文献速递白内障与屈光手术

亚洲眼轴≥32.00mm眼内人工晶状体屈光度计算公式准确性比较

Accuracy of 8 Modern Intraocular Lens Power Calculation Formulas in Asian Eyes With Axial Length ≥ 32.00 mm.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Ophthalmol · 2026-05-23

该回顾性观察研究纳入330例眼轴≥32.00mm的亚洲白内障患眼,比较8种现代人工晶状体屈光度计算公式的预测准确性。主要分析组(眼轴32.00至<35.00mm,n=307)中Zhu-Lu的均方根绝对误差最低(0.562 D),Cooke K6次之(0.563 D);Cooke K6中位绝对误差最低(0.271 D)。超长眼轴组(眼轴≥35.00mm,n=23)中Zhu-Lu的均方根绝对误差最低(0.438 D)且±0.50 D内比例最高(78.26%)。综合多指标,Cooke K6、EVO、Pearl-DGS和Zhu-Lu在该人群中临床更可取。

要点

  • 眼轴32.00至<35.00mm时Zhu-Lu与Cooke K6的均方根绝对误差最低,分别为0.562 D和0.563 D。
  • Pearl-DGS在主要分析组±0.50 D内比例最高(75.24%),Zhu-Lu在±1.00 D内比例最高(93.49%)。
  • Hoffer QST在主要分析组误差指标最差,且在超长眼轴组随眼轴增加出现最大远视漂移。

核心结论

  • 在眼轴≥32.00mm的亚洲白内障患眼中,8种现代人工晶状体屈光度计算公式的预测准确性存在明显差异。
  • 综合多项准确性指标,Cooke K6、EVO、Pearl-DGS和Zhu-Lu是该特定人群临床更可取的选择,但各公式在不同终点上的相对优势不同。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性观察研究,比较人工晶状体屈光度计算公式。
  • 共纳入330例(330眼)眼轴≥32.00mm的亚洲白内障患者,排除既往眼部手术、威胁视力的角膜疾病或手术并发症者。
  • 评估8种公式:Barrett Universal II、Cooke K6、EVO 2.0、Hill-RBF 3.0、Kane、Pearl-DGS、Hoffer QST和Zhu-Lu。
  • 为使系统屈光偏差最小化,对每种公式和每种人工晶状体模型的预测误差进行算术调整,使平均预测误差归零。
  • 因Hill-RBF和Kane的眼轴输入上限为35.00mm,将屈光结果分为主要分析组(32.00mm≤眼轴<35.00mm,n=307)和超长眼轴组(眼轴≥35.00mm,n=23)分别分析。

主要发现

  • 主要分析组中Zhu-Lu的均方根绝对误差最低(0.562 D),Cooke K6紧随其后(0.563 D)。
  • 主要分析组中Cooke K6的中位绝对误差最低(0.271 D),EVO和Pearl-DGS均为0.272 D。
  • 主要分析组中Pearl-DGS的±0.50 D内比例最高(75.24%),Zhu-Lu的±1.00 D内比例最高(93.49%)。
  • 主要分析组中Hoffer QST的均方根绝对误差最高(0.682 D)、中位绝对误差最高(0.369 D)、±0.50 D内比例最低(61.89%)。
  • 超长眼轴组中Zhu-Lu的均方根绝对误差最低(0.438 D)、±0.50 D内比例最高(78.26%),Cooke K6的中位绝对误差最低(0.281 D);Hoffer QST随眼轴增加远视漂移最大。

关键数值与推荐

  • 主要分析组(32.00mm≤眼轴<35.00mm,n=307):Zhu-Lu均方根绝对误差0.562 D,Cooke K6为0.563 D。
  • 主要分析组:Cooke K6中位绝对误差0.271 D,EVO与Pearl-DGS均为0.272 D。
  • 主要分析组:Pearl-DGS±0.50 D内比例75.24%,Zhu-Lu±1.00 D内比例93.49%。
  • 主要分析组:Hoffer QST均方根绝对误差0.682 D、中位绝对误差0.369 D、±0.50 D内比例61.89%。
  • 超长眼轴组(眼轴≥35.00mm,n=23):Zhu-Lu均方根绝对误差0.438 D、±0.50 D内比例78.26%,Cooke K6中位绝对误差0.281 D。

临床怎么用

  • 对眼轴≥32.00mm的亚洲白内障患眼,可优先考虑Cooke K6、EVO、Pearl-DGS或Zhu-Lu进行人工晶状体屈光度计算。
  • 使用Hill-RBF 3.0或Kane时需注意其眼轴输入上限为35.00mm,超长眼轴患眼无法直接应用。
  • Hoffer QST在该人群中误差指标较差且随眼轴增加远视漂移最大,选择时应谨慎。

局限性

  • 本研究为回顾性观察设计。
  • 超长眼轴组(眼轴≥35.00mm)样本量仅23眼,结果解释需谨慎。
  • 因Hill-RBF和Kane的眼轴输入上限为35.00mm,超长眼轴组无法完整比较全部8种公式。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To compare the accuracy of 8 modern intraocular lens (IOL) power calculation formulas in Asian eyes with axial length (AL) ≥32.00 mm. DESIGN: Retrospective observational study to compare IOL power calculation formulas. SUBJECTS: A total of 330 eyes from 330 Asian cataract patients with AL ≥ 32.00 mm were included. Eyes with previous ocular surgery, vision-threatening corneal disease, or surgical complications were excluded. METHODS: The accuracy of eight formulas was evaluated: Barrett Universal II, Cooke K6, EVO 2.0, Hill-RBF 3.0, Kane, Pearl-DGS, Hoffer QST, and Zhu-Lu. To minimize systematic refractive bias, prediction error (PE) values were arithmetically adjusted to zero the mean PE for each formula and each IOL model. Due to the 35.00 mm AL input limit of Hill-RBF and Kane, refractive outcomes were analyzed separately in the Main Group (32.00 mm ≤ AL < 35.00 mm, n = 307) and Ultra-Long Group (AL ≥ 35.00 mm, n = 23). The correlation between PE and AL was also assessed. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Root mean square absolute error (RMSAE), median absolute error (MedAE), and percentages of eyes with prediction error within ±0.50 D. RESULTS: In the Main Group, Zhu-Lu showed the lowest RMSAE (0.562 D), with Cooke K6 ranking closely behind (0.563 D). Cooke K6 achieved the lowest MedAE (0.271 D), followed by EVO and Pearl-DGS (both 0.272 D). Pearl-DGS had the highest proportion of eyes within ±0.50 D (75.24%), whereas Zhu-Lu had the highest proportion within ±1.00 D (93.49%). Hoffer QST had the highest RMSAE (0.682 D), the highest MedAE (0.369 D), and the lowest proportion within ±0.50 D (61.89%). In the small Ultra-Long Group, Zhu-Lu yielded the lowest RMSAE (0.438 D) and the highest proportion within ±0.50 D (78.26%), whereas Cooke K6 had the lowest MedAE (0.281 D). Hoffer QST again showed the greatest hyperopic drift with increasing AL. CONCLUSIONS: In eyes with AL ≥ 32.00 mm, modern formulas showed distinct differences in predictive accuracy. Based on an integrated assessment across multiple accuracy metrics, Cooke K6, EVO, Pearl-DGS, and Zhu-Lu are clinically preferable options for this specific population, although their relative strengths differ across endpoints.

来源:Am J Ophthalmol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Xiang J, He W, Qi J, et al. Accuracy of 8 Modern Intraocular Lens Power Calculation Formulas in Asian Eyes With Axial Length ≥ 32.00 mm. Am J Ophthalmol. 2026. PMID: 42177933. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2026.05.026

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。