近视激光矫正术后无病史IOL度数计算:14种公式多中心回顾研究
本研究基于美国多中心数据库回顾分析3738只既往接受近视激光矫正(M-LVC)患眼的人工晶状体(IOL)度数计算准确性,比较14种公式。结果显示现代公式优于早期公式,联合后角膜曲率(PCC)的版本更佳;眼轴<23.5 mm或角膜曲率>43 D时在线现代公式(尤其K6、EVO 2.0)获益最大。
要点
- 现代公式优于早期公式,PCC版本优于非PCC版本,差异有统计学意义。
- 非PCC公式中K6与EVO 2.0的MAE最低(均为0.40 D)。
- 眼轴<23.5 mm或K>43 D时在线现代公式(K6、EVO 2.0)获益最大。
核心结论
- 在术后视力满意的M-LVC眼中,现代公式优于早期公式,且优先选择基于PCC的版本。
- 当眼轴<23.5 mm或K>43 D(占这些眼的22%)时,在线现代公式尤其K6和EVO 2.0较Barrett True K准确性提升最大。
- 在典型post-M-LVC眼中上述增益临床意义可忽略,无法获得完整生物测量时Shammas-Cooke是合理替代。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心回顾性数据库研究,评估IOL度数计算准确性。
- 纳入2017年10月2日至2025年8月20日美国多中心145名术者完成的3738只眼(3738例患者)。
- 使用Veracity数据库(Carl Zeiss),M-LVC眼依据术者报告病史识别,未独立核实。
- 采用IOLMaster 700行生物测量,术后21-90天测量主觉验光。
- 比较14种公式,主要结局为平均绝对误差(MAE)及±0.50 D、±1.00 D内比例。
主要发现
- 现代公式优于早期公式,PCC校正公式MAE低于非PCC对应公式(p<.0001)。
- 非PCC公式中K6与EVO 2.0(MAE均0.40 D)排名最佳,Shammas-Cooke(0.42 D)优于Barrett True K(0.45 D)、Haigis-L(0.48 D)、Hoffer QST(0.49 D)和Shammas-PL(0.57 D)。
- PCC公式中K6(0.37 D)、PEARL-DGS(0.38 D)、EVO 2.0(0.38 D)和Barrett True K(0.38 D)排名最佳。
- 陡角膜(43 D至<45 D及≥45 D)中,K6较Barrett True K的±0.50 D内比例分别提高8.4%和10.4%。
- 短眼(AL<23.5 mm)中K6的±0.50 D内比例提高>13%,MAE降低0.1 D。
关键数值与推荐
- 非PCC公式MAE:K6 0.40 D、EVO 2.0 0.40 D、Shammas-Cooke 0.42 D、Barrett True K 0.45 D、Haigis-L 0.48 D、Hoffer QST 0.49 D、Shammas-PL 0.57 D。
- PCC公式MAE:K6 0.37 D、PEARL-DGS 0.38 D、EVO 2.0 0.38 D、Barrett True K 0.38 D。
- PCC与非PCC对应公式MAE差异p<.0001。
- 陡角膜43 D至<45 D及≥45 D时K6较Barrett True K的±0.50 D内比例分别提高8.4%和10.4%。
- AL<23.5 mm时K6较Barrett True K的±0.50 D内比例提高>13%,MAE降低0.1 D。
临床怎么用
- post-M-LVC眼IOL计算优先选用现代公式及基于PCC的版本。
- 眼轴<23.5 mm或K>43 D时优先考虑在线现代公式(K6、EVO 2.0)。
- 典型post-M-LVC眼中上述公式间差异临床意义有限。
- 无法获得完整生物测量时可选Shammas-Cooke作为替代。
局限性
- M-LVC眼依据术者报告病史识别,未经独立核实。
- 为回顾性数据库研究,术后验光测量时间为21-90天。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To investigate intraocular lens (IOL) power formulas in eyes with prior myopic laser vision correction (M-LVC). DESIGN: Retrospective evaluation of IOL power calculation accuracy. SUBJECTS: The study included 3,738 eyes from 3,738 patients undergoing routine cataract surgery by 145 surgeons across multiple U.S. centers between October 2, 2017, and August 20, 2025. METHODS: Veracity database (Carl Zeiss) was used; M-LVC eyes were identified from surgeon-reported history without independent verification. Biometry was obtained with the IOLMaster 700, and subjective refraction was measured 21-90 days postoperatively. Refractive prediction errors were calculated for 14 formulas: early-generation formulas (Haigis-L and Shammas-PL), modern formulas with and without posterior corneal curvature (PCC) input (Barrett True K, Cooke K6 [K6], EVO 2.0, Hoffer QST, PEARL-DGS), Shammas-Cooke (without PCC), and Haigis-TK (with PCC). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Main outcome measures were mean absolute error (MAE) and proportions of eyes within ± 0.50 D and ± 1.00 D of target refraction. Formulas were ranked by MAE, and pairwise comparisons were conducted using heteroscedastic testing with Holm's correction. RESULTS: Modern formulas outperformed early-generation formulas, while PCC-adjusted formulas demonstrated lower MAEs than their non-PCC counterparts (p <.0001). Among non-PCC formulas, K6 and EVO 2.0 (both MAE 0.40 D) ranked best, while Shammas-Cooke (0.42 D) outperformed Barrett True K (0.45 D), Haigis-L (0.48 D), Hoffer QST (0.49 D), and Shammas-PL (0.57 D). Among PCC formulas, K6 (0.37 D), PEARL-DGS (0.38 D), EVO 2.0 (0.38 D), and Barrett True K (0.38 D) ranked best. Online modern formulas showed the greatest benefit in extreme eyes. In steep corneas (43 D to <45 D and ≥45 D), K6 increased the proportion within ± 0.50 D by 8.4 and 10.4%, respectively, compared with Barrett True K. In short eyes (AL <23.5 mm), K6 achieved >13% more eyes within ± 0.50 D and reduced MAE by 0.1 D. CONCLUSIONS: In eyes with satisfactory postoperative visual acuity, modern formulas outperform early-generation formulas, and PCC-based versions are preferable. With AL <23.5 or K >43 D (22% of these eyes), online modern formulas-particularly K6 and EVO 2.0-provided the greatest accuracy gain vs. Barrett True K. In typical post-M-LVC eyes, such gains are clinically negligible. When full biometry is unavailable, Shammas-Cooke is a reasonable alternative.
引用
- Cooke DL, Kaufmann CL, Englisch CN, et al. No-History IOL Power Calculation After Myopic Laser Vision Correction: A Multicenter Retrospective Database Study of 14 Formulas With and Without Posterior Corneal Curvature. Am J Ophthalmol. 2026. PMID: 42556630. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2026.07.059
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。