访视安排策略对青光眼手术研究估计成功率的影响
该研究评估不同访视管理策略如何影响基于眼压的青光眼手术成功率,对934只小梁切除术眼和1760只深巩膜切除术眼应用文献高眼压失败标准,采用六种访视管理策略计算Kaplan-Meier成功率,发现策略显著影响报告的成功率,且各策略下失败与成功组的视野进展速率分布存在大量重叠。
要点
- 访视管理策略显著影响青光眼手术研究报告的基于眼压的成功率。
- 最低眼压策略下5年成功率最高,所有访视眼压策略下最低。
- 各策略下失败与成功组的视野进展速率分布均存在大量重叠。
核心结论
- 访视管理策略影响报告的成功率,且所评估的方法均未在视野进展速率上实现清晰分离,凸显基于眼压阈值分类的固有局限性。
研究设计与样本
- 对两个队列分别包含934只和1760只接受小梁切除术和深巩膜切除术的眼应用文献基于高眼压的失败标准,中位随访分别为41.4个月和45.4个月。
- 将访视分组到基于指南的时间窗内,并对所有访视应用六种访视管理策略:平均、最低、最高、中位数和接近推荐时间点的眼压,计算每种策略的Kaplan-Meier成功率。
- 对小梁切除术队列中术后≥2年内有≥4次视野检查的患者进行视野分析。
主要发现
- 对于21 mm Hg阈值,5年成功率在最低眼压策略下最高(小梁切除术:54.8%;深巩膜切除术:74.5%),其次为接近眼压(小梁切除术:46.7%;深巩膜切除术:67.6%)、中位数(小梁切除术:46.9%;深巩膜切除术:69.1%)和平均眼压(小梁切除术:46.3%;深巩膜切除术:68.6%)。
- 峰值眼压(小梁切除术:39.3%;深巩膜切除术:60.4%)和所有访视眼压(小梁切除术:38.8%;深巩膜切除术:61.0%)策略下成功率较低。
- 在视野子集中,被分类为失败的眼光敏感度平均偏差进展显著快于被分类为成功的眼,尽管在每种策略下两组间平均偏差速率分布仍存在大量重叠。
关键数值与推荐
- 失败定义为眼压阈值、光感丧失、需要修正的低眼压或额外降眼压手术。
- 21 mm Hg阈值下,最低眼压策略5年成功率:小梁切除术54.8%,深巩膜切除术74.5%。
- 峰值眼压策略5年成功率:小梁切除术39.3%,深巩膜切除术60.4%。
- 所有访视眼压策略5年成功率:小梁切除术38.8%,深巩膜切除术61.0%。
临床怎么用
- 解读青光眼手术成功率研究时需考虑访视管理策略对结果的影响。
- 基于眼压阈值的失败分类与视野进展速率之间分离不清晰,临床决策应结合视野等功能指标。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To evaluate how different methods of managing multiple visits within predefined time windows affect intraocular pressure (IOP)-based success rates in glaucoma surgery studies. METHODS: We applied literature-based high IOP failure criteria to two cohorts of 934 and 1760 eyes undergoing trabeculectomy and deep sclerectomy (DS) with median follow-up of 41.4 months and 45.4 months, respectively. Failure was defined by IOP thresholds, loss of light perception, hypotony requiring revision or additional IOP-lowering surgery. Visits were grouped into guideline-based windows and six visit-managing strategies were applied to all visits, mean, lowest, highest, median and closest IOP to the recommended time point. We calculated Kaplan-Meier success rates for each visit-managing strategy. Visual field (VF) analysis was conducted on patients in the trabeculectomy cohort with ≥4 VFs in ≥2 years post-surgery. RESULTS: For the 21 mm Hg threshold, 5-year success was highest with the lowest IOP (trabeculectomy: 54.8%; DS: 74.5%), followed by closest IOP (trabeculectomy: 46.7%; DS: 67.6%), the median (trabeculectomy: 46.9%; DS: 69.1%) and mean IOP (trabeculectomy: 46.3%; DS: 68.6%). Success rates were lower with peak IOP (trabeculectomy: 39.3%; DS: 60.4%) and all visits IOP (trabeculectomy: 38.8%; DS: 61.0%). In the VF subset, eyes classified as failures demonstrated significantly faster mean deviation (MD) progression than those classified as successes although substantial overlap in the distribution of MD rates persisted between groups under every strategy. CONCLUSIONS: Visit-managing strategies influence reported success rates. None of the evaluated approaches achieved a clear separation in VF progression rates, underscoring the inherent limitations of IOP-threshold-based classifications.
引用
- Rabiolo A, Khaliliyeh D, Jin SW, et al. Impact of visit schedule on estimated success rates in glaucoma surgical studies. Br J Ophthalmol. 2026. PMID: 42055787. doi:10.1136/bjo-2025-329283
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。