等效球镜屈光度与眼轴长度在儿童近视监测及疾病风险估计中的比较:系统综述与荟萃分析
结果显示,绝对AL阈值可识别视网膜风险极高的极长眼少数人群,但SER更能反映多数患者所在近视范围内的白内障和原发性开角型青光眼风险梯度。作者建议将SER作为儿童近视控制监测的主要进展与风险指标,AL选择性用于监测眼轴增长较多的少数儿童。
要点
- 绝对AL阈值(如≥26 mm)仅适用于不足10%的眼,但可识别视网膜风险极高的极长眼少数人群。
- SER定义的近视与白内障和POAG风险增加相关,而AL定义的效果对白内障为无效或 modest。
- 建议SER作为儿童近视控制监测的主要进展与风险指标,AL选择性用于眼轴增长较多的少数儿童。
核心结论
- 绝对AL阈值可清晰识别视网膜风险极高的极长眼少数人群,但SER更能捕捉多数患者所达近视范围内的白内障和POAG风险梯度。
- SER应作为儿童近视控制监测的主要进展与风险指标,AL选择性用于监测眼轴增长较多的少数儿童。
研究设计与样本
- 报告AL和/或SER及人口学特征和/或视网膜、白内障或原发性开角型青光眼(POAG)结局。
- 当k≥3时采用Hartung-Knapp调整的随机效应荟萃分析,其他结果描述性合成;使用纽卡斯尔-渥太华量表评估偏倚风险,采用GRADE评估证据确定性。
主要发现
- 正常AL随年龄、性别、身高和种族强烈变化,而SER依赖性强得多。
- 视网膜病变随AL增长陡升(每+1 mm比值比[OR] 3.85),AL 26 mm相对于23.6 mm的风险比≈25(合并梯度),但该长眼阈值适用于<10%的眼。
- SER数据较少,但显示视网膜风险随每-1屈光度一致增加(OR≈1.5至1.8),高度近视OR 2至12。
- 白内障患病率方面,SER定义的中/高度近视核性白内障OR 3.09、后囊下白内障OR 4.58,而AL定义的效果为无效或 modest。
- POAG患病率方面,AL每+1 mm OR 1.37,SER定义的中/高度近视OR 2.95。
关键数值与推荐
- 视网膜病变:AL每+1 mm OR 3.85;AL 26 mm相对于23.6 mm风险比≈25(合并梯度),适用于<10%的眼。
- 视网膜病变:SER每-1屈光度OR≈1.5至1.8;高度近视OR 2至12。
- 白内障:SER定义的中/高度近视核性白内障OR 3.09,后囊下白内障OR 4.58;AL定义的效果无效或 modest。
- POAG:AL每+1 mm OR 1.37;SER定义的中/高度近视OR 2.95。
- 证据确定性:患病率分析为中等,发病率和描述性部分较低。
临床怎么用
- 在儿童近视控制监测中,优先使用SER作为进展和风险的主要指标。
- 对眼轴增长较多的少数儿童,选择性使用AL监测。
- 不应仅依赖固定AL阈值(如≥26 mm)来定义高风险,因为多数近视相关病变发生在未达该长度的眼。
局限性
- 证据确定性对发病率分析和描述性部分较低。
- SER数据报告频率低于AL数据。
- 纳入研究为观察性设计,可能存在偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
TOPIC: To determine the relative merits of spherical equivalent refraction (SER) vs axial length (AL) as the primary measure for monitoring childhood myopia progression and predicting adult myopia-related pathology. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Myopia prevalence is rising worldwide, but most patients only reach low-to-moderate myopia. Many guidelines emphasize AL over SER using fixed thresholds to define ``high risk'' (eg, ≥26 mm), yet a large proportion of myopia-related pathology occurs in eyes that never reach those lengths. METHODS: We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of population-based observational studies (≥200 eyes; PubMed and Embase searched from 1990 to July 2025) reporting AL and/or SER with demographics and/or retinal, cataract, or primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) outcomes. Random effects meta-analyses with Hartung-Knapp adjustment were performed when k ≥ 3; other results were synthesized descriptively. Risk of bias was assessed with the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale and certainty of evidence with Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation. RESULTS: Seventy studies met inclusion criteria. Normal AL varied strongly with age, sex, height, and ethnicity, whereas SER showed much weaker dependence. A small tail of emmetropes reached AL ≥26 mm. Retinal pathology rose steeply with longer AL (odds ratio [OR] 3.85 per +1 mm), implying risk ratio ≈25 at AL 26 mm relative to AL 23.6 mm (pooled gradient), but this long-eye threshold applied to <10% of eyes. SER data, although less frequent, showed consistent retinal risk increases with OR ≈1.5 to 1.8 per -1 diopter and OR 2 to 12 for high myopia. For cataract prevalence, SER-defined moderate/high myopia yielded ORs of 3.09 for nuclear and 4.58 for posterior subcapsular cataract, whereas AL-defined effects were null or modest. For POAG prevalence, AL per +1 mm showed OR 1.37, whereas SER-defined moderate/high myopia showed OR 2.95. Certainty of evidence was moderate for prevalence analyses and lower for incidence and descriptive blocks. CONCLUSION: Absolute AL thresholds clearly identify a small tail of very long eyes at high retinal risk, but SER better captures cataract and POAG risk gradients across the myopic range that most patients will reach. SER should be the primary progression and risk metric for monitoring childhood myopia control, with AL used selectively to monitor the minority of children with greater axial elongation.
引用
- Clark RA, Wong RK. Spherical Equivalent Refraction Versus Axial Length for Monitoring Childhood Myopia and Estimating Disease Risk: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Am J Ophthalmol. 2026. PMID: 41825844. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2026.03.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。