests, cycloplegic refraction, and comprehensive ophthalmic examinations. These data were analyzed from January 2025 to June 2026. EXPOSURE: UCVA assessments using HOTV and tumbling E logMAR tests. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome was mean UCVA (logMAR). Secondary outcomes included referral rates for reduced UCVA, screening performance for amblyopia and refractive errors, testability, and time required for vision test. RESULTS: Overall, mean (SD) UCVA was 0.15 (0.22) (20/25) with HOTV and 0.20 (0.20) (20/32) with tumbling E (95% CI, -0.07 to -0.02; P < .001). The difference between the 2 tests decreased with age, initially 1 logMAR line in children aged 3 to younger than 4 years, more than 3 letters in those younger than 8 years, and reducing to 1 or less letters by age 8 years or older. Among 183 preschool children, HOTV test showed a lower referral rate (n = 34 [18.6%]) than tumbling E (n = 57 [31.2%]) (mean difference, -12.6%; 95% CI, -19.2% to -5.9%; P < .001), along with a higher true positive rate (0.68 vs 0.44; P < .001) and better specificity (0.93 vs 0.79; P < .001), with similar measures in older children. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: These findings support the use of the HOTV test for children younger than 8 years. Its use could reduce unnecessary referrals, especially in the context of growing global emphasis on pediatric vision screening and early detection of myopia. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT05770661.
引用
- Wu H, Wang Y, Ni Z, et al. HOTV Vision Test Compared With Tumbling E for Pediatric Vision Screening. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2026. PMID: 42658504. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2026.3425
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。