重度先天性上睑下垂修复:美国眼科学会报告
该报告由美国眼科学会基于截至2025年5月的PubMed文献,纳入11项研究(1项I级、1项II级、9项III级证据),评估儿童重度先天性上睑下垂(提上睑肌功能≤4 mm)术后效果。结果显示额肌瓣、额肌悬吊和最大提上睑肌切除术的成功率与暴露性角膜病变发生率存在重叠,额肌悬吊特有吊带感染、排出和肉芽肿风险,额肌瓣特有眼睑移位伴上转受限风险。证据等级和缺乏比较文献妨碍了等效性判断。
要点
- 儿童重度先天性上睑下垂(提上睑肌功能≤4 mm)的三种术式成功率与暴露率存在重叠。
- 额肌悬吊术报告了吊带感染、排出和肉芽肿等特有并发症。
- 额肌瓣术报告了眼睑移位伴上转受限的特有风险。
核心结论
- 额肌瓣、额肌悬吊和最大提上睑肌切除术在重度先天性上睑下垂修复中的成功率和暴露率存在重叠,但证据等级和缺乏比较文献妨碍了等效性评估。
- 手术风险可能影响术式选择,额肌相关技术各有独特风险,需长期多机构前瞻性比较研究进一步明确手术持久性和并发症率。
研究设计与样本
- 美国眼科学会报告,文献检索截至2025年5月在PubMed进行,初检209篇,全文审阅30篇,最终纳入11篇原创研究。
- 纳入标准为英文原创研究,至少25眼重度先天性上睑下垂(提上睑肌功能≤4 mm),术后随访至少6个月,包含详细术后数据。
- 证据等级:1项I级,1项II级,9项III级。
- 纳入研究涵盖额肌瓣、额肌悬吊和最大提上睑肌切除术,患儿年龄从婴儿至16岁,平均年龄范围在1-8岁。
主要发现
- 文献对成功、翻修手术和暴露性角膜病变的定义描述不一。
- 三种手术技术在成功、暴露和翻修方面存在显著重叠。
- 额肌悬吊研究显示疗效范围最广,并报告了吊带感染、排出和肉芽肿等手术特异性并发症。
- 额肌瓣相关技术报告了眼睑移位伴上转受限的风险。
关键数值与推荐
- 重度先天性上睑下垂定义为提上睑肌功能≤4 mm。
- 纳入研究要求至少25眼且术后随访至少6个月。
- 证据等级分布:I级1项,II级1项,III级9项。
临床怎么用
- 对于儿童重度先天性上睑下垂,额肌瓣、额肌悬吊和最大提上睑肌切除术均可考虑,但需权衡各自独特风险。
- 选择额肌悬吊时需警惕吊带感染、排出和肉芽肿风险。
- 选择额肌瓣时需注意眼睑移位伴上转受限的可能。
局限性
- 证据等级以III级为主,缺乏比较性文献,无法评估等效性数据。
- 文献对成功、翻修和暴露性角膜病变的定义不一致。
- 需要长期、多机构、前瞻性比较研究以进一步了解手术持久性和并发症率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To review the literature on the outcomes of severe congenital ptosis repair in the pediatric population and to assess the rates of exposure keratopathy and other complications. METHODS: A literature search was last conducted in May 2025 in the PubMed database. Articles were limited to original research in the English language that included detailed postoperative data on at least 25 eyelids with severe congenital ptosis (defined as levator function of 4 mm or less) after any given ptosis repair technique with at least 6 months of postoperative follow-up. The initial search identified 209 citations; 30 articles were reviewed in full text, and 11 articles were selected for inclusion in this assessment. The panel methodologist assigned a level of evidence rating to each of the included studies. RESULTS: One study was rated level I, 1 study was rated level II, and 9 studies were rated level III. The included studies examined frontalis flap, frontalis suspension, and maximal levator resection surgeries. They focused on a wide range of pediatric ages (infancy to 16 years), but the average age range in all cases was squarely in the younger pediatric demographic (ages 1-8 years). The literature demonstrated variable descriptions of success, revision surgery, and exposure keratopathy. Significant overlap in success, exposure, and revision exists for all 3 surgical techniques. Perhaps biased by the greater number of articles defining success, frontalis suspension surgery studies demonstrated the widest range of efficacy and had the additional surgery-specific complications of sling infections, extrusions, and granulomas. CONCLUSIONS: Although the level of evidence and dearth of comparative literature precluded evaluation of clear equivalency data, frontalis flaps, frontalis suspension, and maximal levator resection appear to have overlapping rates of success and rates of exposure. Risks of surgery may influence surgical choice. Frontalis-related techniques were associated with unique risks, including sling-specific inflammation, infection, and exposure; and flap-related lid displacement with supraduction. Long-term, multi-institutional, comparative prospective studies would allow further insight into surgical durability and complication rates. FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE(S): Proprietary or commercial disclosure may be found after the references.
引用
- Dagi Glass LR, Aakalu VK, Grob SR, et al. Severe Congenital Ptosis Repair: A Report by the American Academy of Ophthalmology. Ophthalmology. 2026. PMID: 42059847. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2026.03.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。